Cookie Tier List
CommentsLast updated 2025-04-07 02:59:40 SGT
In an effort to secure myself literal brownie points with the grad students here in Hawaiʻi, I’ve taken to bringing baked goods to group meetings and morning coffee on a roughly monthly basis. Naturally, some recipes have worked better than others. These ratings should be taken with a pinch of salt since I’m a novice baker.
Year 1 (2022/2023)
- November 2022: Various quiches (no rating: not cookies)
I made two quiches (seaweed & feta, and leftover buttermilk prawn) for the Institute’s Halloween party, and a chorizo-and-potato quiche (essentially a Spanish tortilla but in quiche format) for a Thanksgiving potluck. These were basically fritatas encased in store-bought frozen pie shells, so I approached them more as cooking than baking projects, giving them constant attention rather than leaving them to cook for preset times, and did not follow any recipes.
- December 2022: Pineapple shortbread (B: ★★★☆☆)
I made pineapple jam from scratch based on the prescription of Rasa Malaysia's recipe for pineapple tarts, but used a shortbread recipe from King Arthur Flour to encase the jam. Overall mixed success. This was the first time I used the oven at my new apartment (gas rather than convection, with no built-in thermostat) for recipes with preset bake times, and the bottoms came out somewhat burnt, leading me to suspect that my oven ran hot. I received an oven thermometer as a Christmas gift (thanks, Chris!) and subsequent testing confirmed this suspicion — at the nominal 350°F setting, my oven runs at 450°F. Unfortunately this systematic calibration error is not linear; I’ve found that to produce an actual oven temperature of 350°F, the rotary dial must read about 300°F.
- January 2023: Rosemary and Olive Shortbread (A: ★★★★☆)
I followed a NYTimes recipe that I stumbled upon during a YouTube baking video binge. Overall, very well-received by the grad students. I also fed this to some older friends at a Chinese New Year gathering. Unfortunately, this recipe does not scale down well. Compared to those of the nominal size recommended by the recipe, the smaller, thinner cookies of a second batch that I made tended to be far less tender, with almost the consistency of (admittedly very tasty) ear biscuits/耳朵饼; this might however just be my fault in making them too thin. Many of the comments on the NYTimes page suggest alterations using more salt, black pepper, cheese, etc. to produce a savoury product for pairing with cheese boards, which might be worth exploring. Final product was far less rich than the King Arthur shortbread recipe above. Would make again, perhaps for some kind of holiday potluck.
- February 2023: Gochujang Caramel Cookies (S: ★★★★★)
Another NYTimes recipe; remarkably, this is one of the very few I have seen with a unanimous 5-star rating on that site. Recipe was simple to follow, although (lacking the recommended ice-cream scoop) I had some difficulty portioning out cookies consistently. My final products ranged from smaller-than-average snickerdoodles to thin blobby cakes covering my entire small sheet pan. Fortunately, I got better at eyeballing an appropriate portion size by the third batch, although at this point I had already used up more than half of the available dough. Quality of final product also fortunately did not suffer from absence of vanilla extract (which I did not have on hand, and for which I substituted a small amount of flavoured soju). This was very well-received by the grad students, albeit with some confusion about, and difficulty in identifying, the “mystery” spicy ingredient. Would absolutely make again for social gatherings.
- March 2023: Various things in pie shells (no rating: not cookies)
I made an asparagus, mushroom, and cotija quiche, for the occasion of the visit of prospective graduate students1 to the Institute, since I was informed that there was no budget to pay for any breakfast for any of their visit days (besides snacky things like granola bars). Unfortunately, about half of the quiche got eaten by the grad students and faculty…
I also made an open-faced blueberry pie for π day! While I like blueberries, and I like pie, and I was certain that I would therefore like a blueberry pie, I ended up being largely disappointed by my own creation. I imagine that a covered pie would have worked better.
- April 2023: Li Hing Mui Pineapple Upside-Down Cake (no rating: not cookies)
I plopped a bunch of canned pineapple into the bottom of my skillet, poured pineapple-juice cake batter over it, baked it off for 40 minutes, and sprinkled li hing mui powder over the top after liberating it from the skillet when cooled (with the assistance of an offset spatula). Not as low-effort as I had initially hoped, and the ratios were a bit off (7 slices of pineapple is a bit too scanty for 3 eggs' worth of batter; could have been more aggressive with the li hing mui). However, was pretty well-received by the few grads who had not packed up and gone to Protostars and Planets VII, as well as the one emerita who showed up for morning coffee. Would make again for festive occasions.
- May 2023: Lemongrass Lime Shortbread (A: ★★★★☆)
I adapted this lemongrass cookie recipe to use the dough from the rosemary & olive shortbread that I had made in January, since that had turned out well the last time. I also added the juice of some calamansi limes that I had lying around to the sugar icing glaze. This was extremely well received by the grads, who felt it had a very sophisticated flavour, and by taste alone I think I would consider it S-tier.
However, the making of these cookies was surprisingly stressful, largely because I made some ingredient substitutions that seemed like a good idea at the time but turned out to be fairly ill-advised2. In particular, I had neither heavy cream (called for by the shortbread recipe) nor milk (for the icing glaze) on hand. I attempted to dilute Greek yoghurt as a substitute for both. While this worked reasonably well in the dough (albeit producing a texture that was more chewy than crumbly compared to the first time I had made a shortbread with this recipe), it failed miserably when I had to heat up the “milk” for the glaze, since the only thing this accomplished was to cook and clump up the yoghurt. This was in fact the whole reason for me trying a lime-juice glaze in the first place. Fortunately, that turned out to work well, and in any case I imagine lime juice and milk would not have played well.
Overall, would make again, but actually using heavy cream in the batter, and would perhaps steep the minced lemongrass in some hot water to spread out the flavour in the dough more evenly. I might also consider taking up Colby's offer of some fresh-grown lemongrass if I were to make this again, since the stuff I bought from Safeway was kind of gnarly.
- June 2023: Li Hing Mui Shortbread with Pineapple Jam (S: ★★★★★)
I made this cookie for a potluck party held in honour of our summer REU students. For this, I adapted the rosemary & olive shortbread recipe again, substituting chopped sour plums for the olives, and omitting the rosemary. I also prepared a pineapple jam with a spare can of pineapple slices that I had lying around. Unfortunately I started the jam going only at 8PM the night before, and didn't want to leave it going overnight, so it turned out a whole lot thinner than I would usually make it. Fortunately, this meant it was more easily spreadable on the cookies. I made two batches, with the first batch turning out not so well (I had cut the shortbread too thin); the second batch with 1cm slices turned out very much better. I served these with a generous dollop of pineapple jam on top of all of them.
On the whole, the response to these cookies was very bipolar. People who don't like li hing mui powder in the first place really didn't like this very much, and people who did found this a very sophisticated flavour combination. I really enjoyed them but would probably use less than a whole cup of chopped sour plum in future. I might also consider adding e.g. a little bit of chili flakes or other spice to the pineapple jam, which for this iteration I had served neat with no additives other than sugar and a little lime juice for pectin.
- July 2023: Gochujang Caramel Cookies (no rating: repeat)
Same recipe as in February, but I got better at portioning out the cookie batter. I tried out a suggestion from one of the NYTimes comments: I patted out the batter, left it to refrigerate, spread out the gochujang caramel, rolled it up, and cut the dough as if it were a shortbread. This produced an uncannily regular swirl, but also left holes in the cookies if there was too much caramel locally.
I made this as a morale booster for the Sunday morning before TASC VII, which the LOC spent assembling swag bags. Some of this made its way to an astronomer party the evening before, as a thank-you to our gracious hosts, Ben and Jen.
- August 2023: NO BAKED GOODS
I am travelling for essentially the whole month of August and won't be able to deliver food to the grads. Sorry guys!
Year 2 (2023/2024)
- November/December 2023: Green Curry Shortbread (A: ★★★★☆)
Thai green curry (kaeng khiao wan) is literally “sweet green curry”, and while the sweetness here refers to the colour, its preparation does indeed require substantial sweetening. I thought that this would also lend it to work well in cookie format, as with the other partially savoury cookies described above.
For my first test batch, I tried recycling the Rosemary and Olive Shortbread recipe from the NYT, except hydrating the dough using some leftover green curry that I had made instead of using heavy cream, substituting Thai basil instead of rosemary, omitting the olives, using lime instead of lemon zest, and using brown instead of granulated sugar. This was tasty, but did not come of as reading very strongly of green curry, primarily because the actual amount of curry in it was minuscule.
For my second test batch, I did the same, except that I used straight coconut cream to hydrate the dough, and also added extra green curry paste rather than omitting the olives altogether. I was happy with the improved flavour of this version. However, I didn't get a chance to present this improved recipe to the grads — I had by this point exhausted the batch of Thai basil that I had been using, and Foodland had itself run out of it by my next grocery order3.
- January 2024: Various quiches (no rating: not cookies)
I made a Spanish tortilla quiche (potato, spanish chorizo, onion, olive oil), and a ham and cheese quiche (with leek greens and chives) for Morning Coffee on two different days. I had to get these out of the way before the faculty candidates started arriving.
- February 2024: Black Sesame Cookies (A: ★★★★☆)
Finally, a faculty candidate who I have no personal connection to!
I made these black sesame shortbread cookies. This recipe stood out to me as being particularly compelling because it promised to be executable with only a single vessel (a food processor). Unfortunately, several mishaps occurred:
- I don't actually have a food processor; what I do have on hand is an immersion blender with a food processor attachment. Since I mostly use the immersion blender for immersion blending, this was the first time I had actually used the food processor add-on, and, not anticipating how razor-sharp the blades were, I sliced my finger on contact while setting it up. This is extra sad given that, after this first use on black sesame seeds, I can verify that the blades of the attachment are no longer sharp enough to slice my finger on contact.
- Owing to a hurried misreading of labels, I added only half the required amount of butter… I only realised this later in the evening (having prepared the dough in the morning, and having spent an inordinate amount of time wrestling the crumbly mess into a log shape that I could wrap in clingfilm).
Despite these issues, the cookies turned out quite well! The recipe appears incredibly robust to have turned out as tasty as it did given my deviations from it. The cookies disappeared before morning coffee ended (I was not even able to save one for my officemate, who normally shows up later in the day). Would absolutely make again.
- March 2024: NO BAKED GOODS
Fell ill and didn't have time to bake.
- April 2024: Various quiches (no rating: not cookies)
I like Peruvian food before visiting Peru — the usual hits like ceviche, chaufa, lomo saltado, papas a la huancaina — but my opinion of it was not overwhelmingly positive. Having tried it in situ, I think I owe the Peruvians an apology. I also very much liked potatoes before this trip4, but every potato dish I've eaten since coming back has proven a disappointing shadow of its still-living Peruvian ancestors.
Anyway, potatoes aside, I also bought a vacuum-sealed pack of what the Cajamarcans call "mantecoso" cheese during a tour of a cheese factory (which, to my regret, I now realise that I can't really buy outside of Peru — I really should have gotten more), which I expended in two quiches for the grads. I made the first to celebrate the return of Fede from Italy: this was a vegetarian quiche with kimchi, green onions, olives and mushrooms. I made the second — an egg white quiche with homemade vegetable stock, potatoes, portuguese sausage, chives, and cilantro — as a treat for the second-year grads when they were giving practice talks for their research class (699-2).
- May 2024: Matcha Cookies (S: ★★★★★)
Since Eric Kim's NYT Gochujang Caramel Cookies worked out so well, I decided to try out another one of his NYT recipes, for Matcha Latte Cookies, although I guess without the boiled-milk frosting they're just Matcha Cookies. Hawaiʻi being Hawaiʻi, I wasn't able to get vanilla paste, but I was able to get my hands on the last tin of Ito En Culinary Matcha at Don Quijote. I also substituted the peanut butter with (in my opinion) a far surperior toasted macademia-nut butter. I think this might be the most expensive baking project I've undertaken so far: the mac-nut butter by itself cost $16 for a small bottle, and the matcha cost another $16 for a [100\ \mathrm{g}] tin.
I really liked how the cookies turned out texturally, but I think the stated proportions are both a little too sweet for me, and don't have enough matcha flavour for my tastes — or this might be a problem with the Ito En stuff I am using. I think the sugar plays a structural role here, so I can't really cut down on it, but if I were to make this again for personal consumption, I would perhaps double the amount of matcha (although see further notes below). Logistically, this recipe was quite pleasing to execute: there were no surprises, and the batter yielded exactly 20 cookies as advertised. I might make a note when mixing the wet ingredients to add the butter last — creaming it by hand was a bit of a workout even at room temperature. Not having a #40 cookie-dough scoop myself, the NYT video tutorial was quite helpful in figuring out how large a ball to portion out with two spoons for each cookie.
I made these cookies as a sweet treat for the second-year grads for their actual 699-2 talks. These were overwhelmingly well-received — at least among the grads who liked matcha enough to want a cookie5. Also surprisingly, some of these matcha-consuming grads still found the matcha flavour a little overwhelming. Maybe there's something wrong with my tastebuds instead. Anyway, all 20 cookies went quickly even despite there being a hiatus on Morning Coffee — I wasn't even able to save any for Fede and Dhvanil. Would absolutely make again.
Update in June: I actually absolutely did make again, twice! These were both after I discovered a mystery bottle of vanilla extract in the IRTF kitchen, which I promptly borrowed to put to use for the public good. The second batch I made was in honour of the arrival of this summer's REU students, and the last was for a potluck for Singaporeans in Hawaiʻi. Both were extremely well-received! It turns out than one jar of macadamia-nut butter is good for roughly three batches of these cookies (with some left over for other culinary experiments), but I have a huge amount of matcha left over.
- June 2024: Various frozen desserts (No rating: not cookies)
In a bid to diversify from bringing only baked treats for the grads (sweet or otherwise), I decided to purchase an ice-cream maker. In the two weeks in which I have owned it I have already made four batches of desserts:
- Strawberry gochujang ice cream, after a Tom Scott Plus video. Learning lessons from the original video, I decided to omit the really spicy components (i.e. using only strawberry jam and gochujang). For the ice cream base, I used what seemed to be a fairly reliable NYT recipe. The grads mostly liked this, but some of them got a little weirded out.
- I turned Martinelli's apple cider into a sorbet/granita (straight up poured it directly into the freezer bowl), to bring to the IfA in honour of the grads' pride celebration. It turned out excellent! My lack of forward planning (only making it the same morning) worked in my favour; the sorbet was still fizzy when I served it at lunchtime. Easily one of my favourites in terms of reward-to-effort ratio.
- I flavoured one batch with lime zest and juice (3 limes), li hing mui powder, the flesh of half a kiwi, and some freshly grated nutmeg; I brought this one to group meeting, and shared the leftovers with random passers-by. This one went down really well!
- I made one last batch with a pureed mixture of 2 kiwis, 1 mango, a handful of grapes, and some li hing mui powder6. This was well received but rated less highly than the lime/nutmeg combination.
- July 2024: NO BAKED GOODS
I am on travel. Sorry guys!
- August 2024: Brown Butter Miso Chocolate Chip Cookies (S: ★★★★★)
I used a recipe that my partner recommended secondhand through an officemate of hers. I made these as a treat for Alexa and Chris, who worked extremely hard over this summer in providing the bulk of the actual labour for organising the REU program. The two of them got 12 cookies to share; of the rest, I ate one as a same-day treat, one for breakfast the next day, and brought the rest to the office to share with the group and random passers-by.
I baked these in two batches of 10, instead of 3 batches of 6. I portioned the first batch out without letting the batter rest in the fridge for 30 minutes as directed, which made it maybe a bit more liquidy and less manageable with only two spoons (I still don't have a cookie/ice cream scoop), but this did not affect the final baked texture adversely. The second batch, which I portioned after chilling, was a lot easier to manage. The miso flavour was subtle enough to add some funk to the cookies without being overly noticeable, and its saltiness interacted well with the brown butter. The cookies were soft and went well with melty chocolate. Another hit!
- September 2024: NO BAKED GOODS
I am travelling 3 out of 4 weeks this month. Sorry guys!7
Year 3 (2024/2025)
Didn't get a faculty job last year, so I guess I get to bake for the grads for one last year!
- October 2024: Pi Pa Gao (枇杷膏) ice cream (no rating: not cookies)
This is technically illegal in Malaysia. I poured half a bottle of Nin Jiom Pi Ba Gao (for the unfamiliar: a honey-based loquat-flavoured mixture traditionally used for treating coughs) into my ice cream maker as it was churning. The Chinese grads and faculty identified it immediately and mostly got the joke (they found it hilarious). Everyone else struggled to identify the flavour. Response was uniformly positive!
- November 2024: Chinese Hawthorne cookies (B: ★★★☆☆)
I crumbled haw flakes (山楂餠) into shortbread batter. This resulted in a shortbread with red planar streaks (I didn't manage to pulverise them completely), and the flavour of the haw flakes only very incompletely penetrated into the shortbread. If I were making again, I would probably food-process the haw flakes into a powder. Nonetheless, the incomplete incorporation resulted in an interesting textural and flavour contrast. However, I think 山楂 is not a commonly appreciated flavour around these parts — the grads didn't seem to like it all that much!
- December 2024: NO BAKED GOODS
I went home and then went to Taiwan and then did a job interview at Tsinghua and then went to the IAS. Too busy for baked goods!
- January 2025: Kuiche Pie Tee (no rating: not cookies)
In hindsight, this worked better as a visual pun than as an actual pun. I mixed steamed jicama, steamed carrot, shrimp, eggs, and onion, put the mixture into a pie shell, baked it off as usual, and garnished with cilantro. The joke is that it's like one giant kueh pie tee. I brought this to a Lunisolar New Year gathering with other Singaporeans the day before my job talk at the CfA, since I figured this would be more appropriate to share there than with the IfA grads. Very well received! If I were to change anything, I might have served with chili sauce on the side, and maybe used crabmeat instead of shrimp.
- February 2025: Pi Pa (枇杷) ice cream (no rating: not cookies)
I bought some dried 枇杷 while I was in Taiwan, and decided to incorporate that into an ice cream to see whether the grads would enjoy it more than my last attempt if the 枇杷 had some texture to it. I chopped it up into roughly 1/2-centimeter cubes, and added some black sesame as well for additional texture. It worked a treat! I split what I made into four batches and brought them to morning coffee and two different group meetings (as well as reserving the last quarter for myself).
- March 2025: Breakfast quiche (no rating: not cookies)
I was intending to make a tomato pie in honour of π day. However, the grads talked me out of it, so for π day I made them a quiche with italian sausage, maitake, tomatoes, and cream cheese instead. This unfortunately also sparked a debate as to what precisely constituted a pie. I have no horse in this race but my opinion is that the presence of tomatoes would technically still make this a fruit pie.
-
delightfully, by IfA tradition, the prospective graduate students are called “protograds”! I suspect this might be too much of an astronomy in-joke for general consumption, though. ↩
-
story of my life ↩
-
a recurring Hawaiʻi problem… ↩
-
boil 'em, mash 'em, stick 'em in a stew ↩
-
Apparently matcha is a polarising enough flavour that some other grads refused a cookie outright. I think is the first time this has happened for any cookies I've made. ↩
-
I am amused that the ingredients spell out KPMG (P for plum) and I'm calling it that when describing it to the grads. ↩
-
However, while at the NASA Hubble Fellow Symposium this year, I gave an informal talk about these cookies and how they were received by the grads! Slides here. ↩