Why Not Wayland
CommentsLast updated 2025-09-08 12:46:38 SGT
Every couple of years, I make a good faith effort to swallow the frog and switch from X11 to Wayland, even despite the lack of feature parity. This time around was the closest I've come to switching for good — hyprland is excellent — but there remain multiple dealbreaking bugs with applications that I have no choice but to use for work.
Slack Desktop, however shiny, is an electron app under the hood. On the X11 Ozone driver (default) running on Xwayland, fractional scaling is broken. On the Wayland Ozone driver, user XCompose files are not supported. I rely heavily on my XCompose file for things like typing maths symbols — this is all the more important here since I use Slack for work!
Zoom screen sharing is utterly broken on Wayland. I have never gotten screen sharing to work without using Xwayland (where, as above, fractional scaling is not applied). Even when using Xwayland, the meeting control toolbar has a nasty tendency to disappear in the middle of screen sharing. Whenever this happens, I'm locked out of stopping sharing/leaving the meeting for a couple minutes until Zoom spontaneously decides that it's done screen sharing and returns control to me. Also, screen sharing still occasionally doesn't work on Xwayland anyway, for reasons that are not transparent to me (or logged when running Zoom from the terminal). Also, transient dialogues (such as configuration menus) can't be reliably accessed even when using XWayland when the meeting window doesn't take up the whole screen — which defeats the purpose of using a TWM.
primary selection is still broken. They may consider this a feature, not a bug. I consider this a dealbreaking regression by design.
This still doesn't include things I'm salty about like the loss of x2x, bugs in IMEs like ibus outside of GNOME (in hyprland, modifier keys getting stuck after switching workspaces), general death of developer communities around nice things like hypr, and other second-order effects caused by the Wayland migration. I predict I'll be staying on X11 for quite a while yet.