We independently evaluate all of our recommendations. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

The 10 Best Fire Pits for a Toasty Outdoor Hangout

Take your backyard party game to the next level.

A fire inside the Necessories Grand 48 x 12 Inch Round Concrete Beechwood Fire Pit
Photo:

Better Homes & Gardens

Fire pits make great places to gather as the weather cools down and the sun sets at the end of a long day (maybe with some drinks and s’mores, too). When shopping for a fire pit, you’ll find there are plenty of options—including propane or wood-burning, large bowl or small, smokeless or not—and you’re left with a lot of choices. So how do you find the best fire pit for you? 

Ryan Cunningham, outdoor expert and founder of the website Beyond The Tent, breaks down the options. “If you will be using the fire pit in your backyard mainly, I would opt for wood or a 20-pound propane tank. If you will be taking it car camping, then a fire pit that runs off a 16-ounce propane tank is an ideal choice."

Plan out where you want to place your fire pit ahead of time, because that will help determine certain key details like the size you’ll need and possibly even the fuel type. With all of that in mind, we tested 18 fire pits and researched other popular choices.

What We Tested

We tested wood-burning, propane, and smokeless options in our own backyards, evaluating them based on performance, size, material, fuel type, and additional features. For more on how we tested fire pits, see our testing process below.

Why You Should Get It
  • This propane-powered, smokeless, and easy-to-use fire pit gives off a great amount of heat. Plus, it’s easy to control and takes less than two minutes to light.

Keep in Mind
  • The propane hose could be longer to keep the tank out of sight, and it would be even better if the flame went a little higher.

The Outland Living Firebowl 883 Mega is a great pick, striking the right balance of performance, budget, size, and looks, which is why it’s our top pick for the best fire pit. We love how incredibly easy this fire pit is to set up and use.

It arrives pretty much assembled, all you need to do is add the lava rocks and hook it up to a propane tank, which took us around five minutes. Once assembled, it took us less than two minutes to start the fire, which is easily controllable with a knob that adjusts the height and intensity of the flame.

This was particularly appreciated while roasting marshmallows as we could turn down the flame to ensure we didn’t end up with a burnt mess. Although we’d like it if the flame could go a little higher for those really chilly nights, the fire pit gives off plenty of heat. We could still feel the warmth on our faces sitting 3.5 feet away.

We were incredibly impressed during our tests that this model seems to be truly smokeless. We found this especially helpful when there was a breeze, and no one needed to reposition their chair to avoid plumes of smoke—there really is no excuse not to sit out by the fire!

As this is a propane model, there was no ash produced, and the only residue we found in the fire pit was from adding the lava rocks. This fire pit also appears incredibly durable. After testing, the only wear we found were just a couple of small scratches in the bottom from initially adding the lava rocks, and some of the rocks were discolored from the heat.

One small improvement we’d like is a longer propane connector so the attached gas tank could stay completely out of sight while using the fire pit, but it’s not at all a deal breaker. Weighing 34 pounds, this isn’t the lightest fire pit on our list, but two people could move it easily. The only accessories available are the Mega carry bag for easier transportation and a natural gas conversion kit.

Overall, we’re impressed with the Outland Living Firebowl 883 Mega fire pit. It’s easy to set up and use, gives out an impressive amount of heat to warm up to eight people, and has a flame you can control. Plus, it’s completely smokeless, which is a huge bonus.

How It Performed After Six Months

The Outland fire pit is incredibly easy to use and requires basically no maintenance. We love the included protective cover that allows us to leave it outside no matter the weather. While we noticed no change in the performance of the fire pit, we should note that the rocks did become discolored the more we used it.

Product Details: Dimensions: 24 x 13 x 24 inches | Fuel type: Propane | Material: Steel

Why You Should Get It
  • This is an ideal option if you are comfortable with open firewood burning and want to enhance your outdoor aesthetic.

Keep in Mind
  • The copper stained pretty quickly during two weeks of use. Plus, the fire pit itself requires two people to move.

If you are looking for a wood-burning fire pit that’s less expensive than other options, we recommend the Better Homes & Gardens Wood Burning Copper Fire Pit. It has a sleek appearance that will add to your outdoor decor. Along with solid durability and noticeable weather resistance, it hit the marks of what we look for in outdoor equipment. 

This model weighs just under 27 pounds and during testing, we noted that it needed two people to move it comfortably.  Once set up, we ignited the fire using a small amount of wood, paper, and cardboard. Overall, it was easy to get started without using any fuel or lighter fluid. 

The fire only emitted a noticeable amount of smoke, but only because our wood was damp. We noted that the fire provided a generous amount of warmth, even when seated about three feet away. When we made a larger fire, we could feel it at five feet away. 

After just three uses, this fire produced a moderate amount of ash, which we disposed of using an indoor fireplace brush and galvanized bucket. We had to tilt the fire pit to get any remaining ash. We also noted that the fire pit’s lid lifter wasn't quite as long as we would have preferred, requiring us to get a bit too close to the fire at times.

After two weeks of testing, we noticed ash stains accumulating on the copper. It didn't deter from the aesthetic appeal of the fire pit, as we still appreciated its durability and ease of use. However, the signs of aging were noticeable in a shorter period than we would have preferred.

Product Details: Dimensions: 30 x 30 x 22 inches | Fuel Type: Wood | Material: Copper

Why You Should Get It
  • It's easy to start and maintain the fire. Plus, the overall construction looks built-in, enhancing your backyard's appearance.

Keep in Mind
  • You will need to build this pit and it requires heavy lifting.

If you have ample room in your backyard, consider the Necessories' Grand Fire Pit. We loved the built-in look of the firepit and appreciated that it was easy to start and maintain the fire. 

Constructing this fire pit was somewhat involved, although we appreciated the smooth delivery. We did have to carry all the pieces to our backyard, however it didn't require any special equipment. Once we began to assemble, we needed to do some heavy lifting as the pit was made of stone. One block was chipped, but when putting the pit together, we positioned it so it wouldn't be visible. 

Getting the fire started was an easy process. We loved the thick stone walls, which made us comfortable to allow for pets and children to be around it. Plus, it gave the firepit a more permanent appearance in our backyard than something we would bring in and out only on occasion.

The fire pit produced a generous amount of heat all the way around. It also has a wide, deep ring that encourages good airflow and keeps the fire going. We could comfortably use our extendable forks to make s'mores without getting too close to the flames. 

Another feature we appreciated was that we could extinguish the fire when we were done instead of waiting for the flames to burn out. Aside from the ash appearing on some portion of things, the fire pit showed no signs of wear and tear or discoloration.

Product Details: Dimensions: 31 x 48 x 12 inches | Fuel Type: Wood | Material: Stone and concrete

Why You Should Get It
  • The attractive contemporary design, as well as its multi-functional purpose as a coffee table, makes this a great addition to your backyard.

Keep in Mind
  • This isn't the best option if you want a fire pit to roast marshmallows.

If you are looking for a fire pit that is built within a table, you'll love the Better Homes & Gardens River Oaks Gas Fire Pit Table. The square shape, black glass rock, and clean lines blend well with the hints of classic touches, like the embossed arabesque design on the walls. It will elevate your outside decor, giving you plenty of room to place a drink even while the fire pit is going.

Because of the sheer weight of this fire pit upon delivery, we had to unpack it and bring it inside piece by piece. It was far too heavy for us to transport it inside and into our backyard on our own.

Assembling it took us about an hour, even though the directions said only a half hour. This was in part because of unclear directions and labeling on all the pieces. Fortunately, everything inside was packaged nicely. There was also an issue with one of screws being stripped, so one of the legs were not properly supported. However, we haven't run into any issues with stability thus far. 

Once all put together, we used propane gas to get it started. There was only a slight gas smell when we turned it on, but that faded quickly. 

The fire pit emitted a lot of heat up to three and four feet away. Since the heating element is a circle, we could feel it all the way around. We did attempt at making marshmallows with this fire pit, but found it didn't burn hot enough like we have found with wood-burning fire pits.

Even though it was a windy day during our testing, the fire still remained lit and provided heat. On one side of the pit, there is also adjustable heat control which can adjust the flame size. It performed well and responded nicely to our adjustments. 

We appreciated that there wasn't extensive clean-up required, just place the lid back and cover up the pit once were finished. When not in use, we found this lid could easily convert the fire pit into a coffee table. We also loved the glass beads that came inside, adding an elegance and reflective aspect to the fire.

Product Details: Dimensions: 30 x 30 x 25.2 inches | Fuel Type: Propane | Material: Steel, tile, stainless steel, and glass

Why You Should Get It
  • The copper basin is extremely weather resistant and can be kept outside year-round.

Keep in Mind
  • It’s on the pricier side for a fire pit that isn’t smokeless.

We found this classic copper fire pit by Frontgate to be an all-around winner when it comes to performance, design, and value. If you have a spacious backyard or patio and love to entertain, this gorgeous wood-burning fire pit will be your best bet. The construction is part of the reason it's so pricey: Its heavy copper basin is made to handle both extreme heat and extreme weather, so you can keep it out all year long. 

It also features a sturdy iron grate that makes for a well-ventilated and thriving fire. The basin holds logs up to 2 feet long; we opted to use five logs during testing for a medium-sized fire, but felt like we could have easily fit twice as many. We like how the large size means it’s great for parties and entertaining; it can easily accommodate five or more people, with plenty of space for everyone. 

The setup took us mere minutes and required no tools, but it’s heavy enough that you’ll likely need to do it with two people. Finally, there’s an option to add a spark guard made of powder-coated iron if you have children or pets around, too. While we were impressed with this fire pit, it’s worth noting that it’s pretty expensive for one that is not considered smokeless.

How It Performed After 4 Months

Our favorite aspect of the fire pit is the size—we like that we can fit a larger amount of people around it and create a bigger fire. It held up really well for its first few months of use, but we would have appreciated an included cover for additional protection against the elements.

Product Details: Dimensions: 40 x 39.78 x 14 inches | Fuel Type: Wood | Material: Copper and iron

Better Homes & Gardens

Why You Should Get It
  • The stylish fire pit doubles as a table for drinks or snacks.

Keep in Mind
  • While easy, the setup was more time-consuming than other options we tested.

For those looking for a backyard fire pit without the hassle of wood, consider a propane-fueled model like this one from Hampton Bay. The unit doubles as a table to rest drinks or small snack plates on, and the antique design is stylish enough to live on your patio alongside existing patio furniture.

Setting up the fire pit for the first time took us just under 30 minutes, which was much longer than most of the other pits we tested. This is because many other pits were fully assembled straight out of the box, while this option requires assembly, including screwing the sides together. However, we found the setup easy to complete with detailed instructions and well-marked pieces. After assembling the fire pit, we connected our own 20-pound propane tank (which nests out of sight under the table), and it was ready to go. 

The initial setup time was worth it, since getting the fire started took no time at all; just remove the cover, open the propane tank, switch a knob, and push a button to light. It’s the perfect option for busy weeknights when you don’t have time to spend waiting for a fire to start. And when you’re ready to go back inside, turning off the fire is as simple as turning the knob off and closing the propane tank.

We appreciated the even heating on all sides of the pit, which we could feel up to three feet from the unit. While using the fire pit, we didn’t see or smell smoke, which we appreciated as no scent lingered on our clothes or in our hair. After turning off the fire pit and letting it cool, a lid slides over the lava rocks and heating unit to protect them and provide more table surface—a feature we found especially useful when the fire pit wasn’t in use.

How It Performed After 4 Months

This became our go-to fire pit because of ease—just turn it on and you have a fire, no prep or cleanup necessary. Because it's so quick, we found ourselves using it more and more often, sometimes even for just 10 minutes. We would have loved to see another option for the finish, but otherwise we have no complaints.

Product Details: Dimensions: 30 x 25 x 30 inches | Fuel Type: Propane | Material: Steel

Better Homes & Gardens

Why You Should Get It
  • This larger smokeless fire pit, perfect for a family or backyard party, can fit six large logs.

Keep in Mind
  • It burns logs pretty quickly, so you may need to reload it several times.

This Solo Stove model is over 6 inches wider and 6 inches taller in diameter than our best overall pick, making it great for longer burn times and larger gatherings. We especially liked the construction of this piece: Setup is quick and easy, and it features a ring on the bottom to protect the grass from the extreme heat below and a ring on the top to encourage ventilation.

It has all of the features that Solo Stove has become so well-known for: The two-walled construction traps air between the walls to burn up smoke before it reaches your hair and clothes, its durable stainless steel will handle the elements and the intense heat while remaining relatively light for the size of the model, and it can easily be cleaned with the removable ash pan. 

We could fit six large logs in the pit, but they did burn fairly quickly. We were impressed with how evenly the fire burned as well. Still, the biggest draw of the Solo Stove is that, when properly cleaned and maintained, it’s a relatively smokeless and smell-free fire pit

How It Performed After 4 Months

We continued to enjoy the smokeless aspect of the fire pit—it funnels any smoke it does produce upward instead of out—as well as the sleek design. It is a bit heavy, so we suggest having someone help you move it.

Product Details: Dimensions:
27 x 27 x 17 inches | Fuel Type: Wood | Material: Stainless steel

Better Homes & Gardens

Why You Should Get It
  • At only 6 inches tall, it fits just about anywhere, including small balconies and patios.

Keep in Mind
  • This fire pit is more for aesthetics than significant warmth due to the size.

The best option for someone who doesn’t have a backyard is definitely this Solo Stove Mesa option we tested, as it’s perfect for a small balcony or patio, given that it only stands 6 inches tall and takes up hardly any space. If you want a little ambience but don’t have a large area outside to sit in, it’s a great, affordable option that also comes in a bunch of interesting colors like deep olive, mulberry, and bone. 

While we don’t recommend relying on this fire pit alone for significant warmth due to the size, we were still impressed with the heat it created. You can use small pieces of firewood to make this work, but might be better off using wood pellets or Solo Stove’s own mini oak pieces since they won’t have to be cut down to size. It comes with a stand and a carry bag—and because the fire pit only weighs a little over a pound, it’s definitely an easy option to take anywhere and store in a closet. 

Best of all, the Solo Stove Mesa has all of the specs the larger sizes have, including the stainless steel, double-walled construction and smokeless design. You can even roast marshmallows with the flame, allowing you to have the experience of a real fire pit even if you live in an area with limited outdoor space. 

How It Performed After 3 Months

While we didn't get to use it too many times before the weather got cold, we continued to appreciate both the size and the amount of warmth it emits. A previous tabletop fire pit we used was just for aesthetics, so we really like being able to use one that actually keeps people cozy when gathered around on chilly nights.

Product Details: Dimensions: 6 x 6 x 6 inches | Fuel Type: Pellet, wood | Material: Stainless steel and ceramic

Better Homes & Gardens

Best for Camping

Outland Living Firecube

PHOTO: Amazon
Why You Should Get It
  • The propane fuel means you may be able to use it in places with fire bans (but check the rules of your campsite first).

Keep in Mind
  • This isn’t meant to be a cooking surface; it’s better used as an area to warm up at night and for ambiance.

If you’re camping, backpacking, or RVing this summer, this Outland Living Firecube is one of the best options to add to your gear list. At a little over 22 pounds and 14 inches in diameter, it’s both easy to store and to pack. 

It’s CSA-approved (which means it has passed a series of safety metrics) and uses a 20-pound propane tank cylinder (not included, but available at most hardware stores) rather than wood, which allows it to be used in places that have bans on campfires, although it’s best to check with your campsite before you go. 

The kit comes with a pre-attached 10-foot hose, an adjustable regulator with a knob to control flame size, a cover/carry kit, and over 4 pounds of lava rocks to create a more realistic and flickering fire. It delivers a clean, smokeless burn and works quietly and in inclement weather. 

While it’s not meant to cook on (besides s’mores or weenies on a stick, of course), there’s a reason we chose one that doesn’t have a grill grate: If you’re camping and are counting on fire as a means to cook your food, propane fire pits generally aren’t made to make elaborate meals for a number of people. They’re great for camping because they produce a more controlled burn, but you’re much better off getting a charcoal grill or a camp stove, in addition to a fire pit, if you want to cook food.

Instead, use this Firecube to provide warmth and a source of flame for nights under the stars. However, if you’re camping in a place that doesn’t have a campfire ban, and you’d rather grill on the pit, check out the option below.

Product Details: Dimensions:
14 x 14 x 9 inches | Fuel Type:  Propane | Material: Alloy steel

Why You Should Get It
  • The pole and grill plate allow you to better control the temperature for cooking meals.

Keep in Mind
  • It needs to be stored indoors between uses to prevent rust.

This Barebones Living Fire Pit & Grill is a master class in smart design: the bowl is used as the fire pit, and to make it a grill, you attach the included pole and the grill grate to the side of that bowl. During testing, we found this allowed us to move the grill grate up and down, depending on how much direct flame you’re looking to have on your food, and gave us added freedom to control the temperature of the food. 

If you’re an outdoors lover who wants to be able to have a backyard campout—complete with dinner and s’mores—at a moment’s notice, this could be the best choice for you. It’s absolutely beautiful and the fire burns evenly, but it's slightly tricky to control the temperature as you’re cooking, which is why the pole is such a brilliant add-on. If your flame gets too high, you can move your food up without worrying about burning it. 

The Barebones pit is 30 pounds and needs to be taken indoors after use so it won’t rust, but it does come equipped with built-in handles to make that task a bit easier. For the higher price, it’s not a smokeless option, but if you couldn’t imagine creating a campfire without cooking up a meal on it, then this fire pit is worth the investment. It’s truly the best of both worlds and functions well as both a grill and a fire pit. 

How It Performed After Three Months

There's no mistaking that this is a gorgeous fire pit—the design is stunning—but we think it's a bit too complicated and expensive (unless you're truly going to use the grill grate for cooking). That said, the aesthetics can't be beat, and if you're regularly grilling on open fire, you'll probably get use out of it.


Product Details: Dimensions:
23.75 x 23.75 x 8.15 inches | Fuel Type: Wood | Material: Steel

Better Homes & Gardens

The Bottom Line

If you’re using a fire pit in your backyard, you can’t beat the Outland Living Firebowl 883 Mega; it’s quick to light, easy to use, completely smokeless, good value for money, and gives off plenty of heat for six to eight people. If you’re looking for a wood-burning option, we like the Frontgate Classic Copper Fire Pit.

Our Testing Process

To find the best fire pits, we spent over 100 hours testing 45 different models across multiple tests in our own backyards. The fire pits we tested included wood-burning, propane-fueled, and smokeless varieties. Some also had cooking accessories.

We recorded a number of data points when testing each model, and used each fire pit at least three times for hour-long durations. We started with timing how long the setup took, recording how clear the instructions were and if we needed any tools from home to build them. 

For wood-burning stoves, we built a fire using firewood with an approximate length of 16 inches (if applicable), and according to the manufacturer’s instructions. In that hour-long burn time, we noted how easy the flame was to maintain, how even it was, and how smokeless it was. We also removed the ash after each use, and recorded the process and its ease. 

For propane fire pits, we tested every setting available and sat on each side of the pit during each setting. For all of the propane fire pits, we tested the usefulness of all included accessories and tested any noted design elements.

While testing, we took into account how many people could comfortably sit around the fire pit, how far the heat extended, how large and bright the flames burned, and how easy it was to cook food over the flame. After testing, we compared the results to determine which models performed the best.

Better Homes & Gardens

What to Know About Fire Pits Before Shopping

Size

The dimensions of a fire pit are generally only important if you’re looking for a very small or a very large fire pit. Smaller wood-burning models are generally under 30 inches in diameter (like our 27-inch smaller option), while smokeless options range between 20–30 inches. Propane fire pits are usually smaller in diameter, but the median range is generally 20 inches. And of course, tabletop fire pits are incredibly small, with many being 6 inches in height and in diameter.

Fire pits come in a range of sizes. Smaller wood-burning models are generally under 30 inches in diameter, while smokeless options range between 20–30 inches. Propane fire pits are usually smaller in diameter, but the median range is around 20 inches. A 20-inch fire pit should comfortably fit up to four people around it, while a 30-inch fire pit could seat up to 10 people. Tabletop fire pits are a lot smaller—most are 6 inches in height and diameter—and generally provide less heat than standalone models.

Material

Fire pits are made of a variety of materials, although steel, copper, and stone are the most common options. 

  • Steel: Many of the fire pits on our list were made of steel, such as Barebones Living Cowboy Fire Pit & Grill or the Outland Living Firecube 805. The material has numerous benefits, such as being resistant to heat and weather, as well as being strong and durable. You may find some variations in the type of steel, such as alloy steel (found in the Outland Living Firecube 805). This typically means it's steel and one other element. You can typically leave steel fire pits out all year round, which is ideal if you’re short on outdoor storage space.
  • Copper: Some fire pit bowls are made of copper, like the Better Homes & Gardens Wood Burning Copper Fire Pit. Copper may not be as durable as steel, but it has a high melting point and good durability overall. However, copper may require some upkeep as it can potentially tarnish. 
  • Stone: Another material found with fire pits is stone. This material can require greater construction work in putting it together than you'd find with steel or copper. However, picks like the Arlmont & Co. Koch Stone Fire Pit eliminate this complication and comes put together without the complication. If you are open to the extra work involved with stone, options like the Necessories Grand Fire Pit do require some assembly, but we think the overall experience is worth it.

Fuel Type

There are two types of fuel you’ll usually see for fire pits: wood and propane. They both work well but have a different set of pros and cons. Wood is a classic for a reason—with it, you get the crackling sound and the delicious smell. It’s also more customizable, as you can choose how much firewood you’d like to use to create a smaller or larger flame, and easier to cook with. However, it also takes more time and maintenance to manage a wood-burning fire, the smoke can sometimes get unruly, and the wood chopping and ash cleanup make it far from being a maintenance-free experience. 

Propane is instant; you simply turn the dial and you’ll have fire. It often has settings to allow you to choose how high your flame should be, and it’s easier to use when camping since you don’t have to worry as much about campfire bans or gathering enough kindling to keep a fire going all night. However, you have to fill it with propane and, like anything that uses gas, it poses a risk of a leak if not properly used.

“An extremely important safety measure to take when using a fire pit is to always make sure the gas or propane connections are tight and solid,” says Chris Putrimas, CEO of Teak Warehouse. “If you ever smell gas, except when you light it, turn it off immediately and call a plumber to check your gas line connections.”

Additional Features

If you’re using a smokeless fire pit, it should always have the double-walled construction that allows it to burn its own smoke off before it reaches you. If you’re using a wood-burning fire pit, it’s nice if it comes with a poker or a mesh screen to control the fire and prevent sparks from flying—and if it doesn’t, you may want to buy one. A stand is an important feature that allows a wood-burning pit to hover above the ground, allowing you to place it on surfaces like a deck or fresh grass without worrying about damage. You should also look for a way to remove ash via an ash pan or tray. Propane fire pits should come with a hose to connect the propane tank. Most fire pits also include  a carrying case or cover, as you need to protect it from the weather or transport it from your campsite to the car.

Safety

Safety is one of the biggest factors to consider when placing a fire pit in your backyard or campsite. You’ll always need to place it in an area at least 20 feet from your house and away from hanging trees or plants. It should never be under an overhang or in a partially-enclosed space. The surface it sits on is equally important. “Instead of placing it directly on a wooden deck or dry grass, opt for a non-flammable surface like stone,” says Anne Puukko, founder of Superdwell. Avoid placing the fire pit on combustible surfaces such as wood, vinyl, stamped concrete, or composite flooring without a stand, and instead opt for level areas made of dirt, gravel or stone.

If you’re buying a propane fire pit, Mitch Brean, founder of Stone Yard advises to “know your fillers and choose safe materials like lava stone or fire glass.” For additional safety, Bryan Clayton, CEO at GreenPal recommends using a spark screen and keeping a fire extinguisher or water nearby. “When you're done, make sure the fire is completely out before you leave,” he says.

Lastly, Puukko recommends considering weather conditions before sitting out by the fire. “While the dancing flames might be mesmerizing, it's also wise to avoid using the pit on very windy days.”

Better Homes & Gardens

Other Fire Pits We Tested

Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0

The Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 was our previous “Best Overall” fire pit, but it didn’t perform as well in a new round of testing. It arrived pretty much ready to go and doesn’t require a lot of assembly, plus, it hasn’t rusted after a long period of ownership. The Solo Stove produces barely any smoke; it burns efficiently and cleanly, and you can even wear the same clothes the next day without smelling like a campfire. All big plus points there. However, it doesn’t produce much heat, in any weather—you have to sit very close to feel any warmth or purchase an additional heat shield to feel the effects. Overall, it’s a good option if you’re looking for a portable, cleanly designed, and smokeless fire pit.

Hampton Bay Tipton 34 in. Steel Deep Bowl Fire Pit in Oil Rubbed Bronze

The Hampton Bay Tipton 34 in. Steel Deep Bowl Fire Pit in Oil Rubbed Bronze did well for a basic wood-burning pit and got extra points for its large bowl that fit a nice amount of firewood. However, it was a bit hard to put together and ended up rusting quickly. Between those factors and the price point, there are better wood-burning fire pits to purchase—unless you particularly like the aesthetic of this one, in which case it would be a fine addition to your backyard.

Arlmont & Co. Gustafson Steel Wood Burning Outdoor Fire Pit

Again, for a basic wood-burning pit, the Arlmont & Co. Gustafson Steel Wood Burning Outdoor Fire Pit does the job, but there are a few reasons why it didn’t end up on our list. For one, it’s over $200, which is a higher price than most models with similar specs. Additionally, there were some issues with the construction of the base. The setup was complicated, and it took a few different tries to tighten and secure the different pieces. Finally, one of the tools that takes the mesh base on and off felt cheap and the handle scratched our hands when used.

Breeo Luxeve Smokeless Fire Pit

There were a few aspects of the Breeo Luxeve Smokeless Fire Pit we liked, such as the even heat distribution and effortless smokeless feature. We also liked that it had an outer wall for temperature control that also made it safe for children. However, despite this being considered a smokeless option, we noticed that our clothes and hair all smelled like smoke after. Considering that it didn’t come with any functionable accessories, we also felt that the price point was too high.

Polywood Round Fire Pit Table

Overall, we really liked the Polywood Round Fire Pit Table. It had a strong heat output with easy temperature control. Plus, the modern, chic design went well with our outdoor space. It also had a large tabletop for additional functionality, like placing down glasses or a small plate of food. However, the price was triple that of our splurge pick.

Your Questions, Answered

What type of fire pit gives off the most heat?

If you’re using a fire pit to keep yourself warm, wood-burning is most likely the way to go, as wood burns hotter than gas. Propane fire pits are also limited in how big the flame can get, as it's designated to a few settings you choose by turning a knob, while wood can be stacked for flames to go as high as you’d like. Generally, though, they’ll both keep you pretty warm.

What is the best outdoor fire pit?

This, of course, depends on the way you’re using it. “From a camping perspective, the main factors I consider when looking for a fire pit are size, portability, and fuel source,” Cunningham says. “First, I want a fire pit that feels like I am sitting around a fire; I don't want it too small where I can't feel the heat. At the same time, I want it to be portable. I may pack it in my RV, bring it along car camping, or set it up in my backyard. If it's too big, that simply won't work.” If you’re using a fire pit for your backyard, keep to a wood-burning option. If you’re using a fire pit for camping, choose a propane model that is easy to take with you.

What is a good size fire pit for the backyard?

Again, this depends. For non-smokeless fire pits, the diameter of the bowl you stack the wood in tends to be over 30 inches in diameter, as you want to be able to stack wood and keep the fire going. Smokeless fire pits, however, tend to be smaller in diameter, but generally are large enough if they’re around 20 inches, with larger models going up to just under 30 inches. If you’re considering a fire pit for a very large party or want to burn a fire for a long time, it couldn’t hurt to choose a fire pit that’s larger in diameter, but if you’re in these ranges, you’ll be fine.

What style of fire pit is safest?

First things first: “Check with your local fire department to determine the regulations for fire pits in backyards,” says Alex Kantor, owner of Perfect Plants Nursery. “It is essential to know the standards and requirements to prevent wasting time, money, and effort building a fire pit that does not comply with regulations.” 

Structure and materials are of course key when looking for a safe fire pit, too. “Steer away from anything that feels too light or flimsy as it’ll likely be prone to wobbling, making it unsafe, especially around people and pets,” says Joanna Humphreys, fire and stove expert for Direct Stoves. “When you’re working with real fire and flames, you need your firebase to be as robust as possible to avoid fire spreading and causing unnecessary accidents to others as well as damage to your garden.” 

Lastly, make a plan for where the fire pit will sit in your backyard or at a campsite. “Avoid placing fire pits in flammable areas, such as wooden decks or near thick brush,” Kantor says.

Better Homes & Gardens

Who We Are

Alida Nugent is a writer specializing in air purifiers, vacuums, humidifiers, and cleaning products, and also has experience writing gear reviews for campers and outdoor spaces. She interviewed Ryan Cunningham from Beyond the Tent for this article.

Rachael Hogg is a writer and editor with more than a decade of experience working at food and drink, lifestyle, travel, and automotive publications. To update this article with new testing insights and recommendations, she interviewed Alex Kantor, owner of Perfect Plants Nursery; Anne Puukko, founder of Superdwell; Joe Raboine, vice president of design, Belgard; Joanna Humphreys, fire and stove expert for Direct Stoves; Mitch Brean, founder of Stone Yard; Chris Putrimas, CEO of Teak Warehouse; and Bryan Clayton, CEO at GreenPal.

What Is BHG Recommends?

Next to all of the products on this list, you may have noticed our BHG Recommends seal of approval. Products that earn the seal have been put through rigorous testing to make sure they're worth a spot in your home. We buy most of the products we test ourselves, but occasionally we are provided samples by companies if buying isn't an option. In these cases, we use the same testing criteria we use to test the purchased products.

Was this page helpful?

Related Articles