In the full video, the distinction isn’t as stark as the clueless moments the internet’s GIF makers found. Shockingly, this is only the 15th-most reblogged meme on Tumblr’s list.

The 2015 list also includes some memes that sadly didn’t survive until the end of the year: RIP Left Shark, Texts From Last Night, and “squad goals.” We hardly knew ye.

Cursed images, Tumblr’s ninth most-popular meme category in 2019, was No. 24 on the 2017 list, but didn’t appear in 2014, 2015, or 2016, according to Brennan.