Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Ghost Notebooks

Rate this book
A supernatural story of love, ghosts, and madness as a young couple, newly engaged, become live-in caretakers of a historic museum.

When Nick Beron and Hannah Rampe decide to move to the tiny upstate town of Hibernia, New York, they aren't running away, exactly, but they need a change. Their careers have flatlined, the city is exhausting, and they've reached a relationship stalemate. Hannah takes a job as live-in director of the Wright Historic House, a museum dedicated to an obscure nineteenth century philosopher, and she and Nick move into their new home—the town's remoteness, the speed with which she is offered the job, and the lack of museum visitors barely a blip in their considerations. At first life in this old, creaky house feels cozy—they speak in Masterpiece Theater accents, they take bottles of wine to the swimming hole. But as summer turns to fall Hannah begins to have trouble sleeping and she hears whispers in the night. One morning Nick wakes up to find Hannah gone. Now, in his frantic search for her he will discover the hidden legacy of Wright a man driven wild with grief, and a spirit aching for home.

256 pages, Kindle Edition

First published February 1, 2018

Loading interface...
Loading interface...

About the author

Ben Dolnick

8 books63 followers
Ben Dolnick is the author of four novels: Zoology, You Know Who You Are, At the Bottom of Everything, and The Ghost Notebooks. His writing has appeared in the New York Times, GQ, and on NPR. He lives in Brooklyn, NY.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
298 (15%)
4 stars
705 (35%)
3 stars
715 (36%)
2 stars
212 (10%)
1 star
41 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 291 reviews
Profile Image for Larry H.
2,863 reviews29.6k followers
November 10, 2017
I'm between 2.5 and 3 stars on this book.

Nick and Hannah's relationship is in a bit of a tumultuous phase—she recently lost her job, they've both been reluctant to talk about getting married even though that is the next logical step in their relationship, and there's tension all over the place—when Hannah admits that she has applied for a job as the director of the Wright Historic House, a museum devoted to an obscure 19th century writer and philosopher in a tiny upstate New York town.

The time between her first phone interview and the job offer seems to fly, and while leaving New York City for a small town isn't quite what Nick had in mind, he's realized he doesn't want to lose Hannah. And for a while everything seems charming—they speak to each other in Masterpiece Theater -like accents, enjoy visiting the town's one grocery store, and can finally listen to the sounds of nature outside their home as opposed to the hustle and bustle of the city. But then the reality of running a museum that very few visitors come to, and dealing with the machinations of a volunteer related to the person whose life the museum commemorates becomes more of a chore than a pleasure.

One night Hannah wakes Nick claiming to hear voices talking, but Nick hears nothing. There have been rumors through the years that the Wright House is visited by ghosts, and a woman whose family lived in the house before it became a museum once disappeared under mysterious circumstances. The stress of being convinced she is seeing and hearing things starts to take its toll on Hannah's already-fragile psyche and her relationship with Nick, which is already straining under the stress of trying to settle on wedding arrangements.

Nick awakens one morning to find Hannah gone. As he tries to figure out what happened to her, he starts to realize she was more emotionally fragile than even he realized, and he is determined to understand whether the house really is possessed by spirits which haunted Hannah, or whether it was her own mind playing tricks on her. His quest forces him to confront concepts of ghosts and the legacy of a troubled writer, and compels him in directions he'd never imagined before.

I honestly wasn't too sure what to make of The Ghost Notebooks . It's certainly an interesting exploration of how a relationship fares under intense pressure, emotional and otherwise, and it's also a look at how grief and extreme emotional stress can cause you to act in very bizarre ways. But I don't know what Ben Dolnick was really trying to say about the situation his characters found themselves in, and whether there really was something supernatural going on, or whether it was some sort of self-fulfilling prophecy.

I've read all of Dolnick's other books— Zoology, You Know Who You Are and At the Bottom of Everything —and I really enjoy the way he writes, and the complexity he brings to his characters. I felt that on the whole, the story flowed well, but it went a little off the rails after a while, and I don't know if that was intentional or not. In the end, while there were some poignant parts of the story, it didn't resonate for me as I'd hoped it would. But if anyone else reads this and has a different take, I'd love to hear it!

NetGalley and Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group provided me an advance copy of the book in exchange for an unbiased review. Thanks for making this available!

See all of my reviews at http://itseithersadnessoreuphoria.blo....
Profile Image for Mohammed Arabey.
709 reviews6,307 followers
February 24, 2018
Caretaking a place, has its slightest share of supernatural power, can't go wrong, right?
Even if the Caretaker has his own slightest of..psychic issues..right?!

Then what went wrong here at this Ghost infested Historic House?

Well, it's not “Shinning” Horror, & not much a true "Gone Girl" mystery..
But it's an excellent Psychological Novel/Notebook..of feelings and Human Sensations; love, comfart, stress, anxiety, grief...A Notebook of life, Past,future & death..

it experience phases of life, in a very strange and interesting way...
“Was life, despite its myriad difficulties, an unfathomable wonder, as his pious and tenderhearted mother would have it? Or was it a Boschian array of horrors, punctuated only by inadequate bits of relief, as his revered but unstable father tended to believe.”

With so many situations that you can easily feel related to, ever wonder how do you feel about getting really too old and fragile?
Ever felt in loss, Should I go on with this job?, this wedding?...this life?
“there is, I think, a special gloom that comes with wedding planning. It may just be the realization that the traps you watched swallow up a thousand people before you are going to swallow you up too.”

Let's see briefly the High and low points in this Novel/Notebook Part by Part.

Part One (2.5 ☆☆☆)
----------------


It's more the narrator/protagonist "Nick" telling how he choose to settle down in a real engagement/marrying commitment with his girlfriend Hanna... parents v protective due to her post-collage seeious Stree issues.
She takes Caretaker job at a 19 century philosopher Historic House... who dealt with intense study of Human Sensations....and Ghosts..

With no Horror nor Ghosts encounter, just Drama, with touch of romance, and a heavy psychological atmosphere, goes this part.. till the Missing Girlfriend happens..

The narrating was a bit ranty , many parenthesis lines. But the good thing that after every chapter there's this varity of stranges pages, from Edmond Wright letters and dairies or books.. or strange bizarre different kind of daires...-seems belong to Hanna but written in a strange way and doesn't seem accurate..

But then comes...

Part Two (4.5 ☆☆☆☆☆)
------------------


To avoid spoilers I won't talk about what happened here... but every way you may think the story will takes from Part One will come crushing here...
It takes a very different route...and it surprised me...

The psychological way the narrator/protagonist dealing with the events is amazingly written...very real and sarcastic..
“Almost every single person at a funeral believes that their being there is a kind of lie, that while everyone else is feeling the exact degree of grief recommended by the American Psychiatric Association, they alone are worrying about whether this will end in time for them to make their train.”

Very accurate psychologically..
“There’s a moment, after you wake up from a nightmare, when you realize: Wait, so I don’t have to worry about any of that.”
~~~~~~~~~
“What I felt, reading this and the pages after, was a more distressing version of the thing you feel when you catch a glimpse of yourself on a store’s surveillance TV. Does my hair really do that in the back? Could that slump- shouldered stranger really be me?”

It's more funny amidst all the hard parts too..-and here a quote that funny and show u how ranty the narrating is-
“There were, at that point, two other people with me in the waiting room— a skeletal teenage girl reading a Game of Thrones paperback so thick it was almost cubic, and a fortysomething woman with curly hair and glasses who I took to be the skeleton’s mother.”


BUT the plus here is the mystery, so interesting. And here the novel made HUGE potential for how it could be concluded...
“ I could either die or I could find out why Curiosity is responsible for as many saved lives as penicillin.”


Well, that leads us to ;

Part Three (2 ☆☆)
----------------


Here where the mystery meet your plainest expectations...
The narrating back to be less interesting -if not pointless- concluding the story with bit of Romance touch...

It sure has its creepy idea of Ghosts... it's the title after all,
“ In my student days I read of a species of caterpillar that was prone to a most frightful misfortune. This sorry caterpillar would on occasion be attacked by a small & vicious wasp who, in the course of his assault, would lay a great many eggs in the caterpillar’s abdomen. The wasp’s eggs would then proceed, by some chemical means, to control the caterpillar’s movements, inducing it to gather precisely the type of nutriment they craved. Once the eggs had matured sufficiently, they would come pouring forth from the caterpillar’s underbelly, a hellish horde . . . Thus do I, at the end of my researches, having spent all the fall playing host to spirits, find myself husked & destroyed.”


but it's really more psychological novel.... has its moments of creepiness...sadness...romance..mystery...uncommon interesting chapters styles.
And it really could have made more of all that if concluded with extra thriller.


Special Thanks to Penguin First to Read Program,


Mohammed Arabey
From 28 Jan.2018
To 1 Feb. 2018
Profile Image for Sarah Joint.
445 reviews1,014 followers
February 18, 2018
If you're in the mood for something light-hearted about love and ghosts, put this one down and seek something else, come back to it later. From the synopsis, I expected it to be dark but it was even darker. It'll make you think and come back to haunt you later on if you give it a proper chance, the kind of book that sinks into you over time. I finished it four days ago but was completely unsure how to write a review at first.

Nick and Hannah are in a rut. They've been together for a long time without getting engaged, and they seem to be drifting apart. Nick has been putting off proposing, but when he gets a glimpse of life without Hannah... he realizes it's time to commit. An opportunity for a drastic life change presents itself. After losing her job, Hannah has been offered a new one as a caretaker for a historical museum: the Wright Historic House, so named for a philosopher from the nineteenth century.

A museum practically in the middle of nowhere with no internet and few visitors, their new lives couldn't be more different than their old ones in New York City. At first, they thrive. With only each other for entertainment, they become closer. Sadly, it doesn't last. As the weather turns cooler, Hannah starts to drift away. She's barely sleeping and hearing things at night. And then she vanishes.

Truly a story of love, ghosts, and madness, as stated in the synopsis. It has light moments early on, but is overwhelmingly bleak in general. It is an odd sort of story, a bit confusing at times, but all comes together in the end and it's very well-written. It's very raw and will make you think. It won't be for everyone, but it was for me. 4.5 out of 5, rounded up.

I received a copy of this book from Net Galley and Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, thank you! My review is honest and unbiased.
Profile Image for Julie.
1,912 reviews594 followers
February 11, 2018
Nick and Heather are tired.....tired of the city, tired of their apartment, tired of their lives. They need a change of scenery. Heather applies for a job as caretaker at a museum in upstate New York and before they even realize it's really happening they are moving to Hiberia, NY. The museum is dedicated to an obscure and strange philosopher and writer, Edmund Wright. At first, living in the historic house is a nice change for them. They enjoy planning events for school kids, leading tours and walking in the woods. They learn a bit about Wright, the death of his son in an accident, and read some of his writing. Then things start to go wrong.....Heather develops severe insomnia, stops taking her medication, seems distant and upset, and starts hearing voices in the old house. Is the house haunted? Is she losing her mind? Then Heather disappears one day......and Nick's life will never be the same.

After finishing this book I feel a bit like I'm back in college, sitting in the middle of a lecture hall for classic literature class, and the professor has called on me for my interpretation of some famous poem or line from a famously classic book. All eyes turn to me, and I have to admit.....I don't really get it. I have to be honest and say.....I read this entire book from beginning to end, waiting to see what was going to happen, what the answer was, what was in store for the characters.....and then it was over......and I just feel a bit puzzled and drained. But I think I understand.....this is a slog through the mire that is the human psyche and emotions. Anger, guilt, sadness, confusion, loss, depression, mental illness.....this is not a supernatural tale, but a very natural one. A raw peek into human nature, relationships, mental health and gut-wrenching loss. Sometimes there is no answer.....sometimes there are only questions and hard as hell reality.

The story is well-written and interesting, but a bit too cerebral for me. And I'm unsure if what I take away from this book are the thoughts and feelings that Dolnick meant to inspire. The story builds quietly....and then jumps deep into the abyss that is mental illness, severe anxiety and suicide. Heavy stuff.

I can't fault the book -- it's very well-written. I think the subject matter is just intrinsically uncomfortable. The atmosphere is creepy and the slow build of the story is strange and unsettling. But, that was the effect it was supposed to have on readers.

Powerful story......but strange and uncomfortable.

The author made his point, but I'm still strangely unsure exactly what it was.

It's sort of like that strange prickling feeling you can get in a strange place.....like someone is watching you from just out of your sight....and the only thing you can think of is getting away and going somewhere light and sunny. Haunting and creepy......yet so real and human.

**I voluntarily read an advanced readers copy of this book from Penguin via First to Read. All opinions expressed are entirely my own.**
Profile Image for Adrienne L.
244 reviews83 followers
November 25, 2024
4.5 stars

Hannah and Nick are a newly engaged couple living in New York City who decide to move upstate to the small town of Hibernia, after Hannah is offered the directorship of the historic Wright House and Museum. The Wright House was once the home of a little-known 19th century philosopher who dabbled in the occult after the tragic death of his young son on the property. Soon after their arrival, Hannah, who has suffered a breakdown in the past, stops taking her medication and starts spending her sleepless nights in the storage room of the house looking through old papers. When tragedy inevitably strikes, Nick is left reeling and becomes obsessed with finding out what Hannah discovered in the museum attic, at the expense of his own sanity.

I first came upon The Ghost Notebooks in the new release section of my local library shortly after its publication. I suspect it was there because I happen to live in the Hudson Valley not far from where the book takes place. I enjoyed it, but I wasn't entirely blown away. However, I would still find myself thinking about the story months and even years later after I had completely forgotten the title of the book. I guess you could say it haunted me in a very vague and insubstantial way, which is appropriate because the supernatural elements in Dolnick's book are vague and insubstantial themselves.

Although I wasn't a GR member at the time of the book's publication, I rather suspect that the fairly low average rating reflects a case of a book being marketed as something it is not, and the few negative reviews I've read confirm this. This isn't a Gothic horror story; it's barely a ghost story. It's a beautifully written and insightful study of relationships and grief.

When I did finally remember the name of the book, I purchased a copy immediately because I knew I wanted to read it again and find out why this book refused to leave my head entirely, even though it didn't exactly wow me on my first read. After this second time through The Ghost Notebooks, I don't regret my purchase. This book is almost, but not quite, a five star for me. And who knows if it won't end up increasing its rating when I pick it up again at some point in the future. It's too bad it never seemed to find it's audience.
Profile Image for Sheila.
1,061 reviews102 followers
February 20, 2018
3 stars--I liked the book.

A creepy old house and ghosts--two things I adore in a book. I loved the idea behind this haunting (no spoilers), but I thought the book took its time getting to it. The ghost mystery doesn't show up until around the 70% mark. Still, cool idea.

Profile Image for Blair.
1,933 reviews5,555 followers
September 27, 2024
(Review written January 2018.) It's make-or-break time for thirtyish couple Nick and Hannah. They're discontented, always bickering; Hannah has been made redundant, and while Nick isn't sure how he feels about getting married, Hannah wants nothing more. It takes an almost-breakup for Nick to realise he can't live without Hannah. He's so grateful to get her back that not only does he propose, he agrees to move with her from New York City to Dutchess County, further upstate, so she can take on a new job: caretaker of the Wright Historic House. This small museum was once home to a writer, Edmund Wright, and his family. The tragic death of Wright's youngest son led him to dabble in occult practices, and local rumours say the building is haunted.

At first, the couple are blissfully happy. The move out of NYC invigorates their relationship; living in the museum is cosy and charming, a whimsical adventure. But after a while, cracks begin to show. Hannah starts behaving erratically, and Nick worries about her mental health. One night, she insists she can hear voices in the empty house. She barely sleeps; spends hours going through old paperwork in a cluttered office. Nick discovers she has stopped taking the medication prescribed ever since a nervous breakdown in her early twenties, and shortly afterwards, she goes missing. The aftermath sends Nick into a spiral of depression, confusion and guilt. What happened to Hannah? And what does it have to do with Wright's experiments in spiritualism?

I just tore through this one – it's so readable, as smooth as caramel and totally compelling. It's not really a ghost story, but there's always the promise of strangeness just around the corner. Dolnick makes his protagonists incredibly likeable yet makes sure the reader is aware something – the true nature of what's going on? – is out of their reach. The way Nick tells his story, with careful trepidation, assigning retrospective significance to certain incidents, only adds further layers of intrigue. If you're looking for a proper supernatural tale, look elsewhere; while there is horror here, it is (mostly) of the more existential kind. However, it's no less effective for that.

I received an advance review copy of The Ghost Notebooks from the publisher through NetGalley.
Profile Image for Faith.
2,075 reviews625 followers
February 26, 2018
Hannah and Nick, a young engaged couple with relationship problems, move to an old house in upstate New York. The house is reputed to be haunted. Hannah has a history of mental illness, she begins to hear voices and then she suddenly disappears leaving Nick bereft. I'm not sure what this book was, certainly not an atmospheric ghost story. It's more the story of the role of mental illness in a relationship. The story is told from the point of view of Nick and might have been more interesting if we had also heard from Hannah. I can't say that I enjoyed this book, or even got the point of it, but I did manage to finish it. However, even for a short book, the story dragged.

I received a free copy of this book from the publisher.
Profile Image for Bill Kupersmith.
Author 1 book233 followers
May 29, 2018
I so wanted to like this book. It has an ideal plot. A couple who work in the artistic sector in New York City--he's a musical editor and she's a museum curator--flee to "upstate" (by NYC standards, Dutchess County, an under two hour drive, is "upstate" which I suppose puts Buffalo at the North Pole) to be custodians of an estate and museum that belonged to a 19th-c. eccentric writer. But narrator Nick is utterly self obsessed (he sounds as if he thinks he made a huge and generous sacrifice by actual marrying his long-time live-in girlfriend Hannah). She is the only interesting character and written out of the story early. We are also treated to excepts from the remains of famous writer, which are unendurably banal, even when he describes a infestation by ghosts. Most importantly, though supposedly being a ghost story, this book is not even remotely scary, not even a little shiver. If you like ghost stories about boring ghosts narrated by a narcissist, you might like this one.
Profile Image for Trisha.
5,333 reviews202 followers
March 28, 2019
"Your own life is terrifying, but life is an unending astonishment."

I wanted to love this one - I did. But it's a very quiet book - an in-depth look at a relationship as a couple moves from New York City to the country to take care of an old house turned museum. I was ready for a ghost story but it has very little suspense or ghost or haunting. For such a short book, I was almost 150 pages in before anything really happened other than the couple moving and starting to work for the museum. Sure, there are a few bumps in the night but there are other possible reasons for it and the MC is a bit...distracted? He's an odd POV to have since he catches little, cares little and stays pretty much in his head. Meh. I wish I'd loved this more but I just couldn't get interested in the story.
Profile Image for Simay Yildiz.
664 reviews181 followers
February 23, 2020
Hepsini bir arada sipariş etmiş bulunduğumdan yine Belletrist kitaplarından gittim sevgili okurlar. Ve şu anda şöyle düşünüyorum: ben Belletrist’i takip edip, “bu kitap nasıl bir şey ki acaba?” diye düşünmekten vazgeçeyim çünkü sevdikleri en iyi şey canım Joan Didion ve onun dışındaki önerilerinden merak edip okuduklarımın yarısı (tam yarı yarıya; az önce kontrol ettim) bana keyif vermedi. Ben Dolnick de “Noktalı virgüle aşk hikâyesi yazan adam” olarak tanıdığım, e haliyle Belletrist’te görünce romanını da merak ettiğim bir yazar.

“Sen de hem ediyorsun hem de bulunca bıdı bıdı ediyorsun” dediğiniz duyar gibiyim; haklısınız da. Ama şimdi ismi The Ghost Notebooks (Hayalet Defterleri) olan, bir çiftin New York gibi bir şehri bırakıp taşındığı küçük kasabada müze haline getirilmiş, pek de kimsenin ziyaret etmediği bir evde yaşamaya başladığı bir hikâye sizin de ilginizi çekmez miydi? Ben de çekerdi. Ama merakınıza yeni düşüp okuduktan sonra yüksek ihtimalle benim gibi hayal kırıklığına uğrayacaksınız (ay resmen bu yazıyı tamamladıktan sonra başka Belletrist kitabı almış mıyım diye kontrol edeceğim).

Devamı: https://zimlicious.com/sevgili-ben-do...
Profile Image for Samantha Martin.
286 reviews50 followers
November 16, 2017
Review from Hello Yellow Room.

Feels like: Gone Girl meets The Haunting meets George Saunders

Sounds like: “Wait” by Wild Cub

“This is a thing that I’m sure is obvious to everyone else but is never-endingly astonishing to me: that every change, every life, consists of nothing but a series of days.”

I wish I hadn’t read this book so quickly, but I couldn’t help it. I ate it up. I consumed the tiny details of the haunted museum, the documentary style precursors to each chapter, the emphatic free-flowing association of jumbled thoughts and feelings through phantom experience, the waterfall of sensory information and memories that comprise the human experience. I ate it all like they were going to take it away from me, like I would never taste it again. In only a few voracious days I was done, and dizzy with wanting The Ghost Notebooks back. If you have anything better to do with your life, read with caution. This is horror-avantgarde-George-Saunders-ian art.

Ben Dolnick’s psychological stunner of a novel opens with Nick, a failed musician turned music producer who is attempting to understand the nuances of his relationship to other people, particularly to Hannah, his long-term girlfriend. When Hannah loses her job as a curator in the city, she decides to take the position as the museum director of the noticeably desolate and rural Wright Historic Museum. The mansion belonged to Edmund Wright, a prolific writer of the nineteenth-century, who was known to dabble in some mysterious other-wordly ideas in his latter years. Nick and Hannah move into the museum in order to run it, but what awaits them is, in short, haunting.

What Dolnick does so well and so accurately is describe a visceral sense of panic. When Nick describes his terror, his unease, his denial, his every infinitesimal discomfort, we feel it. I feel it, because Dolnick writes sorrow like a diary. He writes loss like he’s felt every inch of it before, all the physical aspects of grief. For example, there’s a scene in which Nick is desperately searching for Hannah in the woods outside the museum. He’s wearing a button-up that has one button missing, and Dolnick describes the patch of cold that enters through the empty square in his shirt. That’s the kind of detailed pain we have here.

I’m so happy this exists.

I received a copy of this book from Net Galley for an honest review.

Memorable Quotes (I know, there’s a lot, but they were just so good):

📖“He would, with the precision of a scientist and the sensitivity of a man of letters, set down on paper all the suffering that a person could reasonably expect to experience in his life, and then all of the pleasure.”📖

❤️”Couples should carry dry-erase boards for writing messages to each other; their voices convey too much.”💔

🌧”If you listen to sobbing long enough, and if you’re tired enough, the sound breaks off from its meaning and becomes something else. One minute it sounds like an animal trying to throw up; then like someone shivering on an ice floe. At its most intense, it sounds—and this is somehow especially horrible—just like someone laughing hysterically.”🌧

🥀”And right then, as my dad signaled for the check, it seemed to me that my mom must have been thinking what I was thinking: that every house is a haunted house. I’d been thinking a lot about the Wright Museum, of course, and how unbearable it would be if I ever set foot there again. But now I was thinking about the house I’d grown up in, where my mom still lived—three stories, pale blue, with the beige driveway and the taped-over doorbell—and I could see it surrounded by the ghosts of men working in their gardens and girls carrying gym bags and dogs going bald. And I could see us haunting it too, younger versions of ourselves trailing around with bags of microwaveable popcorn and broken plastic laundry baskets and—but I was too tired to finish the thought.”🥀

📚”Am I, this trembling, hallucinating ball of sinew, really any stranger of a creature, any more improbable of an object, than a ghost?”📚
Profile Image for Katherine Moore.
182 reviews47 followers
December 13, 2017
After a few bumpy starts, I raced through about 2/3 of this book in one go until a 3am finish. Obsessed with ghosts at an early age, I enjoyed this delightfully atmospheric novel which was told often with some humor and a good dose of self-reflection, by the narrator and protagonist, Nick. He and his fiancée Hannah move away from the big city and into this historic museum, the Wright House, in tiny Hibernia, to be its caretakers, which immediately gives you flashes of 'The Shining'. We don't get to know too much about Hannah right away, and the story centers around Nick's experience as he is the one who is really 'brought along for this strange ride'.
Because I was reading a digital copy, I didn't get to experience what the special notations of the original owner of the house, Edmund Wright, Mary have looked like, as with the ones kept in a journal by Hannah. I expect those to look different in the finished copy. This will likely add to the atmosphere of the novel. Also, whoever picks up this book should be fooled by that sweet cover, for there are spirits working within that aren't so innocent.
I found this book to be filled with quite a bit of mystery, some humor, self-reflection, a look at grief and loss, the supernatural, and the author,Ben Dolnick uses fascinating language throughout.
I'll be interested to see a finished copy with the 'Ghost Notebook' writings included.
Profile Image for Jessica Woodbury.
1,806 reviews2,773 followers
August 12, 2017
Much to like in this horror novel. Feels like it's very much set in the present day, but uses the old-haunted-house trope effectively.

Nick and Hannah leave the city to become caretakers of a small museum in upstate New York. Nick is the narrator, but it's his girlfriend, Hannah, who appears to be gradually more and more affected by the house. This isn't the kind of book that will actually scare you. It's not spooky or suspenseful, if anything it's almost more of a thriller with a ghost story attached as Nick looks back and tries to unravel what he missed and what went wrong.

One thing I thought about often while reading this is how the is-this-supernatural-or-am-I-going-mad trope is a tricky one to pull off these days. While a long time staple of the genre, this book has a character who's previously struggled with mental health which at first seems like it may add something new to the idea, but ultimately just had me feeling a little uncomfortable with the book's treatment of mental health. In particular I had trouble with the idea that a couple could be together for years (engaged, even) and share so little with each other about mental health issues. Secrecy is the key to the plot but it doesn't feel natural to the characters.

Readers who are sensitive to issues of depression, anxiety, and suicide should probably give it a pass as they're all major elements, particularly in the final third of the book.
Profile Image for Lisa.
750 reviews158 followers
April 24, 2018
This was odd and strange but I really, really loved it. 5 stars.
February 9, 2018
This is one of those reviews I'm having trouble writing. Partly because there isn't a lot of action in the book and the reason I actually liked it probably had more to do with the atmosphere in it and not the actual action. First I have to say I think the cover does this book a huge disservice. Had I not investigated more, I would have had no idea it was a horror read. Then again, nothing about it was really horrific so I think advertising it as horror is a disservice to readers. See, I'm all over the place already.

"The Ghost Notebooks" tells the story of Nick and Hannah. They reside in New York but when Hanna gets laid off, she seeks a job as a museum curator/director of the Wright House - a local tourist attraction in Hibernia, New York. Since it is in a very remote location they actually live on the property as well and although Nick is hesitant at first, he knows Hannah needs a change and this move might just be what he needs to reignite his music career.

Once Nick and Hannah arrive, strange occurrences begin to happen. Plus, Hannah sort of goes off the deep in but Nick accounts this to past mental issues and the fact that he learned she is off her medication. Then something happens that turns his world upside down and sends Nick down the rabbit hole of madness.

I picked this book up on a whim as it was not my planned next read. It is quite slow at times, but that didn't really bother me because it coincided with the story and also, being a relatively short book, it didn't feel dragged out. I didn't really feel an intense connection with either Nick or Hannah, but did care enough about them to what to know what happens to them. I also remained curious about the Wright House and the secrets it held. The book is divided into three parts and to be honest, although the ending wrapped things up nicely, it felt like a let-down and probably contributed more the the 3/5 rating than anything else. The first and second parts definitely rated higher.

If you like slower paced atmospheric reads, and you enjoyed "haunted" tales, then you might be interested in "The Ghost Notebooks." However, don't go into this expecting a lot of horror, or you will probably be most disappointed.

I received this book from the Penguin First to Read program in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Teresa.
662 reviews178 followers
July 29, 2024
I don't know what to say about this book! I was looking forward to a good ghost story but that it certainly wasn't. It started off well even if it was a bit drawn out but then it seemed to lose itself somewhere along the way. It became more about psychology than ghosts. I found Hannah very trying and when she disappeared, Nick started acting strangely.
I skimmed the last third of the book because I was that disinterested in the outcome. People have loved it though so don't go on my review alone.
Profile Image for Cedricsmom.
301 reviews2 followers
May 7, 2018
This small book caught my eye while reading the New York Times Book Review. The premise sounded intriguing so I gave it a read. Very good writing; Dolnick is quite skilled at descriptions, imaging and metaphor. This is a hybrid of ghost story, haunted house tale and first marriage love. He doesn’t linger but makes it into, through and out of the story in under 250 pages. Definitely worth a read. He has several other books out of you need more.
Profile Image for Abbie | ab_reads.
603 reviews440 followers
December 7, 2019
Don’t you just love it when you go into a book basically blind and it ends up being all the better for it? For some reason I had convinced myself that The Ghost Notebooks was pure historical fiction, and indeed there is a historical element to it, but it’s more of a literary ghost story and such a unique book!
.
The story begins with Nick and Hannah realising their lives are in desperate need of a shake up, so Hannah accepts a job as caretaker of a historical house in the country, a museum dedicated to informing people about the life of an eccentric 19th century philosopher whose life was marred by tragedy. At first they revel in the adventure of it, but soon Hannah starts acting strangely, hearing whispers in the night, until one morning Nick awakes to find her simply gone.
.
As well as the spiritual element, Dolnick also presents us with a heartbreaking portrayal of grief. I didn’t cry, but some passages were so beautiful and raw that I just had to sit there and think on them for a while. Yet the book isn’t overrun with emotion - the narrator, Nick, has a great sense of humour and some of his asides in the first person narration were so funny, but the humour didn’t feel out of place in this otherwise dark story.
.
It’s not a horror novel per se, but there are some chills - or maybe that’s just me being a wimp! I’d say there’s a tinge of unease running through it, and Dolnick does well to express the grief, madness and obsession his characters are experiencing.
.
For a quiet yet haunting read playing on psychological and supernatural fears, I would definitely recommend this one!
.
Thank you to @sumaiyya.books for sending me this one!
Profile Image for Amanda .
834 reviews13 followers
December 28, 2018
I can’t really compare The Ghost Notebooks to any other book I’ve read. The narrative took the perspective of one of the main characters, Nick Beron. It also occasionally contained excerpts from books by the writer, Edmund Wright, the original owner of the Wright House, the perspective of Wright during his lifetime, and thoughts from an unknown female throughout the entirety of her life, I thought that these multiple perspectives and writing styles made the writing as a whole confusing and unwieldy at times.

Although I would place this book within the paranormal genre, I would not classify this book as horror. I enjoyed the plot and mystery of the story. I couldn’t predict where it was going. There were some unanswered questions in this story such as . Dolnick is a talented writer and he was able to phrase descriptions in brilliant ways. He grabbed me from the first sentence:

Let me explain, first of all, that I was never one of those people who believed, even a little bit, in ghosts. I knew people who did – people with office jobs and shoe inserts and wallets stuffed with sandwich punch cards – and I could never quite hide my bewilderment when I realized that they weren’t kidding.

Even though this wasn’t a humorous book by any means, Dolnick’s descriptions were witty and well thought out:

…She had on jeans and a flannel shirt, and she had the long gray hair of someone who cares deeply about horses.

Despite all of this, I had mixed feelings about this book. I think the dysfunction between Nick and Hannah’s relationship throughout the book did not make this a really pleasurable read. I have neutral feelings about this book.

I would make a disclaimer that anyone who flinches at reading about animal cruelty, this isn’t the book for you. .
Profile Image for rachel.
807 reviews162 followers
March 20, 2018
I was glued to this book while I was reading it, and could not wait to get back to it when I was not reading it. But, looking back after finishing, I think you as a reader need to be fully invested in Nick and Hannah's relationship as a Great Love in order to love the book, and I wasn't quite there.

Don't get me wrong: I loved the fact that their relationship is messy and we see second thoughts about spending forever together. That felt real, something that young couples who are serious about each other actually go through before deciding to tie the knot. But I also don't know if we see enough of their sustained good times before Hannah's disappearance.

Also:

On a superficial note, the design of this book is excellent. It's a little more elongated than most books (to seem more like a notebook/journal?) and the cover art is perfect for its content and mood. I love the sort of retro designs and fonts we are starting to see on new books, and being a sucker, it will always catch my eye. Hint hint, publishers...take my $!
Profile Image for Jonathan Maas.
Author 27 books329 followers
September 27, 2018
Ben Dolnick gets into Book of the Year territory - any category - with The Ghost Notebooks

I knew what this book was going to be from the very beginning - that ultra rare combination of a tale that holds John Updike-levels of insight on every page, and yet makes you want to turn the page.

For example, on the main character's pre-marriage life:

Our fridge had become a collage of other people’s “Save the Date” cards; our credit card bills went all to flights to cities we didn’t want to visit where we sat sulking in folding chairs and pretended to be surprised when the bride appeared. I knew that I could solve our problems by proposing to her, and I knew that any remotely competent therapist would tell me that my reluctance had nothing to do with Hannah and everything to do with the fiasco of my parents’ marriage…but I couldn’t.


Or on his idea of careers:

Just as the function of most furniture is to fill up a room, the function of most jobs is to fill up a life.


But make no mistake - this is a page turner

Ben Dolnick doesn't have the usual tricks in a thriller - The Ghost Notebooks doesn't have many murders, or even ghosts - and the little violence it holds is all off screen.

But the plot moves forward with every word, and you can not put it down.

Call it Ill Will, but just easier on all fronts

Dan Chaon's juggernaut of a book Ill Will knocked me for a loop - and I felt the same themes in The Ghost Notebooks.

But Ben Dolnick pulls his punches, but in the best sense of the phrase.

IE he doesn't go for the dread - he goes for the insight.

And oh wow, can Dolnick bring a character to life with a paragraph

On the main character's father in law -

Bruce was an eye surgeon; this was the first, and possibly the only, thing he thought you needed to know about him. He took yearly trips to Tanzania, where he performed free surgeries for village kids who then hung grinning from his biceps in photos. He jogged a loop of Central Park each morning, and was under the impression that their building’s doorman (“That’s all you running today, Mr. R?”) was personally fond of him. He had a full head of gray hair and pink skin and he interacted with everyone, including his offspring, in a way that managed to convey I’m going to do you the favor of listening hard to what you’re saying right now, but please understand that the meter is running.


On the main character's parents -

My own parents, by comparison, were as involved in my life as an uncle and aunt. (My mom, when I told her that Hannah and I were engaged, said, “Oh, that’s great news. We just love her, love her,” and then asked if she could call me back because she was about to pull into the garage.)


And oh - can he set the scene with a line or two

The character thinking that he didn't hear a voice -

To be clear: I still didn’t hear any voices. But you never quite hear nothing when you’re in an old house in the middle of the night.


In short - book of the year all around

Don't let the title make you think otherwise. The Ghost Notebooks is literature with a paranormal edge.

It's first and foremost literature though - and that is why it should be in the running in more than just a thriller / horror category.

In any case great tale - I recommend it!
Profile Image for Samantha.
390 reviews202 followers
April 15, 2018
I enjoyed Ben Dolnick's The Ghost Notebooks. Dolnick is a skilled writer. This is the story of a struggling young couple that coalesces into a very good classic ghost story. Dolnick presents a lot of interesting and relatable ideas that offer food for thought.

Nick and Hannah are a couple living in New York City. On the cusp of their thirties, they're unsure whether to break up or get married. When Hannah is offered a job in upstate New York to be the caretaker of the Wright Historic House, this is a catalyst for them. Nick proposes and they move to the Wright House. At first they enjoy being an island of two and preparing for the not-so-frequent visitors and school tours of the museum. But as the weather gets colder, Hannah begins to suffer from insomnia and becomes visibly distressed. When Nick tries to find out what's the matter, she grows secretive and distant. After things go horribly awry, Nick sets out to uncover what about the house has been troubling Hannah. He must delve into the life of 19th century philosopher Edmund Wright, who became interested in spiritualism when his young son died on the property.

I enjoy novels like this, with a fictitious author who's given a believable and detailed background in the storyworld. There's a realistic quality to the history, life, and oeuvre of Edmund Wright, as well as his excerpted writings. The Ghost Notebooks has a cool format, with mysterious passages in a stream of consciousness style, informational literature about the Wright House, and "historical" writings interspersed between chapters.

Dolnick has a good, strong voice. I liked his way of putting things and describing things. He employs evocative figurative language. I particularly appreciated his unique metaphors. The Ghost Notebooks contains spot-on observations about relationships, work, and 21st century life. It contains wry humor and is clever, knowing, and smart. It's also haunting and sad. At its core, this is a meditation on grief and loss. This novel peels back the layers of a relationship and follows Nick as he tries to make sense of life in an indecipherable world.
Profile Image for Rachel.
48 reviews11 followers
September 14, 2017
A good ghost story haunts you, chills you with its dark atmospherics, fills you with the dread and horror of the unknown. In real life, our choices are what haunt us: past mistakes, fear of the unknown consequence. Failed relationships. Failed careers. In The Ghost Notebooks, Ben Golnick seamlessly weaves between the two to create a tale of horror of both the psychological and supernatural variety. The writing is gorgeous and perceptive, and the twists are gutting. It's the most riveting ghost story I have read since David Mitchell's Slade House.
Profile Image for Trin.
2,082 reviews636 followers
March 3, 2018
Dolnick's prose is fantastic -- full of rich simile, descriptive but not show-offy, packed with brilliant observations and clever turns of phrase. I was less enamored with the characters: Hannah, especially, I wish were better developed. But from the moment I started I wanted to keep reading this book, which was, in the end, less a haunted house story and more a surprisingly sensitive portrait of grief.
Profile Image for Sonia Gensler.
Author 6 books245 followers
Read
May 1, 2019
This was one of my Brooklyn bookstore purchases. Very clever and a fast read. More mysterious than spooky. I will read it again.
Profile Image for Debbie Hope.
372 reviews13 followers
March 23, 2021
I really enjoyed this. A newly wed couple starts experiencing difficulties when they move into a historic museum.
Profile Image for Alex.
27 reviews1 follower
March 19, 2023
i wanted to read something spooky but it was mostly about loss. it was very painful to get through. its a good book.

“We're like the hands of a clock...chasing and escaping each other, losing and finding each other, around and around, again and again, joined way down at the root, no matter how far apart.”
150 reviews6 followers
February 4, 2018
The Ghost Notebooks by Ben Dolnick was a combination of the most detailed descent into grief and madness ever written and a heartwarming story of love and salvation.  I started reading this book with high hopes.  The blurb makes it sound like something that keeps you on the edge of your seat, however I found that wasn't quite the case.

Initially, the book reads as a simple memoir.  A recounting of a man's life.  The beginning is a very long set-up, wherein Dolnick delivers excruciating details on the minutiae of Nick and Hannah's lives, from their meeting to their careers.  The entire first (nearly half of the book) section is devoted to this...staging what leads up to the encounters with spirits and the disappearance of Hannah from Nick's life.  There were points where I was tempted to skim, but the writing was beautiful despite the somewhat boring subject matter, and I would find myself drawn back in, over and over.

The writings of Wright at the beginning of each chapter seemed to serve no purpose, though reading them is highly recommended due to the nature of Part 3 of the book.  Also, the stream-of-conscious writings that head up random chapters are DEFINITELY necessary to read, despite the difficulty in lack of punctuation.

Dolnick's handling of mental illness is masterful.  The contrast between Hannah's nearly invisible illness and Nick's very in-your-face grief and subsequent spiral is amazing, and neither one appears to be more or less tragic for it.  The suffering of both characters exists without comparison.  At times, you wonder what would have been different had Hannah been more open?  Others, you wonder if the reason for her lack of candor regarding her illness is because Nick is oblivious to her suffering.  The interpersonal relationship becomes more convoluted after Hannah disappears, as Nick begins to realize just how little he knew her...and then you have to wonder how much of that spurs on his own devolution.  

I spent most the book in a state of confusion, crafting plausible and not-so-plausible theories on what happened to the characters (major and minor) that would get supported or rejected as the book progressed.  It wasn't until, perhaps, the last 1/3 of the book that things started to pick up and the thriller part really got going.  The last 100 pages were definitely fast-paced (but still with bouts of "WHEN WILL IT END" that seemed to detract somewhat from the pace.  The ending was both a relief and a bit of a disappointment, as the lead-up was so dramatic, it was almost an anti-climax.  However, I actually like that the question of what happened to Nick is left open.  It would have felt completely out of place to have the whole of the story wrapped up.  

Overall, the pacing was somewhat erratic, but that almost lends a higher level of credibility to the whole story.  I would probably say that this is somewhere between a 3 and 4 star book.  The compelling story making up drastically for the strange pacing.  I am not sure who I would recommend this to, but I'm sure I know a few existentialists who would appreciate it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 291 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.