Barney Oldfield's Race for a Life

This silly, manic Mack Sennett classic is good fun for anyone who enjoys silent comedies. It displays Sennett's frantic, deliberately goofy style at its best. It is a parody and a deliberate exaggeration of some of the conventions of melodrama that were apparently routine even in 1913, complete with the villain tying the heroine to a railroad track. Mabel Normand is delightful as the heroine, Ford Sterling overplays the villain for all that it's worth (twiddling his mustache as often as possible), Sennett himself appears as Mabel's rather silly beau, and then-famous racing car driver Barney Oldfield also joins in the fun. There are a couple of very funny gags, along with some real excitement as the good guys try to foil the villain's dastardly plots. While of course thoroughly goofy, this one is well worth tracking down if you like these old silent films.

Having recently discovered the films of Mabel Normand and seen some of her great slapstick scenes with Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle, Barney Oldfield's Race for a Life was a big disappointment for me since Ms. Normand spends most of the short film tied onto railroad tracks because villain Ford Sterling didn't accept Mabel's rejection of his advances (glad to see her do so by knocking him down, however!). When her bashful boyfriend Mack Sennett finds out, he gets real-life race car driver Barney Oldfield to help him rush to her rescue. Also on hand are the Keystone Kops who get a hilarious scene at the end. Other than that and some of Mr. Sterling's over-the-top performance, this was mostly blah for me. Worth a look at least once for silent movie buffs. I saw this on YouTube with a score that contained some modern music from John Williams and other scores from recent movies and TV shows.

The scene is iconic in silent movies: a villain ties the heroine to rail tracks so an oncoming train can run over her. The first film to use the Victorian stage nail biter sequence was Keystone Studio's June 1913 "Barney Oldfield's Race For Life." The Keystone Cops try to save the woman, but not with the expected results.

There's a raging debate how often such a scene appeared in movies. Some say the track suspense sequence was a common occurrence, showing up in a number of silent films--many of them which are lost today. Others say it was rare, that the "woman-tied-to-tracks" thriller was hardly used at all.

The idea of such a dastardly act emerged from Victorian, late 1800's stage dramas, especially traveling troupe acts which used simple sound and light effects offstage to heighten the tension of a train approaching. Back then, however, it was usually the male hero of the play who was tied to the rails while the heroine would arrive breathlessly just in time to save the day.

One common comedic act that appears to be a first in ""Barney Oldfield's Race For Life" is the jealous villain, played by Keystone's Ford Sterling, dropping a huge object, this time a big hammer, accidentally on his foot, eliciting a howling scene of pain. Sterling was one of Keystone's "Big 4" comedians, which included Charlie Chaplin. When Chaplin was signed to Keystone by the end of 1913, he was asked to act just like Sterling, which irked the young stage comedian. They did both appeared together in two films in 1914. Sterling's movie career stretched throughout the talkies until 1936. He was an expert photographer, with some of his work exhibited in Paris' Louvre Museum.

And Barry Oldfield was a celebrity himself. He was the speed king of the early 1900's, holding several race car records, including the first to drive over 60 mph on a circular race track.

Archetypal slapstick chase comedy that is sometimes wrongly considered to be the epitome of the cheesy 'girl tied to railroad track' stereotype when it is, in fact, a comical lampoon of the stage melodramas of the day. Easily the best movie Keystone had made up to the date of its release despite Mack Sennett's clunky performance and real-life racing driver Oldfield's complete lack of charisma. Ford Sterling dominates as the 'tache-twirling villain, and the chase sequences are hair-raisingly effective.

Barney Oldfield was like the Mario Andretti, Ricky Bobby or Dale Earnhardt of his day--a racing legend. However, today he's mostly forgotten despite his being the first man to achieve the amazingly fast speed of 60 miles per hour (fine...but at that time it WAS quite the achievement). As a result of his fame, he later went on to appear in a few films--and "Barney Oldfield's Race for Life" is one of them. It's a short comedy from Keystone starring Barney as well as the prolific Mabel Normand and Ford Sterling. Mabel is, as usual, the lady in distress and Sterling, as usual, is the Snidely Whiplash sort who kidnaps her and chains her to the railroad tracks. So, it's up to Oldfield and his partner to race to the rescue and get her before the train can cut her into pieces. Unfortunately, at the end the director had no idea what to do so Sterling just starts killing cops!! None of this (particularly the cop massacre) is funny but at least it had a couple nice stunts and driving sequences. Mostly of historical interest.