Brown of Harvard

Brown of Harvard is a hard movie to pin down. We expect a lot more from our movies these days, so it helps to remember that audiences in the 20's were a bit more innocent. William Haines is charming as the rogue who has to stumble through pain and humiliation to find success and, even, glory. All of the relationships in the movie feel very stilted EXCEPT for the homoerotic tie between Billy and Jack Pickford, the town nerd. The movie has everything, romance, tears, love, death, and even sports... It's a great education in how society has changed in the 20th century.

This is an extraordinary film, that tricks you constantly. It seems to be heading toward cliche at several points, and then something astonishing will happen that genuinely startles. It would give away too much to say much more, but stick with this film and you will be richly rewarded. William Haines is absolutely delightful - he is certainly a star that deserves to be re-discovered. The gay subtext in his relationship with Jack Pickford is amazing - there is even a scene where Haines rubs Pickford's chest (Pickford has a cold). Both actors play this sub-text subtlely and with great depth of emotion, so that there are moments that are very moving. And I never thought I could get so involved in a football match as I did in this movie - and I don't even understand the rules! Also excellent is Francis X. Bushman's son Ralph as Haines' rival for the girl (yes, it's not completely a gay movie). Wonderful silent classic - a great example of Twenties commercial cinema with an edge.

Basically the same plot as William Haines' Tell it to the Marines from the same year, but with the action switched from a military academy to Harvard University. Once again, Haines is something of a jerk, rude and arrogant to his fellow students (apart from the put upon Jack Pickford) and repeatedly forcing himself on pretty Mary Brian, which makes it difficult to root for him in the rousing climactic football game against Yale. This was famously John Wayne's film debut, but you'll be hard pushed to recognise him amongst the Yale team.

I found it difficult to watch this film with a critical eye, as I have limited experience with the silents. However, it was interesting to think that I was watching the heart throbs of the time, in one of the most popular movies of the time. The story of the relationship between Brown and his bookish roommate was, uh, interesting, but overall the story seemed so unrealistic (a partying slacker who happens to be accomplished at all sports, mysterious and unnamed life-threatening illnesses) that I wondered how such a storyline was accepted in 1926, or anytime. Tips from anyone who knows how to appreciate or analyze a silent despite the hamminess would be appreciated.

An American silent drama; A story about a college freshman who faces failure in his athletic endeavors after meeting a girl. This buddy film is directed well with a fine cast performing well. The relationship between the two dorm pals, established from the beginning, runs as a meaningful thread; the love interest for Brown, played by Mary Brian, is sweet and charming and brings all her scenes alive. William Haines as Brown is captivating and plays an arrogant, conceited youth very well, and with good comic timing. The staging of the football scenes made this a real spectacle.