Auf Winnetous Spuren

This is a fun action adventure set in the 18th century that mixed a Jim Bowie type of character with "Last of the Mohicans" as the British Forces in Albany have to treat with their French counterparts in Montreal via the treacherous Iroqouis trail. Thing is, the British are getting bit of a raw deal - and they suspect that there is a spy in their midst. When the young "Sgt. Cutler" (Don Garner) is killed in suspicious circumstances and is subsequently suspected of being that infiltrator, his brother "Nat/Hawkeye" (George Montgomery) sets out to prove his innocence and expose the real culprit. It's a colourful story with plenty of skirmishing, tomahawks and just a hint of romantic swan song from Brenda Marshall as our hero closes in on the traitor, the identity of whom I think we all guess quite quickly... Still, it's a decent effort from all, and I quite enjoyed it.

Although set during the French and Indian War, this suspenceful, fast and violent film is fuelled by strick Film Noir. An innocent man falls deeper into a web of deceit and danger trying to prove his innocence. Director Phil Karlson weaves his powerful style of disturbing close ups, unique twists and turns, unflinching / sudden violence and claustrophobic realism with charactors from James Fennimore Cooper's "Last of the Mohicans". Colorful performances all around particularly from film heavy Sheldon Leonard as a rather sinister Native American Indian. Contains the magical quality that compels you to watch it every six months or so.

I saw this film courtesy of Youtube and was quite impressed. Considering the presumably-small budget it compares well with other versions of "The Last of the Mohicans". It is pared down a bit: Hawkeye only has one Indian sidekick and there's only one daughter at risk from the rapacious Native Americans.

But the plot flows along nicely, the scenes of the besieged fort are adequate and a river chase with canoes is good.

But it did defy credulity that the daughter, "Marion Thorne", was allowed to try to get to the fort from comparative safety through hostile country escorted by one supposedly-trusted Indian, a British officer and a frontiersman and another Indian, the last two being unknown quantities to the British general.

In the version that I saw, there was a jump between the French commander Montcalm announcing that he would offer the British a truce and his men occupying the fort; the first that I knew that a truce had actually been agreed and implemented was when the Indians attacked the fort and overpowered the French guards.

I recently discovered this movie, which is based on the James Fenimore Cooper novel, "The Last of the Mohicans", and stars George Montgomery as Nat Cutler (the "Hawkeye" role). The story takes place along the St Lawrence River and in Albany, in the first years of the French and Indian War and depicts the siege of Ft. William Henry at Lake George.

There's a lot going on, as Nat tries to clear his murdered brother's name (he was an army officer, falsely accused of being a traitor), while Ogane, (Sheldon Leonard) the Huron native posing as a Mohawk scout for the British, is responsible for his death and working for the French. (Because of this, an important dispatch, requesting help from Fort Williams for the Crown Point outpost was not delivered and the British lost Crown Point to the French.) Nat is being helped by Chief Sagamore (Monte Blue), a Delaware native, and they enlist as scouts at Fort William, and act as escorts for Captain West (Glenn Langan), who needs to deliver important dispatches for Col. Thorne (Paul Cavanagh) and for the Colonel's daughter, Marion (Brenda Marshall).

As the story progresses, Nat and Marion fall in love, much to the chagrin of Captain West, who has been paying court to her for quite some time. She has another (very unwelcome) suitor, when Ogave decides he wants her for his wife, despite her being one of the Anglo-Americans he despises. This leads to quite a battle between him and Nat. Also, it must be discovered who the spy is, that's supplying information to French General Montcalm. Meanwhile, both Nat and Sagamore are charged with insubordination.

A lot goes on in this short film. It's worth watching/

Only it is slightly different. We have 'Hawkeye' as played by George Montgomery and one daughter instead of 2 daughters being accompanied to camp by the treacherous Huron Indian. Sheldon Leonard takes on this baddie role as 'Ogane' instead of the more famous 'Magua'.

The film is ok but there are two 'Last of the Mohicans' films that are better - the 1936 version and the 1992 version. So............... watch those instead! This film is a bit complicated to follow and will lose you at the beginning stages. It is not made easy as everyone looks the same. They all wear wigs in the British army and it is confusing as to who is who and what is happening. The film comes across as a poor man's imitation of 'Last of the Mohicans' with one daughter instead of two daughters, and one Indian accomplice for Hawkeye instead of 2. The slight changes to the story take away from the effect of what we know is a better story.

There is a good knife fight when one hand of each of those involved are tied together and Sheldon is the standout character of the film. Unfortunately, Brenda Marshall (Marion) is a peculiar looking woman. She plays the daughter but looks like a middle-aged mother. There is also no way she is a source of desire for Leonard. It just doesn't ring true. I've seen her in another film - "The Sea Hawk" (1940) in which, again, she doesn't convince - there is something weird about her.

This film, does, however, contain the classic Indian greeting - "How". This is the only Indian word that absolutely everyone said at school when we were about 5 years old and I have never ever heard it spoken in a film. In TV comedy sketches, yes, but never in an actual film. So, we get an iconic moment when Leonard delivers this iconic word!

Watch 'Last of the Mohicans' for a more satisfying experience of this tale. It has a better story and ties things up more memorably rather than playing out as a happy families love story as in this effort.