Der große Santini

More common than not, even though it looks rather mean in these "politically correct" times, this is the way many families were back in the 50s.

The racial conflicts shown were very realistic and I'm sad to say did happen in the southern state in which I grew up. This movie does a good job of showing how the head of a family, the Dad, was "expected" to act.

Even though we are lead to believe he was a monster, we never found out that his son grew up to be a doctor of highest esteem.

I have not seen this film in over 20 years, but having been in the Marines, it will always be burned in my memory. You may also have to be, or have been, a Marine to fully appreciate the film (although anyone that has lived under authoritarian rule must feel some sympathy for the situations presented).

Although the film may have been re-cut for video release, I remember Duvall's character as being a fully fleshed out dichotomy of a man who rebelled against authority when submission was called for (his practical jokes while performing military duties) and invoking authoritarianism when more compassion and understanding were called for (his family life).

This is what it was like to be a Marine: The Corps was your family and your family was just an inconvenient duty to be performed for society.

If the movie has been re-edited, I suggest you try to see the original theatrical release, if possible. I found it to be a thoughtful and powerful motion picture.

I could not stand to read Pat Conroy's book because it upset me so much. The critics who reviewed it said that Colonel Wilbur "Bull" Meechum is the man that you will hate to love but you will. Hogwash! I hated him from the very beginning. Bull Mecham was a monster just like Loren Singer was on JAG. He was a great Marine, but a rotten person, husband and father. I don't know if people realize this or not, but Pat Conroy based the character on his father. I have always wanted to write a book and thought it would be a fun experience, however I pity Pat Conroy. This man is one of our finest authors and a true master with the English language, but I'll bet he has never enjoyed writing any of his books because they deal with the pain of his life and growing up in an abusive family with a father who was much, much worse then Bull Mecham! Robert Duvall and Blythe Danner and Michael O'Keefe as Ben all give wonderful performances. O'Keefe was nominated for an Academy Award as best supporting actor for his fine work. I think it is unfair that people think of Danner only as Gwenyth Paltrow's mom because she is a great actress in her own right! I felt so sorry for Lillian and the terrible burden she had to bear with this rotten SON OF A BITCH!!!!Robert Duvall made Mecham a complex character. There were scenes where he was portrayed as caring about his kids. However, I want to tell you something that Pat Conroy wrote in his latest book A Losing Season. He said that when he wrote The Great Santini, he by no means told the truth about his father! Donald Conroy was a monster. He said that his father still haunts his every waking moment. In Fact when his mother finally divorced his father on the grounds of extreme cruelty, she gave the judge at trial a copy of her sons book and said that was how his father really was! I could not stand to watch this movie.

Robert Duvall is magnificent as a classic warrior without a war who moves his family from town to town. Blythe Danner is an excellent match as his wife. And Michael O'Keefe deserves all the kudos he received plus more as Duvall's put-upon son. Lisa Jane Persky strikes a nice balance as the sarcastic-yet-still-loving daughter. Stan Shaw, Paul Mantee, Paul Gleason, and David Keith are flawless in edgy supporting performances. There's perhaps one scene that's slightly overdone which causes me to give it a 9/10 rather than a 10. Otherwise, The Great Santini is an utterly riveting family portrait from start to finish.

This movie is excellent for its first half: crisply delivered, well-developed, it takes chances that you don't see in films made today. Characters like Bull Meechum are usually, in contemporary films, greatly exaggerated or treated with utter contempt (the military dad in American Beauty as a typical example). This film delivers all the way through the basketball game episode.

Then it starts to fall apart. The episode with Toomer and Red seems like a mighty big price to pay just to show Bull's lack of sensitivity and empathy, or anything else it intends to show. Not too long after, Bull himself gets yanked right out of the movie. I really would have appreciated seeing all of these interesting characters resolve their differences - or see things come to a head. I just felt that the movie just quit with 30 minutes to go.

The music was also kind of hit and miss in the last half. For example, when Ben confesses that he prayed for his father's death, the music is inappropriately creepy. It resolves into sorrow, but the net result was kind of off-putting.