Top Gear America

I like Rob as an actor and watch everything he's in but every time he speaks he sounds like he hates cars. The other two hosts seem to have a true love for vehicles but even when Rob praises cars he sounds cynical and not in a funny way. This aspect of the show kinda takes the fun out of it for me. To be clear though there are leaps and bounds above the original cast, although I liked Tanner.

I still like it better than the new s**t show that is Top Gear without the original cast. I honestly can't understand the casting choices in that show period. I'm glad the guys came back on the Grand Tour.

Cast chemistry is weird. They're also trying to do the classic Top Gear joke and poke routine but it's rarely funny and mostly corny

Well made, sure, little rough round the edges compared to the technical standards of the UK edition in it's prime, but at least up to the standard of Motortrends other shows. It's main problem is that the magic between the hosts just isn't there, and it feels waaaaay too scripted - the earlier US team had more of the magic and were more natural hosts. The next is, these guys are acting like they're all stars, when they're unknowns for this audience - Motortrend would have been better off calling up a couple of race drivers or some youtubers. And as for the GeoBlocking, it's time mobs like Motortrend realised that all they get when they limit the audience location, is to get pirated.

It seems like they're trying to reproduce a great show instead of making it their own. Jethro is not a presenter, he's very bland and predictable. They have a great racer already in Dax, bring a good presenter maybe a Danica Patrick or Mike Finnegan to give the show some vehicle expert that has been on TV before. Rob Corddry is a hilarious comedian, let him be funny!

Definitely has some good qualities, the challenges are pretty generic and often don't have much backstory or any real challenge aspect to them.

Has the bones of a good show, but needs some surgery to make it an actual good show.

I'd honestly give it 8/10 for what it is, IF you didn't have to subscribe to the MT app to watch. I'm only mildly interested in cars but still find the show very entertaining and campy in a good way. It's self aware enough to play around in dad joke territory and doesn't take itself too seriously. The result is charming and lighthearted. Cast chemistry is great even though it wouldn't seem to work on paper. That's also part of the charm of the show.