America's Most Musical Family

I love this show! So many amazing and talented families. This show is very unique

Show is really judged poorly. Show does have some really good groups that can sing. The group that goes through is totally mind blowing that the better groups are passed on.

Nick wasn't kidding when they were attempting to do more unscripted content. And so we get shows that are rather unfitting for the network, like America's Most Musical Family. While the Substitute goes well with Nick's comedic style, AMMF is just your typical American Idol / America's Got Talent clone. No offense to Rob Bagshow, but when I think of reality competition shows, I think of the major networks, especially ABC. A show like AMMGF does not fit Nickelodeon whatsoever. Maybe MTV since Lord knows we need more musical themed shows on a so-called "music" channel. I only saw the first couple episodes before my household got rid of cable in favor of Disney Plus. While I did enjoyed some of the talents, I just wasn't impressed that this was on a kids network. Sure, there's a few adults joining in the kids to become the next big thing, but it proves that it should have been on another channel not named Nick. Let's go with the host and judges. Nick Lachey does an okay job as host, but the judges I am very neutral on. I am not the biggest Ciara fan, but she is okay presenting the singers. David Dobrik, on the other hand, looks like he doesn't want to be there. Then again, he is a Youtuber, and not an actual musician (correct me if I'm wrong, I haven't seen much of his works). Debbie Gibson did the best of them all due to her spunk towards the singers. Sorry, Nick, but this is one of your duds. I don't downright dislike it, but I just hate how unfitting it is on a kids network. Everyone can enjoy these type shows if they air on ABC or NBC. 5/10

This show seems like a traditional singing concept meets the modern influencer world, but fails to satisfy both.

First of all, the show seems to focus a lot on the fact that David Dobrik is a judge.. who has no business being a judge on a singing show, he should've been the host - who is supposed to be funny. The remaining judges aren't that famous (considering the target audience is kids and teens watching Nickelodeon). The show also fails to create any sort of character relation (like Simon Cowell and Demi Lovato's subtle fights in-between performances on AGT) - leaving the show without any sort of humour at all.

The only thing this show has going for it, is the families singing - and I have no complaints here, all families are actually good at singing, but the songs alone can't be the only thing that keeps me watching the show!

Over all, I think the show fails to succeed - maybe it would've been more popular, if there was a more modern feel to the show (more fast paced, viewer interaction etc.), not just another singing show.. If they would've had more intriguing judges, a funnier host and had a more modern format, this show would be great.

This is a fun idea and offers some families the opportunity to show off their musical skills!