IMDb-BEWERTUNG
6,3/10
1120
IHRE BEWERTUNG
Winter 1598, die Geschichte der letzten Seeschlacht von Yi Sun-shin während der japanischen Invasion Koreas, die in der Straße von Noryang stattfand.Winter 1598, die Geschichte der letzten Seeschlacht von Yi Sun-shin während der japanischen Invasion Koreas, die in der Straße von Noryang stattfand.Winter 1598, die Geschichte der letzten Seeschlacht von Yi Sun-shin während der japanischen Invasion Koreas, die in der Straße von Noryang stattfand.
- Regie
- Drehbuch
- Hauptbesetzung
- Auszeichnungen
- 3 Nominierungen insgesamt
Yoonseuk Back
- Shimazu
- (as Baek Yoon-Seok)
Empfohlene Bewertungen
As a history lover, the movie was painful to watch from beginning to end. Sure, artists can take certain liberties while telling a story, but nothing in the movie was true to what actually happened.
The order of battle of complete nonsense. The portrayal of factions completely one dimensional: the Japanese are all demonic and fanatical, the Chinese are cowardly and useless,. The Koreans are all heroic and invincible. If that was true, why did the war drag on for seven long years in the first place? How did they manage to lose almost all the land territory without Ming China's help?
At any rate, a thoroughly disappointing movie. More of a caricature than anything else.
The order of battle of complete nonsense. The portrayal of factions completely one dimensional: the Japanese are all demonic and fanatical, the Chinese are cowardly and useless,. The Koreans are all heroic and invincible. If that was true, why did the war drag on for seven long years in the first place? How did they manage to lose almost all the land territory without Ming China's help?
At any rate, a thoroughly disappointing movie. More of a caricature than anything else.
Korean filmmaker once again distorted history by portrayed their rightful and supremacy pride, dismissed chinese contribution.
The Chinese Ming's admiral portrayed as traitor and coward actually considered as hero in china and korea. He is griefing when hear the dead of admiral Yi.
Later his descendant even come to korea and become Gwangdong Jin clan. How his descendant feel when see this distorted movie discredit their ancestor ?.
In part I too (The Admiral: Roaring Currents), the director portrayed Admiral Yi's heroism with only 13 turtle ships when in reality he got help too from Ming's navy.
The Chinese Ming's admiral portrayed as traitor and coward actually considered as hero in china and korea. He is griefing when hear the dead of admiral Yi.
Later his descendant even come to korea and become Gwangdong Jin clan. How his descendant feel when see this distorted movie discredit their ancestor ?.
In part I too (The Admiral: Roaring Currents), the director portrayed Admiral Yi's heroism with only 13 turtle ships when in reality he got help too from Ming's navy.
Sorry for that and no pun intended. Wave games better? Probably not - also even more removed from the show I took to make a joke ... than the stories here .. both Korean at least. But leaving that aside for a moment.
There are more of these movies (General this, General that) ... but it is quite enlightening to watch this one. It may take a while to get started (almost an hour I believe) ... but once it does ... well it goes all out ... on sea! And then some ... the sea battles might be the best ones put to film yet! The last 90 and more minutes are incredible to say the least.
So the visual bombardment (sorry) of it all is quite winning (I mean ... it was right there) ... and all that with the background of being historic ... and I reckon somewhat accurate at least? You have an added bonus scene after the credits roll ... which is important to know - even more so when watching on a streaming platform that tries to force the next thing on you ... therefor making you miss this, if you do not watch ... well out! Over and out!
There are more of these movies (General this, General that) ... but it is quite enlightening to watch this one. It may take a while to get started (almost an hour I believe) ... but once it does ... well it goes all out ... on sea! And then some ... the sea battles might be the best ones put to film yet! The last 90 and more minutes are incredible to say the least.
So the visual bombardment (sorry) of it all is quite winning (I mean ... it was right there) ... and all that with the background of being historic ... and I reckon somewhat accurate at least? You have an added bonus scene after the credits roll ... which is important to know - even more so when watching on a streaming platform that tries to force the next thing on you ... therefor making you miss this, if you do not watch ... well out! Over and out!
Entire movie is talking, talking, talking, translating from Chinese to Korean, adding the time of this movie to be a lot longer. Fine, this is how it actually happened, using translators. Then 30 minutes of amazing battle scene and then 20-30 minutes of slow motion of the battle scene that completely killed the entire movie. Why? Why waste my time slowing everything down for that long? I guess the director and the editor keep falling asleep when they watch the movie and forgot to edit things out or dragged the slow motion and fell asleep. At a certain point the battle becomes repetitive, the scenes of people's reaction is beyond repetitive. The banging of the drum should be normal pave to keep the momentum of the fight and then gradually slow it down. But nope.. total one hour wasted watching this 2 hours and 30 minutes movie.
I believe there are inaccuracies in many Korean historical movies as they often portray events in a way that may not align with historical facts. This movie again proves my point because it is misleading and does not represent the actual history. It is essential to acknowledge that during the invasion, Korea was in a vulnerable position and relied on China for support. Japan most likely would defeat Korea without China's navy. While stating this, I understand that sharing these views might provoke adverse reactions from some individuals. However, it is crucial to realize that distorting historical events will not change the reality of the past.
Besides the historical inaccuracy, this movie is slow and puts me to sleep. I was only awakened by the battle scene. I would not recommend this work to any historical movie lovers.
Besides the historical inaccuracy, this movie is slow and puts me to sleep. I was only awakened by the battle scene. I would not recommend this work to any historical movie lovers.
Wusstest du schon
- WissenswertesAlle Einträge enthalten Spoiler
- VerbindungenFollows Der Admiral - Roaring Currents (2014)
Top-Auswahl
Melde dich zum Bewerten an und greife auf die Watchlist für personalisierte Empfehlungen zu.
Details
- Erscheinungsdatum
- Herkunftsland
- Offizielle Standorte
- Sprachen
- Auch bekannt als
- Noryang: Deadly Sea
- Produktionsfirmen
- Weitere beteiligte Unternehmen bei IMDbPro anzeigen
Box Office
- Bruttoertrag in den USA und Kanada
- 315.245 $
- Eröffnungswochenende in den USA und in Kanada
- 19.333 $
- 24. Dez. 2023
- Weltweiter Bruttoertrag
- 34.210.966 $
- Laufzeit
- 2 Std. 32 Min.(152 min)
- Farbe
- Sound-Mix
- Seitenverhältnis
- 2.35 : 1
Zu dieser Seite beitragen
Bearbeitung vorschlagen oder fehlenden Inhalt hinzufügen