Die größten Rivalen im Cricket: Indien gegen Pakistan

While I enjoyed watching this 3 part show, this felt....very incomplete and wasn't what I expected it to be. The show is primarily from Sehwag and Shoaib Akthar's POV and the roles they played in the India's tour of Pakistan.

The cricket rivalry is more than the one tour and while there's some political context provided, it's not enough to do justice to the title of the doc. I understand that given the vast (cricketing) history between both these nations, it's not easy to make a documentary but just call it "2004 India tour of Pakistan" instead of making it sound like it's about the cricketing history. Plus, it's misleading this is mainly about the ICT making history in bilateral competition. If that's what you're going for, go all out telling the story from India's POV but they didn't do that either.

It's always fun to listen to people share stories and context you may not have known behind real life events, that was the only fun part about the show. But as much as I liked listening to everybody speak, it wasn't what was sold to me and it was too less. I mean, how do you make a documentary about India vs Pakistan cricket without the T20 final?

Watch it anyway, but go in without expectations and go in to listen to a handful of players talk about the context behind ONE series and you'll probably not be disappointed.

As a passionate cricket fan, I was excited to watch The Greatest Rivalry: India vs Pakistan (2025), expecting a well-rounded portrayal of this iconic contest. However, the documentary felt more like The Virender Sehwag Story rather than a true exploration of the India-Pakistan cricketing legacy.

While Sehwag's contributions were phenomenal, the documentary largely overlooked other legendary players who shaped this rivalry. Sachin Tendulkar's iconic battles, Sourav Ganguly's fearless leadership, Rahul Dravid's resilience, and Virat Kohli's unforgettable knock in recent times deserved more attention. MS Dhoni's fearless batting against Pakistan in his early days. The likes of Yuvraj Singh, Suresh Raina, and other key figures who played crucial roles in these encounters were barely acknowledged.

A rivalry of this magnitude isn't defined by just one player-it's a saga of countless unforgettable moments and legendary performances from both sides. The documentary could have been even better with more episodes and a deeper dive into these iconic stories that fans would have loved to relive.

You make a series on indo-pak from 1999-2005, with no mention of Sachin's batting exploits ? Even if it is pivoting on two series- 1999 and 2004, where are Sachin's great innings of Chennai, Rawalpindi or even Multan? The tide of the rivalry changed with Sachin's centurion knock- no mention of that? Sachin's catch of inzamam that turned the final ODI or that Googly to moin in Multan ?

Yaaawn! Same old tropes- Pakistan bowling great, sehwag's daredevilry.. tired of them now!

4 points- for Ganguly, Osman, Inzamam , Waqar interviews.. too much time to Akhtar and Sehwag interviews.

Even in the cursory Sachin tribute in the beginning- u talk about his 1992 World Cup exploits and video shows him batting in Sharjah in 1998.. why call it greatest rivalry- essentially it is only about 2 series, which too are inadequately researched... Might as well call it - Sehwag and Akhtar show.

Yet to see a good sports documentary coming from India.

I haven't seen a bigger waste of opportunity in a documentary ever. They missed so many big names of the rivalry. Why even bother making such a half-cooked documentary if you couldn't manage to get the players' interviews? And if it's supposed to deal with India vs Pakistan tours back in the 2000s, what's Ashwin and Dhawan doing in all of these? The shock factors make absolutely no sense. Shehwag and Akhtar were probably the only ones they could manage and made them blabber throughout the 3 episodes. Cringe, pathetic and a horrible attempt at a documentary. Not to mention, pretty damn biased as well.

I was so excited to watch this but truely a dissapointed documentary. I felt as if only sehwag and shoaib akhtar led all India pakistan matches. Clearly missed out on some real good matches. Where was sachin, Kumble, V prasad, Amir sohail, afridi, saeed anwar... those were true legends of those era... A big big opportunity lost...on what could have been a series that could have brought our childhood memories back but i felt it didnt showcase relevant matches. Wish someone else would have directed this with some better juiciness that used to exist during the india pakistan matches. Was good in bits and pieces.