El hombre de la estación

I rented this film because I wanted to see Julie Christie and Donald Sutherland act in tandem once more, almost two decades after their bravura performances in "Don't Look Now" They did not disappoint the second time around. The acting was superb, which is to be expected, but the story is also well-developed and especially in this post 9/11 climate,timely. Films such as this, which can deal with the larger themes of terrorism and political unrest while still being able to fully develop the more personal themes of love, loss and redemption among middle-aged lovers are rare; films that can do this well are rarer still. I highly recommend "The Railway Station Man." If only Donald Sutherland and Julie Christie were paired more often.......

Christine

So this film came on just at the perfect time, for me and my wife to watch it, this is vary rare that we would watch a film during the week, but maybe a good omen?

The scenery is obviously stunning, giving a beautiful, yet stark setting for the characters to develop and the story to unfold.

I liked the minimal themes, there was no clutter that needed removing.

Acting was great - pace was fine, but for me, so much time was (rightly) spent watching the relationships developing, that the ending was rushed. It deserved more than that. Plus a character deliberately disturbs the couple at the end, when they knew not to... so it doesn't really make sense. It's as if the director thought, you know what let's just do this and we can all go home...

Shame, as not really seen anything like this before... loved the tucked in denim shirts though... very 90s...

This movie stars two actors at the top of their game, Julie Christie and Donald Sutherland. Oddly, the British actress plays an Irishwoman and the Canadian actor plays an American. Regardless, they are both excellent in the film...and it's a shame the writing isn't better.

Helen lost her husband when he was accidentally murdered by the IRA. Oops. Some time later, Roger comes into her life and slowly the sparks begin to fly. You wonder if the couple stand a chance...and the answer is NO!

This movie, though very well acted, really frustrated me. While it sure seems like a romance, the ending is so abrupt and unromantic it left me frustrated. I can only assume the same was true for others, as you'd expect a film like this to have a higher overall score.

Watching this movie felt like going to a fancy restaurant...and instead of bringing you the dessert you ordered, the waiter just pelts you with dead fish. It's unexpected and most unwelcome at the end.

What a load of rubbish.

Donald Sutherland with dyed orange hair - which it appears he must have cut himself - and a ridiculously long artificial lower arm with a hook on the end, tries to seduce Julie Christie. She adopts a rictus grin as a bizarre means of appearing to be Irish. At one point he pulls up her skirt with his hook and appears to have sex even though she is still wearing her woolly tights. When they do go to bed he still keeps his shirt on. The whole thing seems to have been filmed in a day, as Donald always appears in exactly the same clothes, and every time we meet the IRA man from Dublin, he is eating a Twirl. A truly dreadful film never far from becoming as farcical as Father Ted.

Parts of this movie are really enjoyable, but the end result is so disappointing, I can't recommend The Railway Station Man. The upside is Julie Christie. She's so adorable in this movie, from her spunky personality to her cozy knit socks, from her plaid skirts to her swing dancing. Had her character been placed in a different, more even story, I'd want to watch more movies about her. She raises her son alone, after her husband was killed in a tragic mistaken identity shooting, and it's no wonder she catches the attention of most folks in her small, Irish town. With her son grown, she feels free to seek out more than just her hobby painting for fun. She meets the badly crippled railway station man, Donald Sutherland, and they hit it off. Will her son understand her need for romance? And will her son be safe, as he starts to get involved with the wrong crowd?

If I were to ascribe one word to this movie, it would be uneven. There's full frontal male nudity as John Lynch prances around in the ocean, an unexplained thaw in Donald's coldness towards Julie, an unexplained chill after Julie decides she likes Donald, a strange flirtation with her son's friend, and random IRA violence. And why is Donald continually cast in movies where he's supposed to be British? In this one, he has artificial red hair but no trace of an accent. Again, why? But Julie is cute as a button with wonderful energy. If I lived in that town, I would love to be her friend!