Grafted

The 1950s, a time when color film was still pricey and beyond the reach of the independent producers, was the decade when horror came into its own. There were no tropes and set pieces because everything was new and fresh. Often the scripts were written on the back of a napkin, and the ending was more about how much money was left in the budget than anything else. The good news is that GRAFTED captures this spirit perfectly, the viewer never knows what is going to happen next. The bad news is that a film should be about more than grabbing attention, it really should have a sense of direction. And this one does not. Nice start, but clearly the budget ran out somewhere along the way. ((Designated "IMDb Top Reviewer." Please check out my list "167+ Nearly-Perfect Movies (with the occasional Anime or TV miniseries) you can/should see again and again (1932 to the present))

One of the most important, yet somehow still so often neglected elements of storytelling - virtually any storytelling - is empathy. After all, you have probably heard of the Six Deadly Words ("I Don't Care For These People") but are they not really fundamentally about the failure of empathy? Not so much on the side of the viewer that is, but rather because the creator failed to write characters worth emphasizing with - often because they are written as mere tools and lack an inner world you can relate to.

Empathy is exactly what sets this New Zealand thriller apart in its first half. Sasha Rainbow's previous experience consisted of two documentary shorts which both chronicle the lives of the underclass in two cultures very different from hers, and here, she is able to depict the clash between the immigrant protagonist Wei and her second-generation, fully Westernized cousin Angela remarkably well for this kind of film. You can easily understand well why both of them act the way they do, and even the supporting cast also feels a lot more humanized than usual (certainly FAR more so than the cast of The Substance - since the comparisons between the two films are practically inescapable due to the unfortunate release timing, I might as well get it over with now.)

Funnily enough, the 2nd half, which delivers what most of the audience must have come here for, actually felt like a letdown to me in comparison, as it feels much more "on-rails". The performances are still effective and one character's demise is so painfully unfair it cuts through emotionally much more than most horror deaths do. The "grafting" is filmed well enough considering the limitations of low-budget filmmaking, though it would have certainly been more impressive in the pre-Substance world. On the other hand, the plain murder scenes themselves can be quite contrived and often aren't really convincing when compared not just to, say, something relatively recent When Evil Lurks, but also rather older films like Alleluia.

On the whole, though, this is a very admirable debut effort and I believe Sasha Rainbow is going to be the one to watch. I would also like to point out that this is the first movie I have seen in 2025 where I almost immediately looked up the OST after watching the film. To me, it's that good, at times absolutely carrying a scene which would have probably fallen flat otherwise.

There's some compelling drama in the first half of the movie. Things spiral out of control in an organic, chaotic way.

We get a very strong character development.

It's body horror but nothing too crazy. It could have gone for a little more gore but it's adequate how it is.

This is not an incredible movie by any means. But it has a fair amount of compelling story that is often lacking.

It deserves more than 5. But also doesn't have enough of an "it" factor to be a great movie.

There's some character and situational cliches.

It's a very entertaining movie with some emotional elements.

Ultimately it's a pleasantly average movie. Not sure why I'm writing this review other than 5/10 seeming a little too low.

It's something you can throw on if you need a movie.

Not a whole lot to say. Actors did their best with a terrible script, nonsensical screenplay and an average director. So many plot holes, abundant head scratching moments that pull you out of the experience entirely...

The average-ish performances earned the movie 3 stars, but they are clearly hindered by an amateur writer and a woeful screenplay, not a whole lot makes sense, nor does it seem plausible. And I mean that in a way that it still doesn't make sense or seem plausible when you suspend disbelief, like you have to with most horror movies (although there is nothing scary about this movie, it plays more like a drama-comedy).

The premise is good on paper, and with a proper writer, director and screenplay (and half a million extra $'s), this could have been a solid 6-7/10. Alas, it is nothing more than a below par evening time-killer.

The film starts really strong, ushering in a blend of Chinese and Kiwi aesthetics, and offering a premise that's erupting with potential. The opening scene sets the tone for gory, skin-crawling events to follow. The first act easily won me over, and that's because I could connect to the protagonist Wei's struggles as an immigrant trying to fit in (given her childhood trauma and deformity), and possibly make her mark in academics. While both these core conflicts take centerstage, the body horror elements somehow fail to work (from a screenplay perspective), even when the special make-up effects are gnarly and effective. Scenes suddenly lack cohesion and the plausibility of certain events is heavily questionable (for instance, no one noticed the abrupt changes in height and weight?). The final act lands unconvincingly, and the film decides to go for maximum shock value. The performances also fail to evoke greater emotions, and the conclusion feels rather tame. The Substance, this is NOT.