Christmas on 5th Avenue

7.3 stars.

The story begins with a woman named Eva who helps people improve their lives. She takes on a challenge to spruce up a very rich author's Manhattan apartment for the holidays. She discovers there is more depth to this man than at first, and he's not the scrooge that he appears to be. The rest of the story is about how she helps Lucas find happiness, and he fills the hole she's had in her hopelessly romantic heart. The theme is about finding happiness with the people in our lives no matter who they seem to be or what station they currently hold. We bring our genuine self to the table and that's how true love is revealed to us.

The film has a lot of slow moments and takes its time delivering the goods. I stuck with it in the hopes that I'd be blessed by something and I wasn't disappointed, however you must be patient with 'Christmas on 5th Avenue' because the gems don't show up until the last 30 minutes.

A sunny, kindhearted girl thaws the heart of an embittered, grieving Scrooge. What could be more suitable for a Christmas story? That she may be a little too forceful in her affection or he a little too reluctant and harsh, it could be overlooked. Unfortunately, while Kathryn Davis is charming and convincing in her role, the acting of Olivier Renaud is amateurish, at best. In many scenes, especially when expected to express strong unpleasant emotions or real affection, he looks uncomfortable and quite off-mark. He seems better suited for the job of a fashion model, than a real actor. The uneasiness of those scenes destroy the little magic this movie could have delivered.

I thought this movie was really cute. Good cast with great chemistry and solid performances. I liked the costumes and dialog.

I watched it more than once and would watch it again.

This movie is carried by Kathryn Davis as Eva. "Eva loves life, darling, and she's not afraid to live it." And it's fund to watch her live it. Why she sets her sights on Lucas baffles me, but the world definitely needs people like her. There is an exchange where Lucas accuses Eva of "doing it for money" and she responds that she has to eat and pay the rent and he doubles down on the accusation. By that point in the movie, it's clear money isn't what motivates her, and Lucas should be able to see that.

Olivier Renaud, as Lucas, is a cold fish in this movie. He never really shakes that even as Eva supposedly reforms him. There really isn't chemistry between the leads. And Lucas' response to all Eva does makes no sense. Whatever response he makes seems to be mostly internal. While Davis carries the move, Renaud holds it back.

Still, it's indicative how appealing Eva's personality is such that the movie is still enjoyable.

The story premise is a slight twist on the trope where a cabin is double booked for two strangers. In this case, it's Lucas' condo.

Christmas On 5th Avenue (2021)-

I find it unlikely that he would agree to her staying at his house. I know that I would be furious if someone interrupted my "Special alone time". And her arguments to stay would not persuade me even if I thought that she was attractive. Furthermore I would have to ask her to leave as soon as I realised just how hyperactive and "Always On" she was.

I'd rather let the creative juices flow my way without her, instead of this barrage of Christmas from a crazy lady. And I love Christmas!

Olivier Renaud is gorgeous, a great leading man and that bottom is desperately trying to break free from those trousers, what a beaut. He deserved better support all around.

That Christmas tree however is awful, what a twig!? Why do they let the props people get away with this?

Some of the other actors are terrible and the sets quite questionable, especially the theatre balcony.

It's not a bad story, but it's hard to believe how it all begins. It puts me in mind of "Trading Christmas" (2011), which I actually enjoy, but I might have turned this one off if it hadn't been for Oliver, his effortless acting and his tight trousers.

7ish/10?