Black Dog (Cara de perro)

A beautiful, slow-burn, and memorizing tale of the grim environment of the rural parts of China with strong performances, direction, writing, and structure. Filmmaker Guan Hu achieves with exploring the relationship between man and dog from a Chinese perspective and filled with gorgeous camerawork, sound designs, and interesting narrative choices, it brings out the realism, engagement, and examination of the characters in a nature way.

With little dialogue, the sobering approach, art-house pacing, and style really brings the narrative into a whole new light. The performances from Eddie Peng and the rest of the cast are great and many of the characters, while some characters could have been explored a little better. I appreciate the movie on exploring about dogs, humanism and society without a biased approach and crafting something that is unique.

Having won the Un Certain Regard prize, I can see why.

This movie is not what I have expected. I was forced to sit through it with a very uninteresting viewing experience. The screen play is quite boring, loosely knitted together with no energy, no steam at all, but just a lifeless narration. What we saw in this movie is a dying town in the northern China, the livelihood is totally gone after the mining business died. What left is a pathetic town with so many ruined and empty buildings, just like what we saw in Flint, Indiana. The leading character, the protagonist as movie critics or veteran reviewers used to describe, Peng, seems to be an bad choice for such ex-con character, a complete out-of-the-place actor to play this role. His dialogue in this movie is minimum in order to portray that this guy is a loner who belongs to nowhere, even in prison, albeit his so-called hometown. There is not much to tell in this movie, and I really failed to see how the director of this movie would have won some nominations as the best director. Maybe less is more is the current trendy. Making a black stray dog as the co-acting role is just not interested enough to stimulate my urge that would give me any passion or empanthy to the whole storyline. I felt quite impatient when I watched this movie. All of the characters who appeared in this movie, those folks, young or old, cops or civilians who tried to get by in a dying town are interested enough, just like their boring dialogue to each other, to the leading role who looked more like a half dumb or deaf person. If a town is dying, if all the town folks are poor, if all of them lose hope, if their daily lives are all so boring, what would enable to make a movie interesting? Even you put a seasoned actor like Peng to play the leading character, how much he could possibly make this boring town with so many boring town folks become a bit more interesting? A spiritless young man and a black stray dog is as boring as Hemingway's "The Old Man and The Sea", other than somewhat literary values that usually was glorified as "Literature". Trying to tell you that "Black Dog" has certain philosophic depth is just a pretentious view that tries to look deep. How could you get anything out of nothing?

The Gobi desert is impressive in its desolation, but what's even more so is the desolation of this run-down small town just before the Beijing Olympic Games from 2008. I don't think I have ever seen something quite like it, on screen or in reality. This is dystopia on earth, in the not so distant past. I guess it's the only thing quietly criticizing the regime or showing the failure of Chinese society, good thing the movie is focused on something else entirely and probably that's how it got past censorship, but I am still impressed.

No animals were harmed during the making of this movie. Kidding. No, but seriously, I do not understand how they made this movie. Packs of stray dogs, it's the humans that are guilty. How many dogs this town has managed to abandon is again impressive.

Should have ended with the animals roaming free on the town streets, that felt like the climax of the movie and had a bit of a surreal feel.

Is dog man the equivalent of cat lady?

It didn't quite work for me, despite what my eyes were able to take in. I couldn't connect to the character or even root for him in particular. The plot felt aimless. Those bozos chasing him for revenge kept popping up and doing the most heinous things and then they would let it go. And then again. It made no sense. And honestly after the snakes they were irredeemable. In fact quite a lot of questionable characters here. Our lead is not particularly sympathetic either.

But OMG Jia Zhangke acts in this movie! I was actually comparing the look to Unknown Pleasures. I guess he wanted to support the movie.

It's a good movie and i wish i would have liked it more and rated it higher. It's so well directed that made me somewhat enjoy it even though nothing significant was happening, specifically during the first 50 minutes. The parallelism between the leading character and this dog was spot-on, the development of their "relationship" as well.

But still, there are some big flaws. First of all, its running time. It should have been at least 15 minutes shorter. I said i enjoyed it but it was too uneventful at some point. I love poetic and minimalist movies but not like this. Story is almost beautiful but simple, there was no reason to stretch it out so much. Ok, it was beautifully shot but after all, it was mostly an urban landscape.

And as another reviewer already mentioned, at times "The plot felt aimless". I didn't understand the entirety of what happened in this movie. Random things kept happening without promoting the story.

However, despite its flaws, this is a good and ambitious movie, well directed as i said but well acted too. The leading character was silent but as a viewer, i understood him, i felt his alienation, his quite desperation and his bond with this dog, the whole thing was touching and natural, not for a moment it felt fake. There were some gorgeous scenes, a great soundtrack with Pink Floyd's songs which were used so effective. And the ending was powerful.

A meditative movie which could have been so much better.

Outstanding drama directed by Hu Guan from China, so, no wonder it won the top honour in the Un Certain Regard sidebar at Cannes for this year.

The story revolves around a guy who, following a period of incarceration, comes home and takes a job ridding a town of stray dogs in time for the Olympic Games. The drama is set on the edge of the Gobi desert in Northwest China. However, he unexpectedly bonds with a black dog, and the two of them set out on a new adventure.

The dog star of the movie took home a dog award earlier in the day when he received the Palm Dog Grand Jury prize! If you love dogs, amazing cinematography, exceptional acting and directing - do not miss this one... impossible not to enjoy it!