Trivia

Learned to play drums for her role in Scott Pilgrim vs. los ex de la chica de sus sueños (2010).

When she first auditioned for Confesiones de una típica adolescente (2004), the director, Sara Sugarman turned her down, as she had a more androgynous appearance in mind for the character of Ella. Pill took pictures of herself as a boy and auditioned a second time, and finally got the part.

Gave birth to her 1st child at age 30, a daughter named Wilder Grace Leonard on November 19, 2016. Child's father is her husband, Joshua Leonard.

Was engaged to actor Jay Baruchel from December 2010 until March 2013.

Nominated for the 2006 Tony Award for Best Featured Actress in a Play for "The Lieutenant of Inishmore".

Her favourite actress is Patricia Clarkson, whom she worked with on Momentos de perdón (2003).

As of 2019, she has been in 3 films that were Oscar nominated for Best Picture: Milk: Un hombre, una revolución, una esperanza (2008), Medianoche en París (2011), and El vicepresidente: más allá del poder (2018).

(May 24, 2015) Married her longtime boyfriend Joshua Leonard following a 4-month-long engagement.

Is of Estonian and distant Swedish descent.

Is a fan of the band Coldplay, and often camps out to buy tickets for their concerts.

Appearing in an off-Broadway play "The Distance from Here" with Melissa Leo, Mark Webber and Anna Paquin. (junio de 2004)

Off-Broadway show "Blackbird" opposite Jeff Daniels at Manhattan Theatre Club Stage II. (marzo de 2007)

Is friends with Lorna Luft, whom she played in Life with Judy Garland: Me and My Shadows (2001).

Currently portraying Annie Sullivan in The Miracle Worker on Broadway. (marzo de 2010)

Her paternal grandparents were Estonian.

Currently appearing off-Broadway in Neil LaBute's "Reasons to be Pretty . . ." which will transfer to Broadway in the fall of 2008. (junio de 2008)

Appearing on Broadway in Theresa Rebeck's "Mauritius". (septiembre de 2007)

Appearing in the Broadway play "The Lieutenant of Inishmore" at the Lyceum Theater, New York City (abril de 2006)