Can You Keep a Secret?

I thought this movie looked so cute! But this fell so flat for me. There was no script, no chemistry, no connection and no humor. What happened with this? While she hasn't picked the best roles yet, Alexandria Daddario deserved better. It just felt like a complete mess. Please skip if you care about any of the things I mentioned.

I'm sure people just want to be mad and hate everything, this film isn't that bad but you'd think it was the worst thing ever from some of the reviews.

Yes I've read the book, I think it's unfair to compare the two as the book is always going to be better. I've never seen a film that's better than the book

It's quite clearly a romcom so expectations should be far more realistic. And nit picking about the plot.....it's fiction. Just switch off and let it wash over you and enjoy, that's what films are made for.

The movie started off charming and a little bit funny and different. It quickly ran off the tracks and went down hill with a plot line with no actual development and a love story that was weak. It was super corny and awkward to watch.

Good performances and directing, and I enjoyed the humor at the start, but then the story tanked with a sappy romance story and no laughs.

I can see how the story itself could have made for a great rom-com ( I heard that it was a beloved book) but this film is so poorly done. The whole things seems low budget, like a cheesy made-for-TV movie. The writing, directing, and acting are all horrible. The supporting characters seem so immature and unrealistic. Then they awkwardly throw in several f-words, silly sexual scenes and lewd references or discussions which just don't play well. It's like they couldn't decide if they wanted to do a sweet rom-com or a raunchy comedy so they fell short on both. I'm not a picky moviegoer but this is just not worth the time In My Humble Opinion!