What If... Captain Carter Were the First Avenger?

Needed at least 15 more minutes to breathe and tell the story smoothly . Impressive animation and visuals. Surely things could only get better. Glad Marvel is taking constant risks first with the shows n now with this. Really looking forward to the future episodes.

Just watched the first episode, so chose to write the review while it's still fresh.

I liked it a lot, the animation is amazing and the voice acting is nice too. Josh Keaton's voice is incredibly resemblant to Chris Evans', I wouldn't have noticed the change if I didn't know about it before watching.

I liked to see the changes in the story of The First Avenger following the experiment with Peggy Carter, loved seeing skinny Steve Rogers again and hearing Sebastian Stan's voice for Bucky. The score is awesome too and I'm very excited to see how everything's going to connect.

Can't wait to watch episode 2, bring it on, Marvel!

This felt rushed and the writing was weak, not a great episode to start off this new show - hopefully it improves!

I went into this with low expectations...I'm and very glad that this episode exceeded my expectations. Amazing animation. Love how one small decision can change so much. And Jeffrey Wright is perfect in this role.

This one episode took everything good about the first Captain America movie and put an even bigger and better twist! The ending!!!!!! AHHHHHHH!!!!!!

The story is short and very fast paced, so for anyone in a hurry, watching this episode is a great option IF you are an MCU fan. And that's a big if since I believe the story would not be as effective if the audience was not already familiarized with the first Captain America movie. Without the established MCU, the episode is at best just good enough. But having watching the previous films makes it much more enjoyable with the references and how the story unfolds in a similar direction but with a different perspective. It stays true to the characters and I just enjoyed so much watching them again with a different setting. Definitely recommended to anyone who enjoys the Marvel characters.