Part III

Why did Disney/Star Wars decide to get rid of a lot of the classic orchestrated music during some of the most important scenes throughout this episode? Without it, Star Wars just doesn't feel like Star Wars... too modern, no sense of real tension and emotion. Is it being saved for the end/ more climactic scenes? If yes, that's too bad that we only get to have Obi-Wan's orchestrated piece by John Williams (and maybe some classic existing ones will be played later on?).

Something feels off with the look and feel, sometimes the image feels too digital like a fan film, and a lot of the CGI doesn't even feel on par with the prequels. The lighting is dull, as well as the set-piece, and without orchestrated music, that entire combination felt really low budget.

Something's off with the lightsabers... something just doesn't feel right, they don't look as powerful, and they look shorter than they should be, the sound effects are also not as powerful.

But besides those negative points, Ewan McGregor is great as Obi-Wan, so 6/10, average at best.

Of canceling my Disney Plus account.

Admittedly, I was still entertained by the episode and I love the potential/premise of the show in general.

The problem? It's fatally flawed in execution and has failed to capitalize on even a bit of the potential that was there.

The acting was uneven, the plot had more holes than any cheese and the directing felt scattered and underwhelming.

With the budget they had, I would have hoped they could have done this show justice.

I'm entertained, but wildly disappointed at the same time.

Every Vader and kenobi moment is great.

But I'm starting to wonder who the show is really about. Because this feels like book of Fett where everyone steals the show away...not because they are good,....nope, you are hard left pulled in elsewhere from the shows namesake by the director to lesser content.

Seems more like a Reva and Leia show...which is highly disappointing.

Both characters are ok, but not main character level. Ir at least how it's been show thus far. And they have really long strained scenes to try and justify their purpose

Reva has zero intimidating aspects and seems to revolve around an off and on force sense

3rd episode with terribly bad chase scenes

Loved the Tala character.

Pacing is odd. We have seen 3 epic and We have only 3 episodes left and we have really gone no where so far. All these meeting points and chases are so contrived with no logic at all. Like Reva suddenly force trips on a secret tunnel and suddenly suddenly can walk to the end of the tunnel from the outside and knows where it is? Or Vader can track Ben down in between hills. But he can't continue to chase Ben after a fire in the way. Even with a new hike crew of troopers.

Funniest part was when my wife asked me if this was fan made, because the main Jedi is really good at acting. Granted, she doesn't follow SW at all, but it speaks to the quality and logic in the plot and script that is not present.

To me this was a step up from the first two episodes! I now feel like we are getting closer to the show i expected it to be! There are still some cringe stuff but not as bad as episode 1 and 2(chases *cough*)! Other Than that there were some great standout moments! Fatih is slightly restored!

Sorry but there's clearly false voting going on here.....An objectively atrocious episode that has NO respect for the canon and lore of either A New Hope or Revenge of the Sith has an 8.0 on IMDB?

NO!

JUST NO!

This episode is absolute TRASH with no redeeming value whatsoever!