Long, Long Time

I tried to understand and level with a lot of other people who disliked or even hated this episode because it didn't feel like story straight out of the game. Although i feel when you make a TV series whether it's from a game or a book, creating back story is a key element otherwise certain characters may seem a little flat especially major characters. Bill was only in the game for a short while and we only met Frank's body after he'd already ended his life, so when you convert this to a TV series it seems a little shallow for development if said characters are an appear and dismiss without knowing about them first.

I don't look at this as a filler, more of an expansion on character.

An emotional love story in a world so torn apart. I loved every minute of it and i nearly cried.

Yes it was different from the game, maybe they could have stuck to the roots a bit more. Although i can't see it as a terrible episode.

Allow me to begin by prefacing my review: I'm a straight male, married with children and religious. That has no bearing on my perception of this episode. I've seen everything from 60's television onwards.

From The Andy Griffith Show, MASH, I Love Lucy, Cheers, Sanford and Son, All in the Family, up to The Sopranos, Prison Break, Breaking Bad, House of Cards, Narcos, and everything in between. This single episode affected me more than all of those shows ever could.

It did so by appealing to my heart and showing me who we truly are - we're vulnerable, afraid, lonely, brave, loving, protective, strong and weak all at the same time - we're human! And we're fortunate enough to have witnessed, in my humble opinion, the greatest television episode ever made.

The writing was coherent, nuanced and brilliant, the pace was perfectly maintained from scene to scene, the acting was tender and reciprocated so seamlessly from one actor to the next. And the attention to the most minute details from the choice of song to the symbolism of the strawberries. Every second was shot with purpose and maintained the singular underlying philosophy that regardless of what the world may throw at us we are always striving to find our purpose in the eyes of our loved ones.

I hope people can set aside their differences and marvel at the brilliance that is this artful, heartfelt depiction of the human condition set against a backdrop of despair and danger.

My sincerest gratitude to everyone involved in the making of this episode.

Just give Offerman the Emmy. Yes, slightly different from the game sure. But, it's expected it would differ from the game. What a great performance. Moving, performance. There's a reason the game is one of the most awarded of all-time, and it's not because of fancy graphics. The story is phenomenal, and they're carrying it tremendously to the TV adaptation.

My one slight gripe is the game had Joel was a bit more angry then in the series. He was much more angry over the events that happened in the past, and took it out on Elle a lot more. But, that's just a minor thing to note. The episode otherwise is brilliant, and I can't wait for the rest of the series.

Just wow. Each episode goes one step further in intensity, drama, and expanding on the game universe. I truly enjoy they give more backstory to characters and events without straying too far from teb source material.

This show consistently pulls no punches, and shows a deeply intimate view of an apocalypse. In ways shows like walking dead couldn't quite touch. They gave bill so many more dimensions than just survivalist curmudgeon. The absolute heartbreak.

I can't wait to see where this show continues to go. Though I don't think they'll get to the end of the game by the end of this season. And I am a-ok with stretching it out.

I can still vividly remember watching this episode for the first time and just started bawling my eyes out because its so tragic. One of the most beautiful hours of television I have ever seen and it's so heartbreaking. I have seen the controversy that this episode is a waste of time but I have never felt or understood that. This episode earns its place in these season, delivering such an emotionally powerful story that offers so much context to this world and humanizes such a bleak world. One of my favorite episodes of television, and possibly this shows best. A deeply powerful episode that will live in my head forever.