Brother

I was really excited about this film as I too am an immigrant that grew up in the Toronto suburbs, on the west side, in Mississauga, but the feel and reality of living in the apartment blocks reminded me of my own experiences in such neighborhoods.

The toil, taking multiple buses each and every day to make it on time to sub par underpaid minimum wage job. Working long hours and overtime to get that 1.5x bump... I could totally understand the predicament this family found themselves in and the sacrifices they made to keep their heads above water.

That said, being polish racial profiling was not an extra burden that we had to carry. Still it was easy to feel out of place around those that had big houses multiple cars and seemingly little hardship in comparison...

Luckily, with two working parents doing overtime to the max, we were able to buy a semi-detached house in the burbs. When I turned 16, I could drive the parents car and the old life felt like a bad nightmare.

I remember for 5 years after moving to our new house, in the burbs these recuring dreams of waking up in the old apartment, carpets in the hallway that needed to be changed last decade, garbage chute smelling foul as you got close to it, the stairways reeking of urine you wake up in a cold sweat being glad it was only a nightmare.

Could it have been different with only 1 parent and police profiling, you bet!

Brothers, a metaphor of love.

At first glance, this is a film about human dignity and family unity. However, it does not stop there. In its multiple layers, it explores other weighty and complex themes. Such as the fear that comes with daring to seek an identity in a society filled with prejudices and inequalities. It is also a movie about the choices we all have to make at some point in our lives, but in the case of these brothers, such decisions are made more difficult by the weight of the traumas and stigmas imposed by their environment. Which, through tragedy, pushes them towards anger, resentment, and violence.

To avoid drowning in this predetermined fate, they have only one lifeline; love, which also seems to be able to flourish in the driest deserts. Can they resist and save themselves, even if it's just one of them? This is the question posed at the beginning of the film, and which is revealed to us in a moving and sincere ending.

As for the technical aspects, the film is characterized by good photography, excellent handling of the shots, and a fragmented narrative with flash forwards and flashbacks, which although may seem confusing at times, at the end of each sequence, we realize that it is not, demonstrating how the apparent chaos prevails a sublime order.

If you are looking for a Hollywood-style movie simply to entertain yourself, this film is a 6 at best, possibly a 7. But if you are a sensitive and curious spirit who wonders what it's like to walk in the shoes of the less fortunate, then this film is for you.

Oh goodie, yet another movie that entirely defines black people by the trauma heaped upon them.

"Brother" has some good things going for it, notably a couple of the performances and a strong directorial vision. But it's too funereally paced and it's just so eager to wallow in everything that's depressing about the black experience and nothing that's joyful about it. It also feels behind the times -- the police brutality that plays a key role in this film has been explored a million times already in countless other ways. It's not that it isn't still relevant and urgent, it's just that this movie doesn't say anything about it that hasn't already been said by better movies.

And the LGBTQ storyline that came out of nowhere and is never commented on felt shoehorned into the film just to tick off another diversity box. It made no sense that it would be such a non-issue in the context of this film or in the world these young men live in.

Grade: B-

Withdrawn, and a bit timid and unsure. Their mother (Marsha Stephanie Blake), a Jamaican immigrant, works long hours to support the boys, so Pierre becomes a de facto guardian for Johnson.

Flashing forward 10 years, we learn that Pierre has died and Blake has been nearly catatonic with grief for a decade. When Johnson's ex-girlfriend Kiana Madeira comes to visit, she initiates a chain of events that breaches the cocoon of grief that Johnson and Blake are living in.

This film is really beautifully shot, creating a really vivid sense of place, and it's wonderfully acted by the three leads. It alternates between the two timelines, showing how Pierre's restless ambition (he's involved with the nascent Toronto hip hop scene) and refusal to be anything less than a person with dignity sends him on a tragic spiral, and how the aftermath of this tragedy impacts his family a decade later.

It's got a few issues. It's really deliberate pace slows down a bit too much in the last half hour, and since we sort of see everything from Johnson's perspective, it has trouble making his motives as clear as everyone else's. Still, it's a powerful story well told and acted, and a really vivid depiction of the Toronto Caribbean community.

Based on the novel by David Chariandy: in the 1990s in the Scarborough suburb of Toronto, Ruth (Marsha Stephanie Blake) is a Jamaican immigrant raising her teenage sons Francis (Aaron Pierre) and Michael (Lamar Johnson). Non-linear storytelling is used in three different time periods to show the family's struggles, strengths, and life-changing events.

Many small scenes are used in the storytelling and they work very well. Even though the multiple time lines are challenging at first, this method pays off very well. This is mainly because the later time-frame indicates that a serious change has happened in the middle time period. The viewer is left curious as to what mysterious event will happen in the middle frame as the film is nearing its end. So, while the climax is in the middle time-frame, it ends up being exposed near the film's end rather than in the middle as it would have in a linear time frame.

The film's first half is depressing as it exposes hardships with very few lighter moments to relieve the sadness. While this would be a handicap for other films, "Brother" works well in channeling the mood to melancholy in its last quarter as it pieces all the mysteries together so compassionately. It is also accompanied beautifully by the song "Ne Me Quitte Pas" sung by Nina Simone. In fact, director/writer Clement Virgo uses music beautifully throughout his fine film with an impressive score by Todor Kobakov.

"Brother" uses various themes effectively including police brutality; the poor immigrant experience; exploitive talent contests in the 1990s in Toronto (and the false hope and heartbreak that arise); and the terrible effects from grief. This film is courageous in its detailed focus on grief which is rare and praiseworthy.

The main performances are powerful especially Johnson whose character is the main focus of the film and Blake whose character changes significantly in different time periods. - dbamateurcritic.