This series had the potential to be truly exceptional. Jane Austen's legacy endures because of her sharp social commentary and timeless storytelling, and a faithful adaptation of her work would have been a fitting tribute.
However, historical accuracy has once again taken a backseat to modern reinterpretations. While diversity in media is important, it should not come at the expense of historical authenticity. In 18th-century England, laws and societal structures made it impossible for a person of colour to be a practicing doctor, no matter how well-intentioned the portrayal may be. Rather than genuine inclusivity, this casting choice feels more like a superficial gesture, undermining both historical truth and the representation it aims to provide.
Telling diverse stories is valuable, but rewriting history instead of exploring it honestly does a disservice to all perspectives. Authentic representation should enhance storytelling, not distort the realities of the past.