A realistic take on family conflicts
Somewhere in the middle of the movie, we see a frame frozen for a few seconds, depicting a typical Kerala house with three brothers sitting quietly and discordantly. This frame epitomises the entire proceedings of the film. Narayaneente Moonnaanmakkal, meaning "Narayanee's Three Sons" in Malayalam, is a film without a real story, a beginning or a typical end. It is just a slice-of-life portrayal that takes us through a few days in the lives of a discordant family. It feels as if Director Sharan Venugopal set up cameras and sound recording devices in and around the house to showcase the candid happenings there as a feature film!
An old mother (Narayanee) is in her final stages of life on a ventilator. Her three sons, along with their families, come together to be with her in her last days, attempting to bury their past hatchets, at least for the outside world. As their wait unexpectedly prolongs, relationships and intentions unravel. This type of narrative is not new to Indian cinema in general or Malayalam cinema in particular. However, Malayalam cinema excels in this genre by keeping it real, devoid of stars, drama, punch dialogues, lewd comedy, or loud music. This film has none of these elements.
As days pass, apart from the relationship dynamics between the three brothers, there are fleeting references to quite a few other issues-interfaith marriage and its aftermath, caste conflicts in society, adolescent love and breakups, the fraught relationship between a mother and daughter, small-town idiosyncrasies, and the rebellious streak of today's youth, among others. Every character, including the ailing mother who doesn't speak a single word in the film, comes in shades of grey and are as real as possible, thanks to some outstanding performances by the entire cast and impressive camera work.
I am certain that outside of Malayalam cinema, actor Alencier Ley Lopez is not very well known. However, as a character actor, he ranks among the best in the country today, in my eyes. In this film, Alencier, as the eldest son, feels as if he has stepped right out of real life. His performance adds to his already impressive filmography in Malayalam, including films like Thondimuthalum Drikshakshiyum, etc. Suraj Vencharamoodu and Joju George, as the other two sons, deliver equally effortless performances with their restrained portrayals. Even with this heavyweight cast, the ones who stood out for me were Garggi Ananthan and Thomas Mathew, who play the roles of the adolescent kids in the family. Garggi's charming face and her permanently moist eyes serve as a perfect foil for her character in this film. Thomas, as a representative of today's youth grappling with their parents, love interests, and life's purpose, is simply fantastic. Without the stellar cast, this film's straightforward and familiar narrative would not have resonated as effectively.
Director Sharan introduces a very uncomfortable sequence that touches on societal taboos, which could be explosive in a society like ours. He quickly shifts the focus to the core theme, which is the nature of relationships between the three brothers. The screenplay, which moves at a slow pace until then, suddenly accelerates towards the end sequence, which cannot be called the climax, as there is none.
The Director leaves the conclusion to the viewers' imagination, but it is not difficult to infer what might have transpired. At another level, the film echoes the essence of another fine Malayalam film-Ullozhukku (Read My Flash Review here). With numerous undercurrents, this film could easily pass as a sequel to that film, featuring a parallel set of characters!
Narayaneente Moonnaanmakkal, streaming on Amazon Prime, is a must-watch if you appreciate realism in movies, as I do.
An old mother (Narayanee) is in her final stages of life on a ventilator. Her three sons, along with their families, come together to be with her in her last days, attempting to bury their past hatchets, at least for the outside world. As their wait unexpectedly prolongs, relationships and intentions unravel. This type of narrative is not new to Indian cinema in general or Malayalam cinema in particular. However, Malayalam cinema excels in this genre by keeping it real, devoid of stars, drama, punch dialogues, lewd comedy, or loud music. This film has none of these elements.
As days pass, apart from the relationship dynamics between the three brothers, there are fleeting references to quite a few other issues-interfaith marriage and its aftermath, caste conflicts in society, adolescent love and breakups, the fraught relationship between a mother and daughter, small-town idiosyncrasies, and the rebellious streak of today's youth, among others. Every character, including the ailing mother who doesn't speak a single word in the film, comes in shades of grey and are as real as possible, thanks to some outstanding performances by the entire cast and impressive camera work.
I am certain that outside of Malayalam cinema, actor Alencier Ley Lopez is not very well known. However, as a character actor, he ranks among the best in the country today, in my eyes. In this film, Alencier, as the eldest son, feels as if he has stepped right out of real life. His performance adds to his already impressive filmography in Malayalam, including films like Thondimuthalum Drikshakshiyum, etc. Suraj Vencharamoodu and Joju George, as the other two sons, deliver equally effortless performances with their restrained portrayals. Even with this heavyweight cast, the ones who stood out for me were Garggi Ananthan and Thomas Mathew, who play the roles of the adolescent kids in the family. Garggi's charming face and her permanently moist eyes serve as a perfect foil for her character in this film. Thomas, as a representative of today's youth grappling with their parents, love interests, and life's purpose, is simply fantastic. Without the stellar cast, this film's straightforward and familiar narrative would not have resonated as effectively.
Director Sharan introduces a very uncomfortable sequence that touches on societal taboos, which could be explosive in a society like ours. He quickly shifts the focus to the core theme, which is the nature of relationships between the three brothers. The screenplay, which moves at a slow pace until then, suddenly accelerates towards the end sequence, which cannot be called the climax, as there is none.
The Director leaves the conclusion to the viewers' imagination, but it is not difficult to infer what might have transpired. At another level, the film echoes the essence of another fine Malayalam film-Ullozhukku (Read My Flash Review here). With numerous undercurrents, this film could easily pass as a sequel to that film, featuring a parallel set of characters!
Narayaneente Moonnaanmakkal, streaming on Amazon Prime, is a must-watch if you appreciate realism in movies, as I do.
- anandkumarrs
- 13 mar 2025