In Another Life

Fantastic episode that showed a good progression in Buck's story with hopefully more to come. After last weeks episode it would seem it would have been a tough act to follow, however this delivers well. The acting in this episode was spot on, particularly Oliver's performance who was obviously the star of the episode. Peter's performance as Bobby also stands out as well. I would just say that the episode could've have done with a bit more time as some elements felt rushed (maybe a two parter would've been better?) Overall though a fab episode. Looking forward to see what happens in the rest of the season and happy to have the show back after the winter break!

I really enjoyed this episode. Oliver did a fantastic job. Buck is an important character to not only the characters in the show but also the viewers. I really would love to see more of Buck and his story and who he is as a person. I would love to see more episodes that are very similar to this one. While some may not like it, a lot of people actually do. You can have criticism s but acting like the overall episode wasn't good would be a complete lie. It showed how important buck is and how he is the very heart and soul of the 118 and I think that's important. He needs to know that he's valued.

This was a beautifully shot, wonderfully acted episode. I was so moved by Buck's journey and the way the he finds himself at the center of the threads of his friend's lives. A beautiful look at how much we matter to each other, how important each and every one of us is, even when it doesn't feel like it.

Buck's journey is so relatable, while also avoiding the feeling that it is too much like a cookie cutter story. Oliver Stark brings beautiful nuance to his performance in this episode, his scenes with Bobby and with (redacted) at the end, stand out particularly. I love when this show allows us to really zero in on one of the characters and really deep dive (some times literally) into their heads. This episode is going on my top ten list for sure.

Oliver Stark did an amazing job embodying Buck in this episode! Really enjoyed all the character development with each person! Also can I just say that Buck IS the life and heart of the 118! From the beginning of the show and being selfish but misunderstood to the man he is now, I feel like a lot of people can get to relate with Evan "Buck" Buckley. He has such a kind heart and I'm glad he truly finds who he is and is doing things for himself cause he needs it. I remember in the beginning of season 1 I didn't like how obnoxious Buck was but he definitely grew on me and is my comfort character throughout the show!

Loved the episode. Some great character development for Buck, and incredible performance by Oliver Stark. I hope from now on, Buck understands how loved he is by everyone. He is more than a firefighter. He has such a positive impact on everyone around him. To me, he is the heart of the show. He is a good friend, a good brother and overall a good person. He has always been my favorite character and i love to see him in the spotlight, specially when it doesn't involve annoying & poorly written love interests. The sperm donor storyline has also been all over the place. And personally, i don't vibe with the whole "forgive your terrible parents" message. I fully believe it's posible to heal from childhood trauma without forgiving and excusing the parents who caused it. Specially in this case where they didn't really atone or apologize for their mistakes. The Buckley's and Chimney's dad can go to hell imho. It made very little sense for them to suddenly be so reasonable and understanding. Other than that the episode was great. 9.5/10.