The Ruse

I watched The Ruse (2024) in theaters last night. The story follows a woman desperate for work who lands a recently vacated caretaker position. She soon discovers that the woman she's caring for is far more than she bargained for-and may be connected to the mysterious disappearance of the previous caretaker.

The film is written and directed by Stevan Mena (Malevolence) and stars Veronica Cartwright (Alien), Michael Steger (90210), Madelyn Dundon (Lucky Louie), and Drew Moerlein (Bloodline Killer).

This is a movie that feels uneven in just about every way. Veronica Cartwright delivers a fantastic performance, keeping the film intense, unpredictable, and charged with uncertainty. Her dialogue, mannerisms, and delivery are consistently strong. Unfortunately, Madelyn Dundon's performance is noticeably stiff, often coming across as inauthentic. Her facial expressions and body language frequently don't align with what's happening in the scene, though it's hard to say how much of that stems from her acting versus the writing.

I did enjoy the cinematography-there are some clever uses of black-and-white visuals and well-chosen camera angles that effectively build tension. However, the kill scenes rely on cutaways, which I always find frustrating. That said, the ending is pretty fun and left me wishing the rest of the film had taken more kills along the way.

In conclusion, The Ruse has enough worthwhile elements to hold your attention, but not enough to stand out in the genre. I'd give it a 5.5-6/10 and recommend seeing it once.

"The Ruse" is an excellent thriller that I would very much like to recommend!

The Plot: A new caretaker, Dale (Madelyn Dundon), is hired to take care of elderly Olivia Stone (Veronica Cartwright) due to being diagnosed with dementia. While taking care of Olivia, she realizes that the caretaker before her, Tracy (Kayleigh Ruller) has disappeared without a trace, leaving Dale to piece together what happened to Tracy while trying to take great care of Olivia.

I am such a huge fan of Stevan Mena's works "Malevolence" and "Malevolence 2: Bereavement." I thought this was very engaging throughout, and this movie is directed, produced, written and even the music is done by Mena! I think that is super awesome that he has lots of control for what he wants to make! Lastly, I think these movies by Stevan Mena has me thinking he is one of the most underrated horror movie directors out there!

9/10 stars for me.

I went into this movie only seeing the trailer and it seemed pretty interesting as I do like thrillers and mysteries. Had nothing to do on a Thursday afternoon so thought I'd give it a shot. It seemed promising for the first about 45 minutes to one hour, but the third act fell apart for me. I'm not really giving spoilers here, just wanted to give my opinion of what I thought of the movie and to be honest could've been better. I thought it was just the theater I was in, but reading a review from screen rant I see that there were audio issues in the movie. I don't understand what happened, but mic cutouts and sudden drops in the audio were kind of strange. Also, some of the action scenes felt very low budget and hacky. This movie felt more like a straight to streaming movie and not a movie theater release. They were only three other people with me in the theater and only one showing today so maybe that could've tipped me off. Not great, not the worst I've ever seen just merely OK, a premise that had promise.

Mystery thriller finds home care nurse Dale (Madelyn Dundon) being sent to the house of ailing orchestra conductor Olivia (Veronica Cartwright) when her current caregiver disappears. Dale herself has just come off a suspension stemming from the accidental death of her last patient. It's a challenge. Not only is Olivia immobile and suffering from dementia and OCD, but the house is rumored to be haunted by her late husband Albert. Soon strange things start occurring and Dale is finding there are some questions as to what really happened to her predecessor. As she begins to try and piece things together the mystery deepens, and Dale starts to believe she might be in danger...but the question is, from who?

Old fashioned style mystery is written and directed by Stevan Mena going in a different direction after his cult classic Malevolence slasher trilogy. He delivers a film that delightfully evokes some of those old school haunted house mysteries of yesteryear but with a contemporary enough edge to not come across as nostalgia. There are some spooky sequences, some nice tension and atmosphere and a few moments of impacting violence, especially in the last act when we start to get some answers ...or do we? Mena does keep us guessing and for the first two thirds The Ruse is a chilling and intense slow burn till the third act reveals and even then, not everything is as it seems. Whodunnit? What is actually going on? You will find out all the answers eventually and if the film has any flaw, it's that it doesn't quite let us enjoy some of the red herrings long enough till moving on to the next one. It changes possible suspects a little too quickly when we should have been left to believe the suspicions a little longer before the next revelation. It's still an entertaining homage to not only old-fashioned mysteries but the type of thrillers that were prolific in the 80s and 90s. A solid thriller that that makes good use of its not only the Maine locations but Mena's horror film background when things get intense or spooky. The cinematography from Cory Geryak is excellent, especially the drone shots, and Mena himself provides an atmospheric score.

The cast here is good. Veronica Cartwright is strong as the ailing but still proud Olivia. She can be tough and yet fragile, sometimes in the same scene, and having had personal experience with someone with dementia, she nails the unpredictability and anguish perfectly. Madelyn Dundon is a very likable heroine as Dale. Some of her delivery in the earlier scenes seemed a little stiff at times but she rises to the occasion when it counts most, especially in the intense last act. Michael Steger is good as neighbor Tom. He gives his single dad next door an air of mystery which suits the material as Mena obviously doesn't want us to trust anyone. T. C. Carter is efficient as the pervy grocery delivery boy Jacob, Nicola Jeanette Silber is good as Tom's daughter Penny, and Michael Bakkensen is solid as Detective Burke who gets to be our Maine version of Columbo in the last act's fun final reveal.

Overall, the film was very entertaining, and it was good to see Mena back in the writing/directing/editing chairs once again after a six-year break. It's a bit of old school mystery, mixed with some 80/90s thriller with a pinch of haunted house movie thrown in. There is tension, atmosphere and a deliberately slow burn pace till the plot starts to thicken in the last third. The only flaw is that it moves through some of the red herrings a little too fast for us to really appreciate/believe them before moving on to the next. Its final big reveal may not have been a complete shock, but the scene is clever fun, and it was an entertaining and sometimes spooky ride getting there.

I haven't been to the theatre in a long time, because movies today don't make you think.

I'm so tired of movies with all action and no story. The Ruse is a movie where you are compelled to pay attention and follow the plot. Great acting, great script, great ending with a twist. Sure, there are some violent scenes, but they aren't there just for the sake of it. You can tell there was a lot of thought to detail. This is how movies used to be. We need more of this. It's made so that you care about the charcters and what will happen, or can happen to them. This was well worth the price of admission.