Where Is He?
- El episodio se transmitió el 19 sep 2024
- B
- 1h 3min
CALIFICACIÓN DE IMDb
7.1/10
19 k
TU CALIFICACIÓN
Galadriel considera una propuesta. Elendil se enfrenta a un juicio. El Extraño se encuentra en una encrucijada. Los planes de Sauron dan sus frutos.Galadriel considera una propuesta. Elendil se enfrenta a un juicio. El Extraño se encuentra en una encrucijada. Los planes de Sauron dan sus frutos.Galadriel considera una propuesta. Elendil se enfrenta a un juicio. El Extraño se encuentra en una encrucijada. Los planes de Sauron dan sus frutos.
- Dirección
- Guionistas
- Elenco
Ismael Cruz Cordova
- Arondir
- (as Ismael Cruz Córdova)
Opiniones destacadas
I'm watching this series understanding that it's mostly fan fiction - taking the world created by Tolkien and playing "What if?" That's fine - it's a world that deserves more exploration and flesh but the least they could have done is understand the essence of the world.
The elves deserve so much more. The LOTR movies actually were a good representation of them. Slightly otherworldly with their heightened senses, aloof demeanor, and a deeper connection of time and place. There is nothing in ROP currently differentiating humans from elves beside ears and hairstyles. The series would be so much better if they respected what the races actually were and what they weren't. But I suspect getting into the headspace and physical dimensions of foreign beings might be too much to ask when the writers are humans trying to appeal to other humans.
The greatness of Tolkien was that he could think like the beings he envisioned, embracing their strengths and weaknesses, knowing that they all had something to offer the world and were all connected to the world in their own unique way. I don't get how with all the money spent they didn't get writers who knew the difference and knew elves would never panic unless something supernatural was causing it. They also don't break twigs walking through a forest.
And settling down with the Mrs isn't a motivation of Orcs.
The elves deserve so much more. The LOTR movies actually were a good representation of them. Slightly otherworldly with their heightened senses, aloof demeanor, and a deeper connection of time and place. There is nothing in ROP currently differentiating humans from elves beside ears and hairstyles. The series would be so much better if they respected what the races actually were and what they weren't. But I suspect getting into the headspace and physical dimensions of foreign beings might be too much to ask when the writers are humans trying to appeal to other humans.
The greatness of Tolkien was that he could think like the beings he envisioned, embracing their strengths and weaknesses, knowing that they all had something to offer the world and were all connected to the world in their own unique way. I don't get how with all the money spent they didn't get writers who knew the difference and knew elves would never panic unless something supernatural was causing it. They also don't break twigs walking through a forest.
And settling down with the Mrs isn't a motivation of Orcs.
I keep hoping this series will improve, but for myriad reasons, I can see now that this is not going to happen. In this episode, we are treated yet again to a series of vignettes strung together with some passable CGI and a borefest of dialogue.
The directing seems to be all over the place, and the script drags so much that I'm sure the writers were constantly talking about how many more pages they had to fill to meet their quota.
This whole series is about promise. We are lured in by the promise of the rich, detailed world that Peter Jackson and his team created with The Lord of the Rings movies and, later, The Hobbit. But this is all it is-a dream of what might have been.
Instead, what we have could be any daytime drama series done badly. Only here, we have fantasy instead of the usual contemporary themes.
This particular episode doesn't move things forward from where we have already been. It is merely repeating what has happened in the last couple of episodes.
The overriding impression is that everything is small scale. The effects and costumes are good, but each scene feels like it was shot on a stage with as few actors as possible.
The grand scale of The Lord of the Rings is nowhere to be seen. Whenever we expect large crowds, we see a small group standing around. Where there should be sweeping vistas of large Orc armies, we see only some lights from torches dotted around in the dark. There is never a sense of something big happening here.
The acting is at times wooden, but I don't think this is the actors' fault. They have a script that is lacking, and they are trying to bring emotion where there is nothing to base it on. I also have to wonder if they don't feel incredulous at having to speak lines that are dull, make no sense, and never move things along.
Only a couple more episodes to go, but based on the ones I have seen so far, I am not expecting anything good.
The directing seems to be all over the place, and the script drags so much that I'm sure the writers were constantly talking about how many more pages they had to fill to meet their quota.
This whole series is about promise. We are lured in by the promise of the rich, detailed world that Peter Jackson and his team created with The Lord of the Rings movies and, later, The Hobbit. But this is all it is-a dream of what might have been.
Instead, what we have could be any daytime drama series done badly. Only here, we have fantasy instead of the usual contemporary themes.
This particular episode doesn't move things forward from where we have already been. It is merely repeating what has happened in the last couple of episodes.
The overriding impression is that everything is small scale. The effects and costumes are good, but each scene feels like it was shot on a stage with as few actors as possible.
The grand scale of The Lord of the Rings is nowhere to be seen. Whenever we expect large crowds, we see a small group standing around. Where there should be sweeping vistas of large Orc armies, we see only some lights from torches dotted around in the dark. There is never a sense of something big happening here.
The acting is at times wooden, but I don't think this is the actors' fault. They have a script that is lacking, and they are trying to bring emotion where there is nothing to base it on. I also have to wonder if they don't feel incredulous at having to speak lines that are dull, make no sense, and never move things along.
Only a couple more episodes to go, but based on the ones I have seen so far, I am not expecting anything good.
Sauron is really badass in this series. I can just watch him all day long. Charlie Vickers was born for this role. He should have more scenes in other seasons. I wish the quality of the other scenes were as good as the Sauron scenes. On the other hand, Galadriel's scenes are really badly written. Her scenes should be shortened. According to the books, she does almost nothing in the 2nd age anyway. Please don't let this character be in the 3rd season. At least her scenes should be reduced as much as possible. Finally, we are not interested in hobbits. We don't want to see them. The closer the series gets to the book, the better it is handled. Best regards.
I think the overarching narrative is picking up great momentum now with multiple compelling storylines. Everything builds towards a finish that promises momentous events to come.
The most interesting plot naturally surrounds Sauron, the rings, and the fate of Eregion. However, some of the best character moments involve the dwarves. The standout performer for me is Owain Arthur who shows great range again.
Events in Numenor are predictable but satisfying. Lloyd Owen is great as Elendil. How this all ties in with the above plot threads will be interesting.
Visually it is splendid as always.
For me it is an 8.5/10, but I round upwards.
The most interesting plot naturally surrounds Sauron, the rings, and the fate of Eregion. However, some of the best character moments involve the dwarves. The standout performer for me is Owain Arthur who shows great range again.
Events in Numenor are predictable but satisfying. Lloyd Owen is great as Elendil. How this all ties in with the above plot threads will be interesting.
Visually it is splendid as always.
For me it is an 8.5/10, but I round upwards.
Honestly the whole show is a botch, I've loved lord of the rings since I was a kid favorite trilogy of all time. On top of the bad acting, first and the second season both start off incredibly slow, with poor dialogue/writing/and acting, however the second half of both seasons is where there is finally some action. Then it ropes me back in this episode was amazing but I hope it doesn't continue to follow this trend so we're not watching 4 hours worth of nothing. Elendil/Sauron are carrying, the episodes with less harfoots are the better ones. Still worth watching, but man they could've done SO much better with this story.
¿Sabías que…?
- TriviaAt about 15 mins, when Adar shows the Iron Crown to Galadriel, Galadriel says, "Morgoth's crown. I was told--" Adar replies, "There are many stories of what happened, after the Silmarils were pried from its settings." In "The Silmarillion" by J.R.R. Tolkien, "...his iron crown they beat into a collar for his neck, and his head was bowed upon his knees. And the two Silmarils which remained to Morgoth were taken from his crown, and they shone unsullied beneath the sky..." (p. 252).
- Citas
Captain Elendil: Faith is not faith if it is not lived.
Selecciones populares
Inicia sesión para calificar y agrega a la lista de videos para obtener recomendaciones personalizadas
Detalles
- Tiempo de ejecución
- 1h 3min(63 min)
Contribuir a esta página
Sugiere una edición o agrega el contenido que falta