The White Room

Oh man! Steve Martin absolutely KILLS in this episode (not literally, mind you, just flexing his comedic abilities all over the place). We were crying from laughing so hard at the "Which of the Pickwick Triplets Did It" white room sequences. And it absolutely did move the story along, so the naysayers should just sit back and enjoy the ride. I'm glad they're incorporating more musical aspects to fit in with Martin Short's character arc. With the Bob Fosse number at the start, to Meryl Streep's beautiful song a few episodes ago, this season is all about creativity while still focusing on the murders that occurred at the Arconia.

Their writers are fabulous!

This is one of my all-time favorite shows. There are just a lot of things I miss this season. I would love to see Ursula, Lester, Nina, Theo, and more people from the building. I'd also like to see the building itself more. I loved the building tenants' meeting from season 1 and the historical opening of the building of the Arconia in the 1900s from season 2. Over the years we got to see the apartments of Tim Kono, Jan, Howard, Bunny, Teddy, Nina...now we have so many fewer little cozy apartments. That microcosm feeling isn't really there for me as much.

Maybe I'm just not a fan of musical theater. It feels like they're rehearsing for something and I miss my show.

PS Andrea Martin still reminds me of Aunt Voula from My Big Fat Greek Wedding. Classic.

"The White Room" is one of the more surreal chapters of OMITB, which Steve Martin utilizes to his comedic advantage. While nowhere near the deepest or most daring episode the series has to offer, I would argue that it is one of the more purely funny ones. That's not to say it doesn't move the mystery forward, it just isn't quite at the forefront. The core trio's chemistry is irresistible as ever and continues to score consistent laughs. Plus, it was nice to see Andrea Martin finally get a chance to shine here. The surprises, while not jaw-dropping, still raise questions that I'm very excited to have answered later this season. "The White Room" is another solid addition to OMITB's repertoire.

P. S. The only slight missed opportunity was that I wish this episode had included the song "White Room" by Cream. It's not essential. Just would've been neat.

Steve Martin's character is at the center of this episode, although the others are also quite wonderful. The White Room is a fictional place stage actors go to when they freeze on stage. Martin has a silly little song to sing in the play, and he is so panicked when he does it, he slips into the White Room. When he awakens, he has done some ludicrous thing and finds that he has embarrassed himself. Tina Faye gets back into the act with Mabel as they try to sort out the killer of the obnoxious actor. The one they suspected is not the one. She is selling products, using the theater where the guy died. The murder case seems secondary at the moment. But watch this to see what a comic genius Steve Martin.

I loved the first season, the second season kind of twisted itself in the end. But both seasons stuck to the main premise of the murders in the building being investigated.

Here it looks like "Only theatrics in the building". This is the fourth episode and all we have till now, is how Martin Short is trying to revive his play into a musical and how Steve Martin is struggling to perform.

The murder investigation and podcast has become a side story which barely gets 5 mins in all this white room nonsense. Yes its good acting but I didn't sign up for the experience of what happens in Broadway and what theatre actors experience. It was how three people crack murders in the building and we are not seeing any progress on that front at all in this season.