Valley of the Dolls

This is even worse than the previous pseudo-documentary episode, which at least had the benefit of being creative. This one is just filler, in which nothing much is accomplished. The storyline is just too thin to fill out a whole season.

So now Charles gets a much younger sister for no other reason than to create this filler episode. I found them completely unconvincing as siblings.

I hope they paid renowned thespian Meryl Streep a whole lot of money to disgrace herself by getting into a stupid catfight.

Hopefully this is just a midseason slump and the next episode will at least be useful and advance the plot.

I cannot say enough good things about this episode everything clicked. The writing was spot on in the core actors did great. Melissa McCarthy was a guest actress who played Steve Martin's sister who lives on Long Island and was unrecognizable. She is arguably the best female and comedy right now, her range is amazing. Just crushed it in this episode. They even gave Zach Galifianakis, Eva Longoria and Eugene Levy material to work with. In the episode, they are told that actors can do anything as they basically do 95% research and during the episode they all work together and Mexico design a murder board and nearly solve the crime. It was cohesive and it moved the plot along nicely and is definitely the strongest episode of the season. I am going to enjoy watching it again with my model wife.

This season's first two episodes were good, but from there it has been atrocious. With this episode in particular I struggled to follow the plot, and the storyline plodded along without much happening. Unwatchable. One thing that certainly didn't help this season was the introduction of numerous additional superfluous characters who appear in bursts and then disappear.

This episode completely lost my attention and I looked forward to it ending.

Looking back, the first season was great, fresh and original, but they should have ended it there if they didn't have anything worthwhile to bring to the screen. The show is like a zombie stumbling forward in the dark, soulless and lifeless.

We have loved this season. Overall, we think that it might be even better than season one, and miles better than seasons two or three. Certainly funnier.

That said, this episode was lousy, and the only stinker of the season so far. Sappy, contrived, and plenty of nothing happening. It had some funny moments early on, and picked up a little bit at the end, but the middle 2/3 was terrible.

The mystery is still interesting, although this episode did virtually nothing to move things along. Just treading water. The real problem was that the humor was largely MIA, and what little there was, was broad and lame.

The rebound flirtation between Oliver and Charles's sister was cringey, and things didn't improve when Meryl Streep showed up to confirm yet again that despite their repeated declarations of undying love, there is absolutely no chemistry between Streep and Short.

After 2-3 disappointing episodes where the season felt like it was going nowhere, this episode was a complete turnaround. It went back to the basics of season 1, restoring my faith in the season. The intimate setting (Doreen's house with hilarious creepy dolls everywhere) and the witty dialogue were a refreshing change from the unrealistic events of earlier episodes.

Melissa was absolutely phenomenal. From her first second in the episode, she stole every scene and outshined the other actors-even Meryl Streep! Every line she delivered was hilarious. Her physical comedy (wigs, vodka cups, leopard leggings), comedy timing (every joke landed), and even her movements (she could just stand there and you couldn't take your eyes off her). She brought back the humor of seasons 1 and 2 and elevated the entire episode by multiple levels. Her catfight scenes with Meryl were fantastic, reminding me of the iconic fight between Goldie Hawn and Meryl in Death Becomes Her.

An amazing episode-so glad I stuck with this season! I will definitely rewatch this episode multiple times just because of Melissa to notice further nuances of her performance. I couldn't get enough!