Verdict: A mystery that remains unsolved, not in the story, but in why Rishav Basu was chosen to play Holmes in the first place
Bad Bad Bad Acting by Rishav Basu
Verdict: A mystery that remains unsolved, not in the story, but in why Rishav Basu was chosen to play Holmes in the first place
Saralakkha Holmes, the much-anticipated Bengali adaptation of Arthur Conan Doyle's iconic detective figure, arrives with a fresh twist rooted in local culture. The film ambitiously tries to merge the razor-sharp logic of Holmes with a uniquely Bengali sensibility. The premise is intriguing, and the cinematography, especially the moody visuals of Dartmoor, offers some atmospheric moments. Unfortunately, the execution stumbles badly, and at the center of this shortfall lies Rishav Basu's underwhelming performance in the titular role.
Basu's portrayal of Holmes lacks the gravitas, conviction, and finesse required for a character built on intellectual sharpness and eccentric charm. His dialogue delivery feels forced and often flat, draining key scenes of their intended intensity. The mannerisms come across as exaggerated rather than nuanced, making Holmes feel more like a caricature than a cerebral detective. In moments demanding subtlety, whether it's deducing a clue or interrogating a suspect, his expressions border on theatrical, which breaks the immersion.
What makes the disappointment sharper is the evident potential in the film's setup. With stronger acting at its core, Saralakkha Holmes might have offered a refreshing interpretation of the legendary detective for Bengali audiences. Instead, Basu's uneven performance anchors the film in mediocrity. The supporting cast fares slightly better, but they're unable to compensate for a central character who never truly convinces us of his brilliance.
In the end, Saralakkha Holmes is a case of a fascinating idea undone by flawed execution. And while the direction and script shoulder part of the blame, the biggest culprit remains Rishav Basu's miscasting, an actor who, at least in this outing, simply doesn't rise to the challenge of embodying one of literature's most enduring figures.
Verdict: A mystery that remains unsolved, not in the story, but in why Rishav Basu was chosen to play Holmes in the first place
Saralakkha Holmes, the much-anticipated Bengali adaptation of Arthur Conan Doyle's iconic detective figure, arrives with a fresh twist rooted in local culture. The film ambitiously tries to merge the razor-sharp logic of Holmes with a uniquely Bengali sensibility. The premise is intriguing, and the cinematography, especially the moody visuals of Dartmoor, offers some atmospheric moments. Unfortunately, the execution stumbles badly, and at the center of this shortfall lies Rishav Basu's underwhelming performance in the titular role.
Basu's portrayal of Holmes lacks the gravitas, conviction, and finesse required for a character built on intellectual sharpness and eccentric charm. His dialogue delivery feels forced and often flat, draining key scenes of their intended intensity. The mannerisms come across as exaggerated rather than nuanced, making Holmes feel more like a caricature than a cerebral detective. In moments demanding subtlety, whether it's deducing a clue or interrogating a suspect, his expressions border on theatrical, which breaks the immersion.
What makes the disappointment sharper is the evident potential in the film's setup. With stronger acting at its core, Saralakkha Holmes might have offered a refreshing interpretation of the legendary detective for Bengali audiences. Instead, Basu's uneven performance anchors the film in mediocrity. The supporting cast fares slightly better, but they're unable to compensate for a central character who never truly convinces us of his brilliance.
In the end, Saralakkha Holmes is a case of a fascinating idea undone by flawed execution. And while the direction and script shoulder part of the blame, the biggest culprit remains Rishav Basu's miscasting, an actor who, at least in this outing, simply doesn't rise to the challenge of embodying one of literature's most enduring figures.
- PageR-7
- 1 sep 2025