After eight years of silence, Anna shows up on her sister Kat's doorstep, with a coffin on the roof of her car and their parents' ashes in a jar. Anna wants to die in Spain, but first, she needs to convince Kat to come with her.
Kat and Anna drive to Santa Rita, the place where they last vacationed with their parents. As painful memories and meddlesome Dutch tourists catch up with them, chaos ensues.
A lost earring leads the sisters to an eccentric stranger with an urgent problem. There's drinking, cooking, dancing, and silence, until it becomes clear that everyone is lying.
In the village where their parents once wrote love declarations on walls, Kat wrestles with her consciousness. When Anna keeps pressing her with questions, Kat acts on an impulsive plan that goes just a little too far.
After a night filled with doubts, Kat finds herself torn between two forces: a man who offers her security, and a sister who wants to give her freedom. What follows is a leap forward, and a confession eight years in the making.
The sisters finally reach their destination, where nothing is as they remember it. As demons from the past intrude, all masks come off and one last confession brings their journey full circle.