From Darkness to Light

This is a documentary of the legendary 'lost' Jerry Lewis 1972 film, "The Day The Clown Cried". Jerry plays political prisoner Helmet the clown in a Nazi concentration camp where he is eventually given the task of leading a group of kids to gleefully walk into the gas chamber.

The early section has a lot of present day celebrities and commentators talking about the rumors of the legend. Harry Shearer is one of the few who claims to have seen a copy. Apparently, some film cans of the working copy were secreted away from the bankrupt production house on their way to the trash. This does show some clips of the unfinished film. Some scenes are enlightening on the tone of the film, but it is tough to know if it's actually good or not. I don't think that this can be a comedy and that's the central question.

The big difficulty for the production is a lying producer who didn't get the rights to the story. In one section, Jerry confesses that the film is not good. He does pull it back by saying that it's almost wonderful which is not good enough. It's a dodge. I find myself wanting to call Jerry out on some of his comments. I'm not sure that he has a grasp on what the film needs to achieve. This is also well before Life is Beautiful and I've always felt that Life's broad comedy never worked due to the subject matter. It would have been great to have Jerry finish the movie. It would have been controversial and maybe set him on a different path.

An interesting and watchable documentary that I cannot help but feel is taken way too seriously by the film makers. It appears, to me at least, that they regard Lewis' not being able to finish his holocaust comedy/drama as a tragedy almost commensurate with that of Welles not having the final cut on "Magnificent Ambersons" and that the film's producer, Nat Wachsberger, to whom they assign the blame for this iniquity, is such an odious philistine that his face must be blocked from our view. I mean, talk about comedy! The fact is that, based on Lewis' own, unusually honest assessment and the out takes that are shown, Wachsberger did Lewis' reputation a favor by pulling the plug on the bathetic, pretentious embarrassment that is "The Day The Clown Cried". B minus.

I see from another review that this film was marketed to TV. And indeed it starts like a TV program, with a set of teasers to convince you to watch. And it claims to solve the last great mystery of cinematic history-- the mystery of what went wrong with Jerry Lewis's never-released film "The Day the Clown Cried." The documentary does apparently provide a definitive answer regarding the project's collapse as a business venture, and it shows us Lewis's own dissatisfaction with the footage although Lewis's own feelings and behavior are more difficult to explain and may to some extent remain a mystery forever. We do see several minutes of "The Day the Clown Cried," and it's obvious (to me at least) that one major mistake was casting Jerry Lewis himself as a German civilian in World War II when the New Jersey whine couldn't help creeping into his voice and putting him apart from the non-American actors playing the other Germans. Other criticisms are brought up, and they're all thought-provoking, even if-- unlike some of the interviewees-- you don't consider Jerry Lewis a great genius of 20th-century cinema.

"From Darkness to Light" shows us as much of Jerry Lewis' "The Day the Clown Cried" as we are likely to ever see. I'm sure Jerry's movie would be a hard one to sit through but I would like to give it a try. The scenes that directors Eric Friedler and Michael Lurie show are interesting but they also give the impression that "The Day the Clown Cried" would be a pretty hard movie to get through. But then again, maybe not. I didn't grow up watching a lot of Jerry Lewis movies. My parents didn't like him. As I got older, I started watching his movies and I became a fan. Jerry Lewis was a genius when it came to filmmaking. He might have actually been able to pull that movie off. Sadly, we'll never really know.

A current documentary on the infamously abandoned Jerry Lewis holocaust vehicle The Day the Clown Cried. Back in the early 70's Lewis set out to make a film about a circus clown who ends up in a concentration group who manages to keep the spirits of the children up while imprisoned there until the wheels of cruelty move them towards their ultimate fate. Lewis felt he had a winner on his hands as evidenced by the various talk shows he went on at the time where he was hyping the near completion of it but then through budget cuts from an unreliable producer & the dawning realization the material was not shaping up to his standards put the film's release into limbo for many years which even by the time of his death & asked about it, he'd say the project was dead. Through interviews w/some of the survivors of the project w/Lewis himself interviewed in length before his passing, we get an idea of what went wrong (especially those who have seen an assembly of the film like Harry Shearer). A fascinating watch since I'd heard about this film within the last few years w/this doc providing actual scenes cobbled together so an audience could make heads or tails of what could've been. Considering subsequent films like the Oscar winning Life is Beautiful & I think Robin Williams made one entitled Jakob the Liar, one wonders if Lewis' take on similar material might've beaten the others to the gate for acclaim & recognition. We'll never know.