AstelleVey

It's apparent that Chibnall took some inspiration from, not only past Doctor Who finales, but also the MCU. It's all nostalgia-bait and cameos, that sacrifices any competent or worthy story telling. The inclusion of past characters, whether they're part of the main group or a simple point-at-the-screen feature, doesn't enhance what's going on; in fact, they serve no purpose. Take them out, and you would have basically the same episode, with a few very minor tweaks. I would consider my self an avid fan of the classic run of the show. I haven't seen it all, but enough to comment about this. The emotions this episodes tries to tug by bringing these characters back don't register at all. In the hands of a competent writer, then perhaps I would take it away differently; however, knowing the losses of the past few years has taught me to not expect anything from this era's finale, and yet I still sigh and eye-roll. It was certainly risky trying to cram all these together, but doing so left many holes, specifically with the absence of certain people.

Even when you ignore the crowd-pleasing attributes, the central story is still stuffed and bloated. The Master! The Cybermen! The Daleks! Wow, the Doctor's big 3 antagonists all to do....nothing, essentially. The Daleks take an off-screen approach to provide no threat in the slightest. Chibnall has blatantly overused the Daleks - and to an extent, all 3 of these vital villains - in his tenure as showrunner. Constantly regurgitating them out for some of the poorest written episodes in TV history, just to make them look like fools and weak. I'm sorry, but wasn't it established countless of times in the revival that the Daleks are the universe's ultimate threat? The most powerful race? Of course, we see plentiful of failures, yet we still witness their pure evil. Guess Chibnall forgot to include that very core characteristic when throwing them in here. This can be said again for both the Master and the newish Cybermen. Trying to amalgamate beloved appearances from both sides into one highlights the consistent flaws that persist in Chibnall's run. His whole shtick with his finales are nothing more than contrived fanservices that build up to nothing.

As for the central plot, it's still pathetic. So the man did it, he actually made 0 decent episodes for his singular-doctor era. What an idiot. What a fool. Let's pray he is blacklisted from working on Doctor Who. It's actually quite irritating attempting to articulate exactly why the plot was bad, because the plot doesn't exist. The characters, which I've already elaborated on, force the plot to happen. That's not good writing. Good writing allows the characters to make decisions and then follow the story from there. What's happening here is the characters do certain actions because why not. There's no history, just recycled motives. They just exist because the episode wanted them to. What do they do? What do they want? Oh they just want to kill humans/destroy the Earth, again, using some uber-complex plan that involves out-of-nowhere devices that contradict written lore, again, and hoping the Doctor doesn't stop them even though they do, again. No nuance, no spices or flavour to appear different. I wouldn't even dare call it a reskin, it's just repeats after repeats.

Visually, it's still horrendous as well. Doctor Who trying too hard on effects is pointless, because evidently, the show has never been about how pretty or realistic it looks. Yet with the desperation to make all the crap on screen look somewhat tolerable, it achieves the polar opposite.

I'm obliged to note on the final minutes. To no one's surprise that this certain event was going to make it in. Again, it's just another attempt to make the viewers smile and eager to continue watching after the appalling 3 seasons we've had. Clever, admittedly. It's obviously the only way they could make us care to tune in next time, which I'm sure we will, excited for a promising, well-deserved good episode with a new writer.