Le fils d'une famille britannique vivant en Asie du Sud-Est se retrouve dans un triangle amoureux.Le fils d'une famille britannique vivant en Asie du Sud-Est se retrouve dans un triangle amoureux.Le fils d'une famille britannique vivant en Asie du Sud-Est se retrouve dans un triangle amoureux.
Parcourir les épisodes
Avis en vedette
J.G. Ballard's satirical novel, 'The Singapore Grip', is set in the last days of British rule, and follows a group of corrupt, complacent colonials as the threat of Japanese invasion draws close. Logically, it should be both fun and angry; but this television adaptation falls flat, in spite of a starry cast (Charles Dance turns up only to die more or less in the first scene). Perhaps it would have been better had it solely followed the perspective of the young man who comes in from Britain and tries to make sense of the world he has found; instead, we see a lot of the action from the point of view of the ghastly character played by David Morrisey, who is somewhat amusing, but too shallow to carry the story. The focus on a small group of expats also means that Singapore fails to come alive as a living, breathing city, populated by millions of people who aren't British. The narrative arc makes good dramatic sense; nontheless, there's a sparkle that's missing.
Some times i like how the show pokes fun at colonialism. At other times I find myself wishing for deeper investigation of the period. On one hand, the way this skips along on the surface parallels the general shallowness of many of the characters. The writing is kind of clever in that way. On the other hand, i found myself often wanting for some deeper investigation. I especially wished for a more thorough investigation of the character of Vera Chiang. I'd summarize this as "light" satire, intended for British audience with some smiles but no big laughs and that only hints at many past sins.. c ould have been so much better but... not bad for wfat it is.
Very poorly set and awfully directed and the scenes are pathetic casting not the best.
Read the book very much better entertainment
I have read reviews of this production with increasing dismay. I accept views of the quality of the acting whether or not I agree with them. I don't object if anyone finds the script writer's dialogue unappealing whether or not I agree with them. I find the level of sanctimonious, self righteous and woke criticism of the story, the content and the author depressing and wholly predictable in today's climate.
This is a novel, and yes it is a single self contained book so I don't think anyone is angling for a "second series" God help us.
It is part of J.G. Farrell's anti colonial trilogy. The characters are awful - they are meant to be. You are not meant to like them. What the production fails to convey is the subtle, wonderful all pervasive disgust that Matthew and the author felt about the damage of colonialism.
I want to suggest people actually read the book but I expect many won't bother and some would find it too challenging.
Unlike some others, I'm enjoying this show, but then I'm always a sucker for a British costume drama. The actors are good and the historical context is interesting. Don't write if off without giving it a fair go.
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesProduction Designer Rob Harris and his team made a functioning replica Ha-Go 95 Japanese tank. Anti-aircraft guns and 25lb field guns were either borrowed from the Malaysian Army, or left behind by British and Australian troops.
- GaffesThe Air Chief Marshall's Aide is portrayed as a Major General, which is far too high a rank for that kind of role, plus the actor is too young to be playing a general. In fact, a typical Aide to a general command would be a Captain or a Major.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et surveiller les recommandations personnalisées
- How many seasons does The Singapore Grip have?Propulsé par Alexa
Détails
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant