Vaillante

This animated film starts out weak, has quite a few silly "jump the shark" moments, is goofy, but in parts funny, heartwarming, and overall fun.

Good animation (common in today's world of CGI animation) and a decent story (a young woman who wants to be a fire fighter when such was prohibited) work together to make this an enjoyable watch. Children will love it. Some adults will tolerate it. Other adults will love it, some hate it. It's right in that gray area.

I'm giving it 7 stars because despite its flaws, it teaches several good lessons about bravery, caution, determination, and the difference between right and wrong while still recognizing that sometimes things go sideways. Those lessons are well worth learning, especially in the younger set.

Not my favorite animation, but it accomplished its purpose despite its flaws. Worth a watch, especially for children.

It's your typical kids movie with a lesson at the end. This time, it's a movie about the fire female firefighter in the FDNY... set in 1932. I think it contains just the right amount of action for a movie, if you count the part where they drive a taxi onto the Empire State building under construction.

Cute and fun, goofy movie, good for children. I'm a pretty easily entertained person and I found it decent.

I only have two issues with this film, but they are pretty minor and easily overlooked.

1. The voice of the main character; she sounds wayyy older than 16, which is the age she is supposed to be, but I grew into it through the course of the movie and pretty much stopped noticing it.

2. The character design for the main character, she is seen working out at the beginning and doing some stuff where she is shown she can easily hold her own body weight and I feel it's very unrealistic that her character looks like she has no muscle mass at all, but then again, its an animation, and a childrens movie, so I can't really ask for realism.

Set in 1930s New York, young woman Georgia Nolan (Olivia Cooke) as a child dreamed of becoming a fireman, but her father, retired fire captain Shawn Nolan broke the news that women can't be firefighters. Georgia has seemingly accepted that and works alongside her father as a seamstress for his tailor business but still holds that dream close to her heart training every opportunity she can get. When a rash of mysterious blazes featuring colored smoke and eerier music occur at various Broadway theaters, the city's firefighters begin disappearing without a trace. Mayor Jimmy Murray (William Shatner) as a last resort finds Shawn Nolan and asks him to come out of retirement to lead a volunteer team to help fight the arsonist which Shawn reluctantly agrees to. Georgia overhearing this decides to dress up as a man named Joe and dons a disguise working under her father along with neurotic science expert Ricardo (Ryan Garcia) and daredevil driver Jin (Wilex Ly) who's prone to fainting spells to stop the arsonist from turning New York to ashes.

Fireheart is the latest film from Canadian animation studio L'Atelier Animation who may not be a household name, but did score a reasonably big hit in 2016 with the animated feature Ballerina also known as Leap! In its U. S. release, earning $100 million worldwide against its $30 million budget. Much like Ballerina, Fireheart is co-produced by both French and Canadian sources, and like many films of this ilk it's on the lower end of the budget for this type of movie with estimates ranging from $35-40 million. Fireheart has gotten a very quiet release, especially in the United States where it appeared on Hulu earlier this month and doesn't seem to have much presence. While Fireheart isn't an overlooked gem or anything, it's a solid smaller scale animated film that I did enjoy.

The best asset of the film is definitely in its animation. While Fireheart doesn't have the resources and polish of something from Disney or Dreamworks, it's more than capable of competing against the likes of Illumination even with half the budget of a typical Illumination production. The movie does a decent job of creating a version 1930s New York, not perfectly but there are some nice background details in things like Times Square with various posters and ads that do feel like they're of the era. I thought Olivia Cooke and Kenneth Branagh were really good in the film and there is a natural chemistry that comes through in their interactions so you buy their relationship as father and daughter. And the firefighting scenes are really good, the arsonist scenes in particular are nicely atmospheric with this colorful smoke and a suit disguise that looks really good and even a little unnerving at certain points.

The movie itself is pure formula especially with its very Twelfth Night/Mulan type protagonist and all the humor that entails. If you remember movie's like She's the Man or Disney's Mulan where the characters attempt to act "manly" by inserting the word "man" into every other sentence we do get some of that here, and there is a running gag about Georgia/Joe's mustache made of dog hair falling off or being on when it shouldn't. The movie is pretty similar to firefighting movie Backdraft if you filtered it through the lens of something like Zootopia (save for the anthropomorphic animals part) and if you've seen Zootopia or 70% of animated films of the past 10 years you'll probably be able to spot the arsonist as soon as they appear. The movie's humor is mostly okay, it's not great or anything but it's serviceable for its target audience. But then you have headscratching moments like a character named Captain Neil of the NYPD who speaks throughout the movie in this exaggerated falsetto with mannerisms that feel like a less restrained Jack from Will & Grace that makes this movie seem like it's about 15 years out of date. I will say that despite this being a "liar revealed" story, the path they take doesn't go exactly the same direction you'd think they go, considering how often this story beat is often tapped I was considerably more accepting of it here.

Fireheart won't set any fires, but it's a solid animated film that can be enjoyed as a suitable time killer. The animation is solid, the voicework is decent (captain Neil notwithstanding), and there are some thrilling or inventive sequences in the movie. The movie does use some rather familiar elements with its central mystery pretty easy to solve even by the least jaded viewer, but other elements such as the conflict of Georgia's lie are handled better here than similar plot points in other films. If you have children who like action/adventure or firefighting this is probably a decent sit for them.

As a female firefighter I am probably not the target audience for this film, but thought I might be able to offer a useful perspective given the subject matter. The concept of the film is unique, and kids (and maybe even some parents) would probably find it to be a fun adventure along the lines of Scooby Doo, but firefighters may find it hard to like.

It comes across as a film that tries to show what firefighters do in an age-appropriate way, while still containing plenty of the fun elements that appeal to kids. While this may be fine for its target audience, the result is a sufficiently inaccurate (and at times illogical) depiction of firefighting that will likely be a frustrating watch for a firefighter. But not just that, this is not a film where you can sit your kids down in front of it and tell them, "this is what mummy/daddy does". It's just too dissimilar.

Going into this film, I was concerned the 'woman fighting the patriarchy' plot point might be overdone to the point of being grating, but it actually had a much smaller role than I expected, and was handled fairly well, and was more just used to set the stage for later events.

It's worth mentioning that there's probably no trigger warnings for firefighters in this film. It is significantly sanitised since it's directed at a young audience, and I don't recall even seeing any open flame, just smoke. There's also no blood, gore, violence, car accidents, or character death. However, like most firefighting films that are not made with accuracy in mind, expect to be yelling at the tv a lot.

Firefighters, by all means let your kids watch this one, but if you join them don't expect to find it all that great yourself. Also, be prepared to field a few questions where you have to explain all the ways firefighting isn't like this movie.