Another Gay Sequel: Gays Gone Wild!

I did love the first movie. It ran with the idea of making a gay version of American Pie and ran with it. The character's became realistic and though it lost me at times it's charm held me till the end.

The second however, was an abomination. The script needed many many more edits before it made it into production. The fact that all of the actors had to be replaced was one of many problems. Their replacements were not completely thought out. Andy's in particular, seemed nothing like his character in the first.

However the premise still had some promise. Taking them all for spring break sounded very hilarious and had plenty of room for laughs and promiscuity. And we were instantly introduced to "Jaspers" our three antagonists. And Griff and Jarrod's budding relationship opened up the idea of sexual monogamy a real issue that many couples face today, a promise for some type of depth to the entire plot.

They failed.

It seemed like all the plot lines had promise even Nico's rather week like with a bad luck Tiki seems to be the set up for some hilarious consequences.

But then the script fails to deliver.

There was not enough prep put into this movie and there was not enough thought given to the final product. And finally the promise of yet another sequel "Gays in Space" sounds atrocious.

I actually didn't know that this 2008 sequel existed prior to stumbling upon it by random chance here in 2025, as I found a copy of the original first 2006 movie "Another Gay Movie" and this 2008 sequel titled "Another Gay Sequel: Gays Gone Wild!"

The storyline in the movie was pretty straightforward, but it just wasn't fully up to par with the 2006 "Another Gay Movie", and I really struggled with the re-casted characters. Writers Todd Stephens and Eric Eisenbrey put together a fair enough script, just with a bunch of shortcomings.

A word of advice, though, if you are particularly sensitive, then there is a fair amount of lewd scenes in the movie. Most of which just unnecessarily sleazed up the movie, and I dare say that had the writers opted not to include such, the movie would still have been able to tell its story and actually be a tad better in general.

The acting performances in "Another Gay Sequel: Gays Gone Wild!" were good, but when three out of four actors from the original movie didn't return to reprise their characters, then you just should have written the characters out of the storyline and not re-cast new actors to portray the characters. That was the first and biggest mistake that this movie faced.

The waterskiing scene was some of the worst green screen I've seen in a long, long time. It was just atrocious to look at.

My rating of the 2008 comedy "Another Gay Sequel: Gays Gone Wild!", from director Todd Stephens, lands on a generous three out of ten stars.

Okay. This one is much worst than the first one.

Of course they couldn't make it as good as the first one...but still..

The first thing that I disliked at first sight, was the actor change. I mean the title says it "the sequel", but of all the 4 boys, just one is the same. Although one of the new guys is similar to the previous, all the others are much different, and they are not so good. I mean it. They are terrible.

The story itself isn't that bad. But there's not that passion from the first one that would make you cry; side perhaps from the mermaid.

I really don't recommend this movie for the folks that saw the first one. It's really disappointing. It still has some funny stuff...but....

This film is NOT supposed to be taken seriously, that's a given. It's a harmless bash at every gay stereotype you can imagine, it's camp, driven and funny.

Many moments in the film have that extreme cringe factor, but you have chosen to invest time in a movie titled 'Another Gay Movie: Gays Gone Wild' you can hardly expect subtleties like the camera veering off to record a fireplace while sexual activity is implied...

RuPaul and Lady Bunny bring classic drag comedy, while the main cast are easy on the eye and don't appall with their acting skills. The Cameos from Muffster and Nico's Mum are also welcomed with a wide grin.

I would say if you are bored and want to spend an hour and a half amused yet bemused, laughing but not really knowing what at and trying to guess the countless films this one parodies, go for it! Like I said it's harmless!

Yes, this is gay, silly, dumb, offensive, trashy and pornographic film making -- but I still ended up chuckling for most of the 90 minutes.

This one had decent eye candy, more than its predecessor. Although sexier and grosser, this one was probably not as good as the first one. The plot was unfocused. I'm not sure they should have returned with Jonah Blechman and Scott Thompson in the same roles because their shticks seemed less original the second time around. The sequel also seemed to have more ham and cheese.

This is the first film I've seen with a reverse bell curve on IMDb.com. You're either gonna love this one or hate it. I think you should see it, but only if this kind of movie appeals to you. Personally, I wish the director would make more gay comedies. There is a certain coarse honesty and sophistication to these two films, despite it all. And there should be more gay comedies out there.