ÉVALUATION IMDb
6,6/10
2,5 k
MA NOTE
Dans les années 1940, une jeune femme très riche s'intéresse vivement au travail de détective, ce qui est mal vu à l'époque. Elle a un majordome, qui la protège et finit par l'accompagner da... Tout lireDans les années 1940, une jeune femme très riche s'intéresse vivement au travail de détective, ce qui est mal vu à l'époque. Elle a un majordome, qui la protège et finit par l'accompagner dans ses aventures.Dans les années 1940, une jeune femme très riche s'intéresse vivement au travail de détective, ce qui est mal vu à l'époque. Elle a un majordome, qui la protège et finit par l'accompagner dans ses aventures.
- Prix
- 2 nominations au total
Parcourir les épisodes
Sommaire
Reviewers say 'A Private Affair' garners mixed reviews, highlighting Aura Garrido and Jean Reno's performances, Galician scenery, stylish costumes, and engaging mystery. Criticisms include poor English dubbing, historical inaccuracies, and anachronisms. Pacing and episode length are contentious, with some finding the series too drawn out. Marina's characterization is divisive; some appreciate her independence, while others find her annoying. Potential for a second season is often discussed, with hopes for script and pacing improvements.
Avis en vedette
I just started watching this series on Prime. A lot of people making reviews here of this show have complained about the English dubbing. Prime has this bad defect in that they seem to be the only streaming service that when living in the USA seams to automatically default to English dubbing of foreign shows. Please be aware that in most cases, you CAN turn it back to the original language and put on English subtitles.
When you use your remote, just tab down on it. You should see the actors in the scene shown. But above that are 3 icons. The middle one if you click on it allows you to select which language the movie has subtitles for. So obviously click English. The icon to the far right is the audio icon. In this show the original audio is Spanish. So select Spanish. Now the movie will show in it's original language and with English subtitles. It is Always better to watch a foreign show in the original language with English subtitles, rather than with bad English dubbing where nothing matches what the lips say they should say.
When you use your remote, just tab down on it. You should see the actors in the scene shown. But above that are 3 icons. The middle one if you click on it allows you to select which language the movie has subtitles for. So obviously click English. The icon to the far right is the audio icon. In this show the original audio is Spanish. So select Spanish. Now the movie will show in it's original language and with English subtitles. It is Always better to watch a foreign show in the original language with English subtitles, rather than with bad English dubbing where nothing matches what the lips say they should say.
The story is not bad and the ending is quite surprisingly tragic. My problem is that she is unbearable. She's a condensate of cliche': the rich spoilt brat who jumps to conclusions and recklessly endengers herself but is surrounded by men ready to catch her in the moment of danger. This kind of character is so tiresome I struggled to get through all 8 episodes and I confess I skipped some parts. It kept me going that I was curious to know who the killer was. And the last episode was rewarding. Jean Reno as a not in your face delicate gay butler is sweet. I still remember him as a gentle but ruthless assassin in Leon.
Like so many recent productions and books in which lazy writers set stories in the past, yet forget to do any kind of serious research about expressions that are used, concepts that are common and technology that existed at the time in which the story takes place, this series is rife with late 20th and early 21st century language and attitudes. It takes away from a fun and otherwise well-produced program.
It is very tiresome that too many people who write stories taking place in bygone eras cannot be bothered to do even a modicum of research to make sure they've stayed true to those times. It takes a few minutes to Google the origins of a word or phrase to make sure it was in use at the time. Ditto manners and mores, songs, films, clothing and technology. Are they stupid or just lazy?
It is very tiresome that too many people who write stories taking place in bygone eras cannot be bothered to do even a modicum of research to make sure they've stayed true to those times. It takes a few minutes to Google the origins of a word or phrase to make sure it was in use at the time. Ditto manners and mores, songs, films, clothing and technology. Are they stupid or just lazy?
Great production with a bit of everything in it exciting, romantic, stylish great lead actress vulnerable and stylish some kind young anti-hero with an incredible talent as a detective mentored by a great Jean Reno.
A Private Affair ventures on a roller-coaster ride of fun and mysteries. And the rest of the characters in this TV series are also entertaining all the way. In addition to the artistry of the serie it,s a period tv series set in Galicia, Spain making it even more interesting for the audience because of the cultural aspect with which this story is told, this series is interesting from that social and class point of view because it,s still resonate in a lot of countries. The characters trying to find a sense of social justice is subtly pointed out in a traditionalist society.
Great production and cast Jean Reno is really entertaining and great as Hector the sidekick in the story. Great international TV series.
A Private Affair ventures on a roller-coaster ride of fun and mysteries. And the rest of the characters in this TV series are also entertaining all the way. In addition to the artistry of the serie it,s a period tv series set in Galicia, Spain making it even more interesting for the audience because of the cultural aspect with which this story is told, this series is interesting from that social and class point of view because it,s still resonate in a lot of countries. The characters trying to find a sense of social justice is subtly pointed out in a traditionalist society.
Great production and cast Jean Reno is really entertaining and great as Hector the sidekick in the story. Great international TV series.
The dubbing is as good as it could be, but after ten minutes I switched to the original Spanish with subtitles and, suddenly, what had been a bit tiresome became excellent. Also, it seems very likely that many of the language anachronisms were down to the poor translation demanded by the need for the lip-sync to be as smooth as possible. Before you give up on this, do what I did. You'll enjoy it a whole lot more. Though I don't disagree that it could have been tightened up considerably - it was a little slow in places. Now I'm wittering a bit to make up the character count. Never met that before!
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesThe graphic novel style openings of each episode forecast the main events of the episode
- GaffesThe Stockholmsyndrome. Marina mentions the Stockholmsyndrome in one episode, but the phenomena wasn't coined until the 1970, while the series takes place in the 1940's.
- ConnexionsReferenced in Cinemascomics: Entrevistas: Entrevista al equipo de "Un asunto privado" (2022)
- Bandes originalesBad Reputation
Written by Joan Jett, Kenny Laguna (as Kenneth Benjamin Laguna), Marty Kupersmith (as Martin Kupersmith), and Ritchie Cordell
Performed by Marem Ladson
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et surveiller les recommandations personnalisées
- How many seasons does A Private Affair have?Propulsé par Alexa
Détails
- Durée
- 45m
- Couleur
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant