Fille

All the little hurts and slights of life build throughout our relationships. Beautifully animated with what I assume is paper mache. Silence is the real killer here.

Weak, and not worthy of the Oscar Nomination. Two Stars for The Animation Work.

This was one of the most beautiful, touching animated shorts I have ever seen. Very moving. Highly deserving of the praise and accolades it has received. Also, I did not expect to see an animated short and be impressed with the camera work. Definitely added to its impact. It was a perfect marriage of content and form. Put simply, an extraordinary work of art.

The relationship between a man and his daughter begins to fray in this silent animated short subject.

This one deserves a nomination for best animated short subject, because of the way it uses its animation techniques to tell the story. This looks like stop-motion of mishappen ceramic figures which have been sloppily, or perhaps impressionistically painted, which gives each of the two characters a distorted appearance to match the other's perception. As I write that, it seems pretty high-brow to someone like me, for whom stop-motion is about animating skeletons or raisins. Yet it works.

This was in a block that my film was in at the New Jersey International Film Festival. I had just been talking about having been in blocks with other animated films that were technically much better than mine, but had nothing deep to say. This blew me away for being a real exception to that. At times the shots looked like handheld live action (which was freaking me out for a stop motion film) and the emotional resonance was there and hit all the right notes. What a beautiful portrait of the father-daughter relationship and the echo of loss. What lovely, lovely work, and I'm so happy to have seen it projected!