ÉVALUATION IMDb
7,5/10
4,8 k
MA NOTE
Septembre 1914. Depuis quelques semaines, les combats font rage. Dans un petit village de l'est de la France, à quelques kilomètres de la zone allemande, quatre femmes se retrouvent projetée... Tout lireSeptembre 1914. Depuis quelques semaines, les combats font rage. Dans un petit village de l'est de la France, à quelques kilomètres de la zone allemande, quatre femmes se retrouvent projetées au coeur de l'horreur.Septembre 1914. Depuis quelques semaines, les combats font rage. Dans un petit village de l'est de la France, à quelques kilomètres de la zone allemande, quatre femmes se retrouvent projetées au coeur de l'horreur.
- Prix
- 1 nomination au total
Parcourir les épisodes
Avis en vedette
I didn't have high hopes for this show when it popped up on my screen, but it turns out it's pretty addictive. Tells the tale of four women in various stations in life interacting and intersecting each other's lives in the early days of World War One in France.
This is a very well made series, good acting, writing, great costumes and sets. The show has a melodramatic, slightly unreal aspect to it, making for a dreamy high end soap opera feel. That's not a bad thing, it was low key mesmerizing at times.
I wish there were more miniseries of this caliber available on streaming services instead of the usual garbage shows.
This is a very well made series, good acting, writing, great costumes and sets. The show has a melodramatic, slightly unreal aspect to it, making for a dreamy high end soap opera feel. That's not a bad thing, it was low key mesmerizing at times.
I wish there were more miniseries of this caliber available on streaming services instead of the usual garbage shows.
The different stories are interesting and not farfetched. Most of the actresses and actors are excellent. The four main characters are so different from one another, what makes the story even more captivating. I binge-watched it and loved it... until the end of the episode 6.
The last two episodes were indeed very disappointing: they lacked realism and were sickly soppy. Example: would it be possible that a high-ranking officer, at war, receives a prostitute in his office and helps her, several times? Finally, the end is just unrealistic and too sentimental to me.
What a shame as it is a super story showing the great value and capabilities of different women during wartime.
The last two episodes were indeed very disappointing: they lacked realism and were sickly soppy. Example: would it be possible that a high-ranking officer, at war, receives a prostitute in his office and helps her, several times? Finally, the end is just unrealistic and too sentimental to me.
What a shame as it is a super story showing the great value and capabilities of different women during wartime.
If you watched "Bonfire of Destiny" you'll be pleased to see the same three actresses ( plus a new one) and Director, at it again. This time it's 1914 and WW1 has started. A prostitute, a nun and a "criminal" abortionist are the main protagonists. And, yup the baddies are mostly men. But it's played out dead seriously which allows the plot weaknesses to be smoothed over.
Audrey Fleurot leads the way with her wonderful mane of red hair. And flaring nostrils! She's so good at playing strong characters who are always interesting even when flawed.
It's also one of the rare movies that show WW1 before it ground down to bunker warfare. It seems the French uniforms were "decorative" while the Germans, practical as usual, were colorless. Zut Alors!
Audrey Fleurot leads the way with her wonderful mane of red hair. And flaring nostrils! She's so good at playing strong characters who are always interesting even when flawed.
It's also one of the rare movies that show WW1 before it ground down to bunker warfare. It seems the French uniforms were "decorative" while the Germans, practical as usual, were colorless. Zut Alors!
I want to focus on the fact that this serie really catches the horrible moments of war in such a way I think noone can go away untouched. The screams are just horrific, If I didn't know it was on TV I could swear it was real.
I have to say it's really well made, great acting from everyone. And the fact I finished this before even thinking of looking at the last of us says it all.
This isn't an American production where everyone is cool and wounds are no match.
France has done it, it's horrific and tense, but you just need to watch to the end. Not sure you feel any better, but you definitely feel something.
I have to say it's really well made, great acting from everyone. And the fact I finished this before even thinking of looking at the last of us says it all.
This isn't an American production where everyone is cool and wounds are no match.
France has done it, it's horrific and tense, but you just need to watch to the end. Not sure you feel any better, but you definitely feel something.
It's a good French series about the involvement of women in WW1 on the French side, through the prism of four prototypal characters: a prostitute with a son in the army; a runaway competent nurse; an upper-class lady with a shady past; and a nun.
The story of the four characters intersect and find a common destiny in a French town near the front, confronted by the horrors of war.
Some of that conflict was well depicted, other elements, maybe not so much. Historical accuracy is not the main element here (e.g there were no gas attack until 1915, whereas all the action takes place at the beginning of the war in 1914).
The depiction of war wounds, the moral of troops, the insufficient equipment (no helmet) and the treatment of the wounded seemed pretty spot on though.
The action and acting is all good if a little over-dramatic and forced at times.
There will be no second season. This is a mini-series and this is all there is to it.
The story of the four characters intersect and find a common destiny in a French town near the front, confronted by the horrors of war.
Some of that conflict was well depicted, other elements, maybe not so much. Historical accuracy is not the main element here (e.g there were no gas attack until 1915, whereas all the action takes place at the beginning of the war in 1914).
The depiction of war wounds, the moral of troops, the insufficient equipment (no helmet) and the treatment of the wounded seemed pretty spot on though.
The action and acting is all good if a little over-dramatic and forced at times.
There will be no second season. This is a mini-series and this is all there is to it.
Le saviez-vous
- GaffesHard to believe that in 1914 both nuns and novices would have long, beautiful hair beneath their coifs and headscarves.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et surveiller les recommandations personnalisées
- How many seasons does Women at War have?Propulsé par Alexa
Détails
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant