ÉVALUATION IMDb
6,5/10
2,9 k
MA NOTE
Traqué par des nazis qui exterminent les personnes handicapées, un jeune garçon ayant une malformation prend une terrible décision tandis qu'il fuit pour sauver sa peau.Traqué par des nazis qui exterminent les personnes handicapées, un jeune garçon ayant une malformation prend une terrible décision tandis qu'il fuit pour sauver sa peau.Traqué par des nazis qui exterminent les personnes handicapées, un jeune garçon ayant une malformation prend une terrible décision tandis qu'il fuit pour sauver sa peau.
Avis en vedette
The short film shows us the suffering of the disabled because the Nazi viewed them as being garbage that waste money and resources. I didn't know before that the disabled German adults and children had suffered the persecution, too. The film is well done with beautiful cinematography, good performance, great location and setting and costume, and the story was told in a way that kept our interest all the way through, routing for the boy to survive. It is perfectly titled, if we think about how human trespassed against each other so much at that time in the history. Heaven must have wept bitterly back then. I hope similar thing won't return in another form to our present time.
Well. As important as the topic of the Nazi genocide against people w disabilities is - you make a movie, do some research. The uniforms are wrong. The whole setup is wrong (SS does not come with tanks and for sure not within Germany). They come with a car, they would come to the school rather maybe, they will be pseudo-nice and "take the kid to an appointment at a clinic" etc - they would then later kill the kids at other facilities. I understand that this is fictionalized but it does not serve the topic to show the sinister and cold actions of the SS and the Nazis by showing them as if they were unorganized brutal idiots. We have to understand that they had smart and devious ways. Well. Just watch man in the high castle, gives you more insight into the psychology of evil.
A very good short film that can make the audience empathize with the main character in 13 minutes.
I hope Netflix shows the success it has shown in festivals in the field of short films as well.
I hope Netflix shows the success it has shown in festivals in the field of short films as well.
During or even before the second world war, the Nazi regime targeted people it deemed lesser. With Aryans allegedly and supposedly being superior to others (be it religious beliefs, skin color or simply race). One group that gets almost forgotten, are the physically disabled. Like the protagonist in this short movie.
A short movie that is very well done and that shows how cruel and mad people got back then. Tension filled and really tight, I would not be surprised if this wins (or has won by the time you read this) awards. Short and while maybe not so sweet (subject matter), this checks all the "right" boxes. Nothing to forgive here ...
A short movie that is very well done and that shows how cruel and mad people got back then. Tension filled and really tight, I would not be surprised if this wins (or has won by the time you read this) awards. Short and while maybe not so sweet (subject matter), this checks all the "right" boxes. Nothing to forgive here ...
Fair and precise remind of a less familiar aspect of Nazi Germany policy about its citizens.
A young woman, teacher. Her son, disabled, is one of her students. One day, the menace against boy. And his survive .
At first sight, holes and a too short / concentred story. But the powerful, impressive and pleasant work of young Knox Gibson is the great gift of this short film about childhood in a different light.
A young woman, teacher. Her son, disabled, is one of her students. One day, the menace against boy. And his survive .
At first sight, holes and a too short / concentred story. But the powerful, impressive and pleasant work of young Knox Gibson is the great gift of this short film about childhood in a different light.
Le saviez-vous
- GaffesThe way Peter and the teacher write the numbers is not how they are written in Germany. Both write their "1" as a single vertical line, as is typical of the US, whereas it is always written with a beginning slanted line in Germany.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et surveiller les recommandations personnalisées
Détails
- Date de sortie
- Pays d’origine
- Site officiel
- Langue
- Aussi connu sous le nom de
- Forgive Us Our Trespasses
- sociétés de production
- Consultez plus de crédits d'entreprise sur IMDbPro
- Durée
- 13m
- Couleur
- Mixage
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant