ÉVALUATION IMDb
5,0/10
1,5 k
MA NOTE
Le retour d'un cosmonaute après une disparition de 30 ans ravive un amour perdu et suscite l'intérêt d'une entreprise résolue à comprendre pourquoi il n'a pas vieilli.Le retour d'un cosmonaute après une disparition de 30 ans ravive un amour perdu et suscite l'intérêt d'une entreprise résolue à comprendre pourquoi il n'a pas vieilli.Le retour d'un cosmonaute après une disparition de 30 ans ravive un amour perdu et suscite l'intérêt d'une entreprise résolue à comprendre pourquoi il n'a pas vieilli.
Parcourir les épisodes
Avis en vedette
The first episode seemed a bit boring so I almost switched off. The music and the photography kept on it and O found myself drawn back in.
More drama than SF as others have noted. Two guys, one girl and two time periods. The two guys are fighter pilots and incredibly competitive but are best friends, some of the time and the girl dances between the two. There are some plot holes but it is far from the worst I have seen.
The Russian subplot was a bit strange but it added a bit of colour although some of the acting there gets a bit overdone but the rest is ok and Nadia was good. The pilots are written a bit like two teenagers at times and you wonder why their characters have F16s to play with at work. On the other had: Top Gun and The Right Stuff.
Overall it looked pretty good. Some are critical of Future Warsaw looking too similar, especially the clothes. I felt that the changes were pretty good. It.was a bit too lucky how things worked so well when left for thirty years.
The ending is open but not necessarily a bad ting.
More drama than SF as others have noted. Two guys, one girl and two time periods. The two guys are fighter pilots and incredibly competitive but are best friends, some of the time and the girl dances between the two. There are some plot holes but it is far from the worst I have seen.
The Russian subplot was a bit strange but it added a bit of colour although some of the acting there gets a bit overdone but the rest is ok and Nadia was good. The pilots are written a bit like two teenagers at times and you wonder why their characters have F16s to play with at work. On the other had: Top Gun and The Right Stuff.
Overall it looked pretty good. Some are critical of Future Warsaw looking too similar, especially the clothes. I felt that the changes were pretty good. It.was a bit too lucky how things worked so well when left for thirty years.
The ending is open but not necessarily a bad ting.
There were interesting characters that you want to care about. Some relationship dynamics were a bit hard to swallow as believable. It had an interesting plot concept and story line. But some of the bits and pieces of it were missing some continuity. I wasn't always sure of how many directions this was going in. However, I was invested in finding out who she chose. Not sure if the story would continue to be as interesting if there was a second season. Great cinematography and the effects were believable. It's really too bad it had to end as stupidly has it did. Vast disappointment unfortunately. It's was good til the last 5 minutes.
... the plot isn't something well-written or very sophisticated.... it's a straightforward time complicated love-triangle.. production budget being quite high was a total waste for what was produced... and why on Earth would they choose an actor who's supposed to be his thirty year aged self, looking nothing like who he was when younger... to a point he's even nowhere near the same height which is ludicrous... and Magdalena Cielecka being a very attractive 50yo woman, how-why does she come off most times looking a worn-drawn-decade-older in this series
... as a Polish science-fiction romance-drama it falls waaaay short, and should have been made into a ninety-plus minute film, not painfully extended-over a multi-episode-series... one critic nails it saying... "If you're a fan of teen-love-triangle-dramas and have binged on-the-likes of Vampire Diaries, you'll probably enjoy the back-and-forth in this film between the main leads. Other than that, it is nothing that will interest adults looking for something with depth and meaning." ... hard-pass.
... as a Polish science-fiction romance-drama it falls waaaay short, and should have been made into a ninety-plus minute film, not painfully extended-over a multi-episode-series... one critic nails it saying... "If you're a fan of teen-love-triangle-dramas and have binged on-the-likes of Vampire Diaries, you'll probably enjoy the back-and-forth in this film between the main leads. Other than that, it is nothing that will interest adults looking for something with depth and meaning." ... hard-pass.
I am so glad I ignored all the negative reviews. I'm truly baffled why such bad reviews. I thought it was suspenseful, it kept me intrigued the whole time. I watched all of it within two days. The ending was bittersweet. It really was, but then, how could it be anything other than that with her having two loves. I'm not one to write reviews but I had to put something out there to give a more balanced perspective. All of the characters were well written and acted. The only thing "Top Gun" related at all was that the two main male characters were pilots. I did enjoy them showing off. For 6 episodes, this was wrapped up nicely without a cliffhanger. Well done. Forget the terrible reviews. Please give it a chance.
It's a well thought out production, with good writing and execution. I enjoyed seeing what Central/Eastern Europe can do with science-fiction-ish storylines. I very much enjoyed hearing Polish spoken, with Russian as needed for the scenes which take place in Russia. Nice balance of humor and drama, with the two different time periods clearly delineated with different actors and actresses. That said, it was easy am d enjoyable to follow. It was not overpowering with intense action scenes; it has a nice balance between conversation and action. Sets and locations were all good. Nice work on the part of Polish Netflix! Looking forward to Season 2!
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et surveiller les recommandations personnalisées
- How many seasons does A Girl and an Astronaut have?Propulsé par Alexa
Détails
- Date de sortie
- Pays d’origine
- Site officiel
- Langue
- Aussi connu sous le nom de
- A Girl and an Astronaut
- Lieux de tournage
- sociétés de production
- Consultez plus de crédits d'entreprise sur IMDbPro
- Durée
- 45m
- Couleur
- Mixage
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant