Echo Valley

If ever a film made you want to scream in frustration, this would be it. From the constant betrayals of trust, to people getting away with horrendous crimes, to the overly-forgiving mom... it will drive you INSANE! That said, the acting was excellent across the board. Julianne Moore is convincing as the mother who will do anything for her child, even if her role is identical to what she's done in her last 50 films. Sydney Sweeney, while perhaps slightly exaggerated at times, delivers a strong performance as an addict, with very realistic addict behaviours. The standout for me was Domhnall Gleeson, who truly shone as the conniving, self-centred drug dealer. I'm so used to seeing him in more passive, underdog roles, so this was a great chance for him to show a different side.

That being said, the story and plot were absolutely maddening. I cannot accept the way Moore's character Kate treats Claire (Sweeney), and vice versa. It felt far too unrealistic. A mother's love is unconditional, yes, but there is a difference between unconditional and overindulgent. At some point, long before the events in the film, Kate should have realised that her constant "help" was doing far more harm than good. I hate when films normalise this dynamic between parents and children and villainise the voice of reason. I fully understand the parental instinct to protect your children at all costs, but when your actions only drag them deeper into their self-destruction, who are you really protecting?

My Review- Echo Valley Apple TV My Rating. 6/10

Julianne Moore is the only reason I chose to watch this movie as I am seldom disappointed with her choice of movie roles however her fine performance in Echo Valley wasn't enough for me to have any emotional connection at all with this dysfunctional mother daughter saga.

Primarily because to quote Eve Arden's famous line from the classic 1945 mother daughter saga " Mildred Pierce " starring Joan Crawford as Mildred and her selfish self obsessed daughter Veda played by Ann Blyth .

"Personally, Veda's convinced me that alligators have the right idea. They eat their young." That's for sure! Now that was a classic I still adore .

The selfish unpleasant daughter in Echo Valley is Claire Garretson played by Sydney Sweeney a drug addict who returns home to torment her mother Kate Garretson played by Julianne Moore when she needs money for drugs.

However this time she's in real trouble with her dealer and boyfriend that drags her mother into a whirlpool of crime and mayhem.

I usually have compassion for movies or series about addiction that feature the eventual rehabilitation or at least the desire to turn their lives around.

Echo Valley however is just about total dysfunctional and manipulative characters with no redemption at all. It does effectively show the lengths both the addict and the parents of addicts will go to either to get drugs or in this mother's case to try a protect her daughter.

Brad Ingelsby who wrote Mare of Easttown which I loved wrote Echo Valley but in this case his story doesn't echo his previous success.

Despite a good cast that includes Fiona Shaw the story descended into implausible melodrama for this viewer.

Julianne Moore is one of the few working actresses with both the talent and name recognition to elevate any mid-budget movie into a relatively successful and engaging experience. Put her in an aesthetically pleasing house with hardships, and she'll deliver a moving performance full of emotional depth and layered moral quandaries.

There's some immersion-breaking Apple product placement-now a norm for films produced by giant tech companies-but "Echo Valley" remains a suspenseful thriller with minimal violence. It's at its best and original when focusing on the ominous mother-daughter dynamic between Julianne Moore and Sydney Sweeney, whose performances fully sell the premise.

I gotta be honest... it was actually way better than I expected.

First of all, the movie is rage baity as hell (but I didn't mind it) Normally that kind of thing annoys me, but here it kinda worked. That's part of what kept me so locked in. It's like, you want to yell at the screen because you're actually into it. It's like a roller coaster of emotions,

Also, the acting was honestly impressive.

The movie is def not perfect. Some scenes dragged a little, and there were a few moments where the characters did things that didn't totally make sense unless you just accept that people sometimes act irrational when they're panicking. Also, the ending left me feeling a little weird. Not bad weird, just like... rage baity :D

Overall, Echo Valley isn't your typical big flashy movie, but it is something that pulls you in and doesn't really let go. It's messy, emotional, a little rage-inducing, and honestly, kind of thrilling in a quiet, twisted way. If you're looking for a wild ride that's not just action but also hits hard emotionally, I'd definitely recommend giving it a shot. It's not a perfect movie, but it's way more interesting than most of the stuff that comes out nowadays.

The telltale sign that this was a great movie was the range of emotions I felt throughout. Julianne Moore and Sydney Sweeney give incredible performances, along with the supporting actors. They truly make you feel frustrated at times, angry at other times and super sad along the way.

Julianne Moore is every enabling parent that you can never talk sense into, and Sydney Sweeney is every junkie kid that puts substance of use ahead of their family. Both characters are just as frustrating and heartbreaking as anyone who's watched this play out in real life.

And although the movie starts out a little slow, there's a twist in the middle that works toward another twist at the end that's even more surprising.

Definitely worth putting on your watch list.