Kereta berdarah

A very bad film, with unclear storytelling and extremely poor acting from the cast. Especially the scene where the train conductor falls off the train-it felt like watching a 1970s Indian movie. The acting was painfully stiff and unintelligent, making it hard to take any scene seriously. The story felt forced, with plot points that made little to no sense. Worst of all, the jump scare scenes were awkward and unnatural, failing to deliver any real tension. Instead of being scary, they came off as laughable and cringeworthy. It was frustrating to sit through a film that clearly lacked effort in both writing and direction. I honestly considered leaving halfway through. A total disappointment from start to finish.

I'm not used to reviewing films, especially since I'm aware of the limitations in Indonesian cinema, which often lacks detail. It's rare to find a film that makes sense from start to finish.

However, I feel compelled to comment on this movie because everything about it is really disappointing. It's a shame, as the individual performances of the cast aren't bad, and the message about balancing nature and the economy is strong and relevant. Plus, with Rizal Mantovani involved, you'd expect better visual quality. Unfortunately, the script is terribly flawed-it's hard to find a worse one.

Hence it is out of mind with Netflix recommend this movie as if Netflix does not understand how the brain cells work.

1. The mix of fact and fiction makes the story very difficult to follow. Sangkara is mentioned in connection with Jakarta and Solo, implying it's based on some "fact." If it's fact that it's a six-hour train ride in Java, that means it crosses provincial lines. So, the starting point of the station and the resort are in different cities and most likely provinces. How could one regent be responsible for such a large project? It makes more sense in papua or Kalimantan. So If Sangkara is a city nearby Solo 6 hrs ride might bring you somewhere in Nganjuk (east) or Tasikmalaya (west).

2. Trains are not like airplanes; they can STOP. It feels as if this were an airplane that can't make sudden stops.

3. The abrupt detachment of the train should create a significant sound impact. If the screenwriter understood basic physics, they'd know that the last carriage detaching would result in a strong collision with the carriage in front. We call it "momentum" at your elementary Physics. It is not like you pee and you dont feel anything.

4. The awkwardness of the characters knowing the train was detached repeatedly is hard to watch.

5. So, who is Tekun? A waiter and a train mechanic?

6. The random Dutch dance scene in the VIP carriage is completely out of place.

7. The subplot with a couple of thieves in the VIP carriage feels extremely disconnected.

8. If the train goes to resort, what business are belonged to those in economy? It is like a Noah Ark that bring anyone...

Everything about this film is disappointing.

As an indonesian myself, this was one of the few horror movies i was waiting for mainly because our group was going to deciding what movie to choose, and i saw this one which seemed very interesting... buuut they watched another one called "Munkar (2024)" and it seemed very bland and made by Anggy Umbara... no thanks, so i didn't watched the movie with them lol

Now since it was finally released in Netflix, i decided to check it out and... MANNN this really had a potential to be a fun gory movie :(((

The first problem i saw was the storyline, where we we're introduced to MANY characters that some i thought we're going to be important... but they weren't explored anymore and just used as a kill count later on

The first act i thought was fine enough (though there was a few cheap useless cliche jumpscares that had no build up, just BOOM a burned guy while the character is literally doing anything else but focusing on the ghost. Hoping the audience attention span won't fall asleep)

The best part of the movie was definitely the second act for me, when the carrieges started seperating i was really getting into it, and the two main characters drama was getting quite ok enough where i care for them, and then the action scenes keeps happening, what is happening and ohh so MANY bloody kill counts i must say that are VERY cool to watch...

Aaand the thing that really hurt the movie, was the third act... i can't really spoil it much but the entire act threevwas NOT in a train anymore and MAN it was really dissapointing with how it turned out. I will admit though the CGI for the third act looks very good for an indonesian which is GREAT for indonesia's industry where we can finally improve... but sadly that doesn't save with how dissapointed i was with the ending

I honestly really think that if they rewrote the entire act three to be still on the train, would be atleast make it more satisfying atleast.

I give this a 4.5/10, Now i get why people say Rizal Mantovani has questionable storylines in his movies, but the way he directs the kill counts is REALLY good though... sad it was almost forgotten by the horrible ending.

I've watched Kuyang before this and I think this one is way better. I like the story and thrills. It's a movie that I could watch twice without getting bored. I just hope there could be more resistance from the humans against the demon force not just like a prey and predator type of scene, but overall it was good for me. The start was intense then the filler parts was just fine. The ending was amazing. I hope scary movies from Indonesia would get better from here. I like the effects and how gory it is. Maybe we could do a part 2 where government send some spiritual forces to sort out the demons from the forest, but failed miserably igniting an Apocalypse.