Rating: (5.5/10)
Summary:
Untamed promises a tense, atmospheric crime thriller set against the stunning backdrop of Yosemite National Park - but ultimately stumbles under the weight of weak writing, cartoonish characters, and squandered potential. Despite a few solid performances, especially from Eric Bana and Sam Neill, the series never earns the emotional or narrative stakes it aims for.
Full Review:
I came into Untamed expecting something right in my wheelhouse: crime, mystery, drama, all set in the gorgeous expanse of Yosemite National Park. With Eric Bana back in a lead role, alongside Sam Neill and Rosemary DeWitt, I was hoping for something rich and layered. Unfortunately, the series just doesn't deliver. The first episode starts strong - two climbers stumble upon a body, setting off a chain of investigation - but from there, things unravel.
The characters often feel paper-thin or cartoonish. Bana's Carl Turner has almost no inner life, and his dynamic with Lily Santiago's sidekick character, Naya, is reduced to the same joke repeated endlessly. Rosemary DeWitt's ex-wife role feels shoehorned in, adding little beyond forced drama. Characters swing wildly in behavior from one scene to the next, and it's hard to get attached when motivations shift purely to create artificial tension.
As the investigation unfolds, major plot turns rely heavily on coincidence or characters just happening to talk to the right person by chance. A ridiculous example is a scene where someone falls down a mineshaft - instead of climbing back up (which visually, they clearly could), they panic and pretend to be stuck, generating fake suspense. And time after time, someone miraculously shows up to save the day. There's also the strange editing, which constantly bounces between face shots, wide shots, and quick cuts, undercutting emotional moments and making deep conversations feel weightless.
One of the most frustrating parts of Untamed is how the final episode handles the resolution - or rather, fumbles it. By episode five, the main mystery is essentially wrapped up, but instead of ending with a satisfying close, episode six feels like an unnecessary epilogue tacked on to stretch the runtime. Characters behave out of sync with how they've been written all series; there's a final twist that comes out of nowhere, feeling unearned because there were no earlier hints or layered performances to justify it. Even worse, a major character death happens with almost no consequence - no investigation, no fallout, just... silence. For a show supposedly rooted in grief, loss, and healing, this lands awkwardly flat. The final moments, meant to symbolize Carl moving on from his son Caleb's death, feel rushed and emotionally thin, because the series only ever sporadically engaged with that core trauma. Instead of a hard-hitting conclusion, we're left with a deflated, shrugging end to a story that had the potential to deliver much more.
The Yosemite setting, meanwhile, is a total missed opportunity. Instead of making the landscape feel like a character, as True Detective or The Revenant did so well, most of the show feels shot on obvious sets. Scenes meant to feel rugged or wild - like a camp of off-the-grid survivalists - come off staged and fake. Social commentary, like the treatment of Native American characters or addiction themes, is handled with the same clumsiness, bringing nothing fresh or thoughtful to the table.
In the end, Untamed isn't an outright disaster, but it's deeply frustrating. There's a version of this show that could have been thoughtful, moody, and emotionally sharp - but this isn't it. If you're just looking for background noise, it's passable. But if you were hoping for something with the atmosphere of Yellowstone or the layered grit of True Detective, you'll likely come away disappointed.
