Trois petits orphelins

While Three Orphan Kittens is undoubtably a good cartoon and is well worth watching, Who Killed Cock Robin? should probably have won and I think that in many ways The Calico Dragon is also better, although not by much. It was an excellent field and all three were worthy, but Three Orphan Kittens wasn't the best, at least to me. The title basically describes the cartoon. Certainly worth your time, this periodically appears on The Ink and Paint Club on The Disney Channel.

I really liked this silly symphony. I did think it had one or two dull spots, hence my rating, but you cannot deny it is a very cute and charming short. The animation is very very nice, and the snow scenes were in particular beautifully done. The three kittens were absolutely adorable, definitely the stars of the short, and the music is beautiful. There are some lovely scenes, the part when the kitten start playing about on the keys of the piano was my favourite. What I meant by one or two dull spots was that, the short does start off quite slowly. And it's not my favourite silly symphony of 1935, The Band Concert gets that honour.

Overall, very cute and worth a look. 9/10 Bethany Cox

I found Three Orphan Kittens purely by chance and wanted to check it out as I'm a huge cat- lover. It turned out to be every bit as gorgeous as I thought it would be. First of all, the kittens themselves are stunningly adorable and join my rankings of truly adorable characters alongside the kittens in Aristocats, Oliver (Oliver & Company), Bambi (Bambi), Dumbo (Dumbo), Lady (Lady & The Tramp), Banjo (Banjo The Woodpile Cat), Feivel (An American Tail), Winnie the Pooh, the title characters of PB&J Otter, and the main Land Before Time Cast (especially Petrie). Second, the animation both on the kittens and on the backgrounds has a nice innocent feel to it reminiscent of Beatrix Potter or Arnold Lobel (if you don't know either of those people you haven't had a childhood). Third, the music is sweet and mesmerizing, especially during the pie scene when the music 'spurts" in time to the squirting pie. All in all, a sweet, touching, simply precious little outing.

The 1930s often gave audiences cartoons chock full of happy singing animals and tons of cuteness. The edgier cartoons were mostly absent, though Disney's stock of reliable characters were awfully good. Today, these "sweet" cartoons are a pretty sad lot when you can compare them to the wonderful (and much more violent) cartoons of the 40s and 50s. However, making this comparison isn't 100% fair--this sort of cartoon was still waiting to be born.

For 1935, this cartoon is much better than average but I am frankly not particularly fond of it. My score of 7 represents it compared to the films of the day, though today I'd be hard pressed to give it a 4, as it's amazingly dull despite some very nice animation. The kittens bounce about the house and get into mischief--and this isn't enough to sustain a film. Speaking of animation, I loved the snow scenes--they were just so beautifully done. Ditto for the backgrounds. As for the three kittens, they actually were not as well animated as many of Disney's films of the day, but apparently the cuteness and the rest of the film was enough to propel it to the Oscar for Best Animated Short. Though, if you were to compare it to the other nominees that year, it is the best short. However, my nod would have been to award the Oscar to a more traditional Disney film--such as THE BAND CONCERT or MICKEY'S POLO TEAM.

By the way, you probably will notice that the film presents Black people as rather hard-hearted servants or as "pickaninny" dolls. Thank goodness times have changed.

It wasn't until I discovered this on YouTube that I finally saw this Walt Disney Silly Symphony cartoon. It has three kittens without a home wandering into a house with the black maid making her pie and singing her song. But she doesn't notice those cats in the home for awhile so those three felines get into some scrapes, that's for sure! I'll stop there and just say I found most of it quite entertaining despite some scenes that wouldn't go in these Politically Correct times. So that's a recommendation of Three Orphan Kittens. P.S. The print I saw was a Spanish-dubbed one so that was something fascinating to view and hear...