Zemeckis approaches a Hitchcockian style in 'What Lies Beneath'. The film itself is a sort of horror-chiller film. The story certainly is not original but while there is a ghost in the movie, Zemeckis also creates a very tense atmosphere relying purely on silence and simplistic sounds (like the wind blowing the door open etc) and cinematography. The camera-work is stupendous as it follows Michelle Pfeiffer (who is very much in every single shot). I particularly liked the shots in the house when the camera would move slowly (as though tiptoeing) with Pfeiffer's suspicious character.
Of course there are jump moments and twists which are usual in this genre but they're far from ridiculous. Some seem to be bothered with the Miranda Otto track arguing that it had little relevance to the main plot. However, this didn't bother me as much and it actually does make sense that Claire would believe her neighbour to be in trouble...(I'll refrain from giving out more spoilers).
Another high point of 'What Lies Beneath' is indeed Michelle Pfeiffer. I think this was her comeback film after she took a short break to take care of her children. From being a vulnerable housewife, who had been through an accident and is now lonely in the house since her daughter (with whom she was very close) moved to college campus and her husband works long hours, to a stronger woman who follows her instincts and discovers dark secrets that bring her to make difficult decisions, Pfeiffer's understated portrayal is amazing to say the least. I can't say much about Harrison Ford's role without hinting spoilers but he does a commendable job.
I enjoyed 'What Lies Beneath' much more during my second viewing than the first time (which was more than five years ago) but I think the main reason was that I was able to pay more attention to other parts of the movie other than just the story, such as the technical aspects (like camera-work and sound effects), and also see and enjoy the homage to so many classics (mostly Hitchcock's films). That is not to say that the story itself doesn't work. Quite the contrary because even though it's not exactly original, it is suspenseful and the events are well put together. 'What Lies Beneath' is an enjoyable chiller thriller with supernatural elements.
