Père Noël incognito

I really wanted to like this movie because I liked the sound of it, but I was a little disappointed.

The idea behind it was good. It was Christmassy but for some reason, I just didn't like it as much as I wanted to.

It was alright but I feel it could of been better.

Will I watch it again? Probably not.

I watched this as part of my 100 christmas movies before Christmas day challenge which made my total to 20.

A wealthy do-gooder with a wise butler who projects Christmas images in the sky, ala the Bat Signal, and a journalist, ala Lois Lane, who falls for his alias while unknowingly working to expose his true identity as the Secret Santa who has been amazing the citizens of Gotham, no, er um, Chicago. Less compelling story arc than the better Hallmark Christmas movies, and an overly earnest kid actor, but saved by good production values and enfaging performances by the leads and Patrick Duffy and Jacqueline Smith.

The casting works in this movie. Erin Cahill is pretty as a journalist and Jaclyn Smith looks believable as her mom. Kevin McGarry looks better and less goofy than in other Hallmark movies. Patrick Duffy plays helper to Secret Santa.

The story isn't the usual thing about a struggling business. There is a tycoon in disguise being Secret Santa. He secretly makes life better for her while pretending to be a journalist like her. A bit of a Prince in disguise type story.

It's nice to see the different things Secret Santa does. Watchable.

This is a story with some unique aspects. Secret Santa has been done. But it's not as overused as most of the stories we see this time of year. The get-a-promotion is a little overused, but not quite in this way. Leading the reporter to the true meaning of Christmas is also a little different. Hiding-a-secret and interrupted-before-I-tell-you are both overused, but hard to avoid in this story.

Erin Cahill is perfect for a character with Christmas spirit. I didn't feel like it was overdone, but the spirit seemed to flow out of her. Kevin McGarry does seem a little forced, but as a duo, these two do a nice job. Jaden Oehr is decent as the kid.

The competing reporters, especially with their debate over principles, is also a little unique. Unfortunately, I hated this aspect of the story. It would have worked much better if it was a little more subtle. The debate was part of the theme of the movie, but the cut-throat competition was overdone. The idealist romantic in me would have like the random-acts theme to be a little more pure, but the way this story is written, even the competition was necessary. But the resulting climax was forced due mostly to less than stellar acting by Hamza Fouad . The climax was still worth it all. When I say I would have like the competition to be a little more subtle, I don't mean completely eliminated, but just a little more subtle.

BTW: What happened to the black tie even Colin promised to be at? You may have noticed he was doing something else. There were a few other minor details that weren't cleaned up. Sydney left her car in traffic when she saw that early event where she met Cole/Colin, yet it didn't get towed. Later when decorating the house, she walks in to cook supper leaving a box of decorations literally in the middle of the porch in front of the door.

Really did like the premise for 'Random Acts of Christmas', seen as part of my Lifetime/Hallmark Christmas film completest sake that has been happening on and off for a while now, which sounded like something a little different from the usual Lifetime Christmas film formula. Lifetime's Christmas output is expectedly very variable, with some surprising hits, some duds and a lot of stuff somewhere in between. Have seen the leads in other things and with mixed success.

There is not an awful lot to add here reviewing 'Random Acts of Christmas'. It was pleasant and acceptable enough, with nothing offensive or out of the ordinary. As far as Lifetime's 2019 Christmas efforts go, 'Random Acts of Christmas' is somewhere in the middle and a film that started well but ran out of gas. The premise was very appealing but the film could have done quitwe a lot more with it, didn't think the potential was followed all the way through.

Good things outweigh the cons just about. It looks good in particularly the scenery. The music is pleasant and not intrusive, not always the case with Lifetime (even more Hallmark) films. The script is far from perfect, but is sweet in places and raised a number of smiles here and there. The story is likewise very flawed, but is very charming and warm-hearted for the first two thirds with an authentic atmosphere.

Most of the acting was good, with two immensely engaging leads as characters not hard to root for and Patrick Duffy being a standout. The chemistry between Erin Cahill and Kevin McGarry is sweet and natural.

Not all the performances work, especially Jaden Oehr over-compensating quite embarrassingly to the point that his character became hard to take. Also found Hamza Fouad annoying in the third act. Which is where the film goes downhill, where things become very contrived, ridiculous and rushed.

Complete with a cheesier ending to usual and at times being too sugary sweet. As said above, the film could have done a lot more with its relatable concept. It was very easy to relate to at first and there was a while where things didn't feel too predictable, later on the premise was given short shrift and the story became conventional Lifetime and very formulaic.

Overall, decent but not great with a good first two thirds but a pretty weak final one. 6/10