Il était une fois Noël à Castle Creek

Vanessa Lachey is feisty and charming as always and was a good match for Ryan McPartin. They both played pretty irritating characters at the beginning, but once they started to work together this was an amusing and romantic story which was actually quite touching at the end. They had one bad misunderstanding near the end which threatened to blow up all their hard-won progress. But lo and behold, they resolved it immediately with frank communication and a humble confession. Incredible. It was good to see Polly Draper again. She played a scary-crazy potter which added some tension and suspense. I wish she would be in more things. So far the beautiful Vanessa Lachey has proven adept at comedy and I have enjoyed her vehicles. Except one, but that wasn't her fault. I hope to see her star in more TV movies.

The arrogance of both Amelia and Vic was so strong that I could barely stand the first part of the movie. If I encountered either of these people acting like this, I would do anything to avoid them. One quarter of the movie led up to clumsily contrived premise - the two rivals being thrown together to organize the decoration of Main Street for the purpose of impressing Elder. And the ugly arguing continued well after that goal was established.

Was it funny? I actually laughed a few times when I wasn't cringing over all the meanness.

Then we meet the towns people. More arguing, arrogance and judgmentalism. We're about half way through the movie, and except for a few laughs inspired mostly by physical comedy, everything about it is a downer.

In most of these movies, all the animosity between the leads disappears suddenly and this movie is no exception. It's too bad they extended the negative so long. Finally, Vanessa Lachey and Ryan McPartlin can start to develop chemistry and they quickly do.

The story follows the usual lines and is predictable. The viewer can see the things that are coming as soon as they are set up. Even so I still needed some kleenex for at least one development. The conflict was predictable too, but a bit unusual as a plot device.

This was like two different movies envisioned by different people. I could easily FF through most of the first half, but the second half is worth the wait.

As far as Christmas movies go, this was just average. Typical storyline of two main characters not liking each other to them falling in love. We must have our happy endings, after all. The premise is they have to work together to decorate houses and a street for the annual contest. Vanessa Lachay wants to have a year round Christmas store. The winner of the grand prize will be able to fulfill his or her dream. I enjoyed watching this movie. It was entertaining enough, with even a couple of laughs. However, I wouldn't out it at the top of my list. It passed the time and somewhat predictable, as these movies are. It's worth watching once.

This was a decent Lifetime Christmas movie. Two people competing for the same property end up decorating some main street shops for a "Battle of the Main Street" Christmas competition with the neighbouring town. As they are forced to work together, the bickering between the two eventually turns into romance. The movie draws a bit on slapstick humour with several mishaps between the two leads (e.g., one of the leads falling on ice at the start of the film). I did laugh a little, at times. The first half of the film relied mostly on constant bickering and banter between the two leads, Amelia (played by Vanessa Lachey) and Vic (played by Ryan McPartlin). The dialogue here was pretty good. I was not turned off by it as some of the other reviewers on here were. At the same time, it was not as funny as the writers would have liked it to be, I suspect. There are some heartfelt messages in the film too (e.g., it is never too late to make amends with loved ones, especially during the holidays). There are some interesting (and at times, funny) characters in the film, again centred around bickering. The acting overall was good. Both Lachey and McPartlin (aka Captain Awesome, for the 'Chuck' fans reading this) had strong performances. The chemistry between the two was believable, as well. Though, as another reviewer on here suggested, it seemed a bit rushed, underdeveloped. The scenery, props, and sets were pretty good, festive. However, it was a bit strange not seeing many people on Main Street, the main shopping street in town. That felt strange, a bit odd. Overall, it is an entertaining Christmas movie, not one of the best I have seen this season, but certainly not one of the worse.

Actors play a good part in this 4 star rate, Ryan McPartlin is one of my fav B stars, and Vanessa Lachey is always cute and decent. Patrick Duffy is very old here, altough I love him in Step by step, but feel like this has been too much for him. Plot is too predictable, first rivals, then... I don't want to spoil it for you. I liked the bickering of main characters, it was fun. Setting could be beautiful, small town, cute houses, but director chose to over do it with fake snow. I mean, you could literally see fake snow cover blankets everywhere. Also, you get the feeling that this town has only 10 citizens. No people on the street, no people in the cafè... Very noticable. Also, one very confusing detail, the owner of cafè who is Indian, says, before, her grandmother was the owner of all year Christmas store. I mean, you could at least pick some other character to say that.