Annika

I don't know why there are so many bad reviews. Sure, it's not Unforgotten, but why remake something that was that good? This was different and amusing. I don't mind that she talks to the camera - I found it funny. It was as though I was listening to her thoughts, and could hear the things she's like to say but didn't because it would be impolitic. Nicola Walker is fantastic, as always, and I'll definitely watch the next episode.

Sometimes you don't need Big, Serious Drama. Sometimes you just need some police work with a large side of family dynamics and humour.

It took me an episode to get into this series. The draw was always Nicola Walker but the writer has her breaking the 4th wall (which is stage speak for talking directly to the audience) which I found off-putting at first, and the tone of the series is rather stripped down and sterile. But, the humour, the disarming frankness of our heroine, the relationship between mom and daughter, the episodic crimes and, of course, the brilliant work of Nicola, soon won me round. Inevitably, I found myself chuckling at the final one liners her character addresses to the camera as the episode ends. I give this series a 7 (good) out of 10. {Crime Dramedy}

Quirky, breaking the 4th wall murder mystery. Living in the US Rocky Mtns, I am fascinated by and enjoy this ocean-centered police procedural, and there is no shortage here. This show sits nicely between the silly type shows (Midsomer Murders) and dreary scary murder mysteries (like Walker's own Previous show).

Funny scenes, and I love to see Walker smile... it reveals the lovely woman that she is. Love watching her deal with her quirky team and the relationship with daughter which seems positive despite Annika being very much a parachute parent.

Con: Depending on mood or episodes I love and hate this show. The breaking of the fourth wall is interesting and description of the hx and literature of Scotland that parallels the theme of the episode is educational, but sometimes can be boring. Another issue is that Annika and others can often be so deadpan I can't tell if they are funny, sarcastic and/or deadpan even with closed captions. I have a friend that's sarcastic all the time, after a while it isn't cute...just super annoying.

Thank goodness for daughter, sweet, smart, and funny, not annoyingly disrupting parent' police work....as well as a few other supporting characters. However the psychologist boyfriend is super deadpan as well. One scene between the two (season two), after they get back together, is suppose to be cute and funny but it is excruciating. My brother was stationed in Scotland and I spent a month there. Scots are funny with beautiful lilting musical voices. My brother belonged to a fishing group and said they were funny as all heck. I don't see that here.

Truly don't get why this is being rated so low. OK, so a dead body in or around the water every week is perhaps a little unlikely, but some of the little quips and dialogue is both clever and witty. Nicola Walker is excellent, the brief monologues to camera are a brave and interesting way of linking things together. Perhaps people gave up on this too early or reality TV, Mrs Brown's Boys or Hawaii 5-0 is more their idea of quality entertainment? Haters have to hate I guess. Personally, I'm hoping a second series will be forthcoming.

I've read a lot of negative reviews, but I think the way it's done is fantastic. How to get to know a character? Have her talk directly to the camera, sharing her innermost thoughts and background. Unusual. Quirky. Whatever - I think it's brilliant.

I decided to watch it because I think Nicola Walker is an amazing actress. I'm staying with it, because I think it's a good show, like the cast, and the writing and the views.

No spoiler - just this - WOW, WHAT A WAY TO END THE FIRST SEASON!!

MORE PLEASE.............